Michell Fang ’24
WASHINGTON, D.C.: Last Tuesday, September 12, 2023, Speaker of the House of Representatives, Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), made the surprise announcement that he had requested an impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden.
“Today, I am directing our House committee to open a formal impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden,” McCarthy stated at the U.S. Capitol, not allowing further questions. Although Speaker McCarthy had previously communicated that he would decide on that issue based on a full House vote, McCarthy is not expected to hold the Constitutionally-sanctioned full House vote. McCarthy stated that the inquiry would investigate President Biden’s alleged involvement in his son Hunter Biden’s business affairs.
Hunter Biden is a lawyer and businessman who has worked in various industries, including technology and consulting. He is known for his involvement with various investment firms and private equity companies. There have been allegations and controversies surrounding Hunter Biden’s business activities, particularly his work with foreign companies and governments. Some of these allegations include his role on the board of Burisma Holdings, a Ukrainian natural gas company, while his father, Joe Biden, was Vice President of the United States. There were allegations of potential conflicts of interest, though Hunter Biden denied any wrongdoing. A source familiar with the matter told Time Magazine that the investigation would focus on whether the Biden family illicitly used their connections to President Joe Biden to enrich themselves.
McCarthy said these allegations “paint a picture of a culture of corruption [in the Biden family].” He added that President Biden “did lie to the American people about his knowledge of his family’s foreign business dealings,” and said he had witnessed this. However, House Republicans have yet to produce evidence of wrongdoing by President Biden.
An impeachment inquiry is the first step toward the impeachment process. Under the Constitution, the House may charge the president or any other federal official with treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors via the impeachment process. To begin this process, a House lawmaker submits a resolution that directs the House Judiciary Committee to investigate an officer. Any member of the House can request an impeachment proceeding. However, the Speaker of the House decides whether to grant a request for House impeachment resolutions. If such a resolution passes with a majority vote, House managers present the case against the official in a Senate trial. At the end of the trial, the Senate must have a two-thirds majority vote to remove the official from office. White House officials, having sensed the impending inquiry, have already prepared lawyers, legislative, aides, and communications staffers to defend the president. In response, House Democrats released a 14-page memo on Monday, September 11, detailing the “overwhelming failure” of the GOP investigation into President Biden.
Following Speaker McCarthy’s announcement, Abbe Lowell, a lawyer defending Hunter Biden described Speaker McCarthy’s effort as an “impeachment-first, reason-second process based on repackaged, inaccurate conspiracies.” For months, House Republicans have been investigating ties Biden may have in his son’s business dealings, but could not find any evidence to implicate this. During the August recess, Speaker Speaker McCarthy said, “I do not make this decision lightly,” adding, “Regardless of your party, or who you voted for, these facts concern all Americans.” Still, there has been no legitimate evidence released to support these suspicions throughout the House Republicans’ nine-month investigation of President Biden’s alleged ties. White House spokesperson Ian Sams took to X to bash Speaker McCarthy’s request, tweeting “House Republicans have been investigating the president for 9 months, and they’ve turned up no evidence of wrongdoing.” Those who agree with Speaker McCarthy’s request largely cite that the public has a right to the truth regardless of concrete evidence. “An inquiry is an inquiry, it’s not an impeachment,” said Sen. Chuck Grassley, who has been investigating Hunter Biden’s business dealings for years. “And it seems to me it will open up an avenue to get a lot of information that we feel we’ve been stonewalled.”
Another reason Speaker McCarthy submitted an impeachment inquiry may be to appease the hard right. This impeachment inquiry comes as Speaker McCarthy staves off possible revolts from conservative hard-liners and an imminent government shutdown. Around a year ago, Speaker McCarthy agreed to a long list of conservative demands, including the ability to call a vote to vacate the chair from office. Now, Speaker McCarthy’s right flank is pushing him to the Speaker’s office. An inability to reach these demands may result in an abrupt ouster. Furthermore, Congress currently has until the end of September to prevent a potentially devastating federal shutdown. Powered by an increasingly hard-right faction in Congress, it is becoming increasingly difficult for things to go smoothly in Washington. Speaker McCarthy has already been struggling to pass a spending bill needed to avoid a government shutdown by the end of the month. Republicans have also been criticizing him for not sticking to the promises he made at the beginning of the year during his marathon leadership race. On top of spearheading both a formal impeachment inquiry and a necessary spending bill, Speaker McCarthy also has the responsibility of supporting Ukraine in the “Russo-Ukrainian War.” Amid these challenges, Speaker McCarthy’s impeachment inquiry of President Biden fulfills a previous promise he made to the hard right.
Any impeachment effort would most likely be rejected by the Democratic-controlled Senate. On Tuesday, Senate Major Leader Chuck Schumer criticized the impeachment inquiry, “I have sympathy with Speaker Speaker McCarthy,” Schumer said. “He’s in a difficult position. But sometimes you got to tell these people who are way off the deep end, who have no interest in helping the American people, who just want to pursue their own witch hunts—that they can’t go forward.” In order to preserve his chances for reelection, Speaker McCarthy must balance these GOP demands while mitigating an approaching government shutdown. Amid these challenges, the futures for Speaker McCarthy, the federal government, and President Biden’s impeachment inquiry are increasingly unclear. Only time will tell.





Leave a Reply