We have roughly eight years remaining until the earth warms more than 1.5-degree Celsius, kicking the effects of the climate crisis into high gear. One might think that with widespread ecological devastation knocking at our doorstep, world leaders would be slightly more proactive about combating the effects of climate change. However, this year’s COP27 conference in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt proved to be an exemplify the ambivalence of many involved parties. Though some progress was made at the conference, very little direct action against fossil fuels and pollution was taken.

One possible reason why the participants at COP27 did not pledge to do much against fossil fuels was because many of them believe that fossil fuels are still viable. Rather than resolving to promote renewable energy sources or phase out nonrenewable ones, the final resolution at the climate conference pertaining to energy was to bolster “low emissions energy,” suggesting a continuation of usage for energy sources like oil and gas. If this is the case, then how did energy sources known to cause carbon emissions suddenly become “low-emission?” The answer lies in the budding technology of carbon capture and removal (CCR). CCR technology has been a controversial subject among climate experts because successful implementation of it would allow for people to use fossil fuels with little repercussions. Though this sounds nice at first, CCR quickly runs into a lot of issues, such as its expensive price tag and difficult process of implementation. However, none of these things have stopped the technology from being adopted as an effective method of greenwashing by many countries. Saudi Arabia, for instance, promoted CCR technology at its COP27, as its economy is based on petroleum extraction and trade. The U.S. also has a history of using support of CCR as a means of not directly supporting renewable energy, as the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 provided funding for CCR but not renewables. CCR was frequently discussed as a climate solution at COP27 due to its ability to preserve the current energy status quo, which took attention away from renewables.

The problems posed by CCR technology epitomize the largest challenge posed at COP27, this being that many parties on the international stage do not want the current status quo to change with regards to energy. Both China and Saudi Arabia offered significant resistance to more ambitious energy transition plans at the summit. Furthermore, many developing nations with prospects in fossil fuels joined the two larger countries in their objections. Despite lobbying efforts from Europe and the U.S., this conflict of interests ultimately stood in the way of any progress in the field of energy. However, some still remain optimistic, with COP27 president Sameh Shoukry calling the small progress made at the conference “the highest ambition that can be reached at this time.”

With all this in mind, it still cannot be said that COP27 was completely unproductive, as participants did come to one crucial point of action in the form of a fund for poorer countries affected by climate change. This is an important step for the U.N., as the effects of the climate crisis will almost certainly hit less wealthy countries harder than anyone else. Food shortages and drought, which will become more frequent as global temperatures increase, will require money to combat, which the fund can help provide. Furthermore, the COP27 climate fund is something that has been a long time coming, as the countries involved in the 2009 Copenhagen climate summit failed to provide the $100 billion that were then collectively pledged towards mending environmental damages in the global South. The fact that some action is being taken towards environmental justice is encouraging.

As hopeful as the progress made there might be, it cannot be said that COP27 was a success. The world is closer to crossing a threshold in the climate crisis, the passage of which will signal the dawn of an ecological holocaust across the globe. To mitigate a rise in global temperature and thereby avoid this catastrophe, decisive action is required. Through the events of the COP27 summit, the U.N. has demonstrated its inabikity to act a decisive manner. It can only be hoped that as we draw closer to passing the dreaded 1.5-degree mark, the urgency of the climate crisis will finally be realized by the powers that be.

By Sebastian Lemberger

Leave a Reply

Trending