Ani Bayramyan ’24
In his new Elon Musk biography, Walter Isaacson reveals that the tech giant and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk rejected Ukraine’s request for Starlink satellite support to attack the Russian fleet located in Crimea. According to the biography, Musk intentionally shut down the Starlink network near the port to prevent the Ukrainian attack. After CNN reported on this incident, Musk expressed his concerns on social media about being involved in a potential “major” act of war.
Musk shared on his social media platform, X (formerly known as Twitter), that he had no choice but to reject Ukraine’s request. “The obvious intent [of the request] being to sink most of the Russian fleet at anchor,” wrote Musk. “If I had agreed to their request, SpaceX would be explicitly complicit in a major act of war and conflict escalation.”
Following Russia’s 2014 invasion of the Crimean peninsula, the Russian Black Sea Fleet was positioned in Sevastopol. In the ongoing Russo-Ukrainian war, the Russian military strategically used the Sevastopol position to block Ukrainian ports. The fleet has fired cruise missiles at Ukrainian civilian targets, and in response, Kyiv’s Ukrainian military has launched attacks on Russian ships with maritime drones. However, the biography reveals that when Ukrainian explosive-laden submarine drones approached the Russian fleet last year, they “lost connectivity and washed ashore harmlessly.” The fleet continues to pose concerns for the Ukrainians.
Musk’s decision left Ukrainian officials pleading for him to turn the satellites back on. However, he was driven by a fear that Russia would respond to a Ukrainian attack with nuclear weapons, leading to a “mini-Pearl Harbor.”
Since the start of the war in 2022, SpaceX has been providing internet service to the Ukrainian government and military through private donations and a contract with a U.S. foreign aid agency. The Pentagon has recently revealed that SpaceX’s Starlink has a Department of Defense contract to purchase satellite services for Ukraine. A Pentagon spokesperson, though refusing to comment on Musk’s decision, maintained that the Department works closely with commercial industry to ensure that the Ukrainians have the necessary capabilities to defend themselves.
It is clear that Musk’s decision not to allow Ukraine to use Starlink internet service for a surprise attack on Russian forces in Crimea has played a significant role in obstructing Ukrainian defense abilities. However, questions have also been raised about whether future contracts need to be more explicit about using purchased services or products in war. The Pentagon relies on SpaceX for more than just the Ukraine response, and the uncertainty that commercial vendors could refuse to provide services in a future conflict has led military planners to reconsider negotiating future agreements as the U.S. military investment in space technology increases. Musks’s decision has also raised concerns around other aspects of US commercial vendor contracts, specifically related to commercial vendor liability in mishap launches and potential obligations of the US government to defend commercial vendor assets.
While the controversy will continue to concern the Pentagon officials’ contracts with commercial vendors, Musk’s decision has also placed more stress on a war-torn country desperate for military support.




Leave a Reply