High Speed Rail has been on the rise lately as legislators around the world begin to consider it as a viable transportation option. When you compare it to other methods of transportation, including cars and planes, it stacks up quite well, or perhaps even better, due to its advantages in efficiency and cost.
According to the High Speed Rail Alliance, trains could be about triple the speed of driving, and at least a little bit faster than airplanes. As long as you aren’t traveling across an ocean, a train includes none of the rigamarole that planes do. There is no complicated bag-checking, security, slow boarding, taxiing on the runway, or takeoff and landing. Once you cut out all that time, trains are not only faster, but also include more “productive time” where you can actually work. Trains are also significantly cheaper, usually being about half the price of airplanes, since they don’t require a lot of additional expenses such as jet fuel, well-trained pilots, and the mechanical components that allow it to fly at 30-40 thousand feet. Moreover, high speed rail can also become an easy transportation method to get to the airport if you really need to go overseas.
In Europe, trains are rapidly becoming the preferred method of transportation for business people and tourists, largely because of campaigns by countries like France. These programs work to eliminate short flights and improve train accommodation by allowing companies to compete easier across international borders. When the French government bailed out Air France in April 2020, they also forced them to shut down their short-haul flights, reducing competition for the newly created high speed rail. A similar thing happened in Austria, where the flight between Salzburg and Vienna was shut down by the government in favor of a three hour train ride. As Alberto Mazzola, the executive director of the Community of European Railways and Infrastructure Companies, said “The idea is that for train trips of less than four hours, no business people will choose to fly, and for trips below six hours, normal people — tourists — will take the train”.
As the EU has been implementing new regulations on high speed rail, Spain has also recently adopted the transportation method. The new regulations , which went into effect in 2016, aim to make it easier for any company, no matter their nation of origin, to build, improve, and run high speed trains all over Europe. This change drove up competition in the market. A few companies, including Ouigo Espana, Renfe, Iryo,are heavily competing with each other on price, convenience, comfort, and services, which is very beneficial for the travelers.
One big proponent of high speed rail in the U.S is Rep Seth Moulton, who represents Andover in the House of Representatives. In 2021, Moulton released a bill that would put more than 200 billion federal dollars into a national high speed rail project. “High-speed rail is faster, cleaner, safer and better for our economy. It will connect people to more jobs in new places, give Americans freedom and choice in how they travel, and put us on par with the rest of the world. This bill is the plan that will get us there,” Moulton said.
Even with all the benefits in cost, efficiency, and convenience, perhaps the most important reason to choose high speed rail over aviation is its lower carbon footprint. Trains, when compared to planes and cars, emit significantly lower amounts of CO2 per person. However, not all trains emit the same amounts of Carbon Dioxide . Some trains run on diesel, while some are electric. If they are electric with the electricity sustainably sourced, some trains can have about half as much emissions per person as a diesel train. But even these diesel trains are still 2-3 times better than planes over the same distance, according to the BBC.
Not everyone loves high speed rail as much as Moulton, though. In California, a recent high speed rail project has been a disaster. The train, which aimed to connect Los Angeles and San Francisco, faced geographic challenges in the form of mountains. Due to political influences and awkward routing, the train has been years in the making and was astronomically expensive. If this system were successful, it would provide a much-needed alternative to the many highways (or freeways as they call them) that criss-cross California. The failure of this project has cast a lot of doubt among politicians on whether the government will be able to successfully put together an efficient and useful rail system in the future.
Even though high speed rail may have some flaws, as all relatively new technology does, it deserves to be considered more by lawmakers, especially in the U.S.. It’s better for the climate and it’s better for us, so what are we waiting for?
By Max Langhorst





Leave a Reply