Elon Musk continues to challenge the meaning of “free speech” in our modern society. After acquiring the social media network Twitter for $44 billion, Musk’s vision for an anti-progressive revamp of the platform sparked international controversy. He quickly laid off 3,700 workers—close to half of the previous staff—ended the company’s remote-work policy, and instilled drastic on-platform changes. The notorious blue “verification” check mark found across most online social media platforms was, now, on Twitter, available for purchase, for around two weeks, at the cost of $8 per month.
Musk immediately made his intention to revamp online dialogue on Twitter clear. In a statement posted by Musk, he stated that “Free speech is the bedrock of a functioning democracy, and Twitter is the digital town square where matters vital to the future of humanity are debated.” Musk’s comments liken Twitter to the Greek town square, where freethinkers, intellectuals, speakers, and sophists would engage in a intellectual combat. Musk, in this same vein, aims to build his dream town square around these storied ideals of free speech.
Revising, what Musk claims to be, Twitter’s oppressive social model is an ambitious task. Internet discourse has increasingly proved to be fodder for violence and vitriol in the real world. Consequently, a greater burden has been placed upon popular social media platforms to properly manage the millions of people that share the social space. Is there a way to build such a space that “bring[s] the world closer together” in the optimistic vision that Musk proposes?1 Musk’s vision will likely remain an overly optimistic fantasy for a multitude of reasons.
First, we need to think about what exactly Musk seems to be pitching to us consumers. Taking the town square metaphor seriously, we would hope that Musk aims to develop the digital world into a place that centers around functionality, open expression, freedom, and inclusion. What we aspire to have is a world where both public and private, digital and physical spaces are contained within an interconnected and happily coexisting ecosystem. What Musk proposes seemingly aims to fix the oppression and censorship that prevails across other digital spaces due to harassment and censorship. At the core of the issue is Musk’s ambitions to host the most effective, “free speech” digital platform on the internet.
Yet, the digital social environment far more complex than Musk may realize. His controversial choice to “un-ban” far-right voices, such as, Donald Trump, Kanye West, and Jordan Peterson seemed to emphasize his ambitions of a free functioning “townsquare.” What Musk indirectly demonstrated is a willingness to excuse the missteps that led to people, such as Donald Trump and Kanye West, being banned in the first place. West’s recent antisemetic and hateful remarks on the platform proved to be too much even for Musk, resulting in West being banned yet again. Whilst lawful, there is plenty of harm that can still be caused as a result of totally unchecked discourse. This may only be expedited by the increasingly polarized and divided tensions that run rampant across the world.
However, Musk may be right to point out that Twitter, among other social media networks, already fails “to adhere to free speech principles and fundamentally undermines democracy.” He is largely correct in saying this, as the public nature of our online personas have resulted in an immense weight on what we say and how we interact on the internet. Social media forces us to confront current events, as well as many diverse perspectives on a single issue, at an international scale.
It is the renewed purpose of the internet that has made it seemingly impossible to create a completely inclusive, healthy, and safe space for dialogue. Instead of approaching the internet with an openness of change, we are instead only inclined to engage with material we already agree with. Political tensions, global conflict and international struggle only inflate the growing animosity in our online interactions. Musk seems to disregard the hot water that he may be diving into. A more serious and global social change is required before effective, safe, and inclusive dialogue can even resemble the functioning democracy that Musk envisions. While the challenge is great, Musk’s ambitions stand true to encapsulate the turmoil that social media platforms, and free speech as a whole, face in an ever evolving modern-day society. Musk’s revisions to Twitter’s algorithm and mission have done nothing to directly confront the looming issue of extremism, division, and social tension that divides the global community. In its current state, Twitter has only bolstered the echo chambers that preserve perspectives, both right and wrong. At present, social media has, if anything, only further polarization which makes the ability effectively, inclusively, and healthily collaborate exceedingly challenging. We are left with deceptively simple resolutions: we need to learn to listen.
By Andrew Chinn





Leave a Reply