Cate Cummings ’26

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused significant public health damage to our society. Now, the time for us to reflect on our experiences in dealing with this unprecedented pandemic in order to establish future evidence-based government policies to protect public health and beyond.

“I think we would’ve done everything differently,”  California Governor Gavin Newsom said in his recent interview with NBC, acknowledging the criticism of California’s tough COVID-19 restrictions. “We’re all geniuses now,” he added in hindsight on public health measures and government approaches to the pandemic. Newsom’s words invite a collective reflection on the lessons we have learned from COVID-19 pandemic responses, which will enable us to promote public health while minimizing undesirable social and economic consequences. 

First, public health agencies should develop a targeted approach to protect citizens and communities from diseases. On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared COVID-19 a pandemic after more than 118,000 cases in 114 countries and 4,291 deaths were reported globally. By July 7, 2020, the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases in the U.S. surpassed 3 million. According to the WHO, 6,958,499 deaths were reported since the start of COVID-19. Over time, we have learned that the mortality rate of COVID-19 differs greatly between the old and young. Developing necessary measures and placing more resources on protecting the vulnerable population should be the top priority. Public health agencies must conduct ongoing risk and benefit evaluations to deliver targeted interventions. For example, intervention strategies could include frequent testing, vaccination, additional funding to the nursing and long-term facilities, as well as social and institutional support for elderly living alone to prioritize the high-risk groups. Recently, vaccination recommendations began to reflect this nuanced approach to public health. For example, WHO and European countries such as the United Kingdom, Sweden, Germany, Norway, and Finland recommend booster vaccinations only for those at highest risk. Regarding vaccinating healthy young people, the WHO stated, “Although additional boosters are safe for this group, we do not routinely recommend them, given the comparatively low public health returns.” 

Second, evidence-based decision-making should be the cornerstone of government policies concerning public health. As infectious and threatening as the original strain of COVID-19 virus – “Wuhan-Hu-1”, our understanding of this virus is evolving. We have learned that the death rate of COVID-19 is diminishing as the virus takes on a milder form through its natural evolutionary pathways as new variants replace older ones. Consequently, the need for hospitalization and intensive care has been reduced significantly. The timely invention of the mRNA COVID vaccine further reduces the chance of severe illness—placebo-controlled studies have shown an efficacy of higher than 90 percent. At the same time, we have also realized that a seemingly perfect medical intervention does not stop virus transmission, contrary to the initial prediction of public health agencies. As the shadow of doubt about reaching herd immunity through vaccination grew thicker, recent studies have enlightened us with the finding that natural immunity produces cellular immunity that can be as effective as that achieved through vaccination. Furthermore, a recent comprehensive study has concluded, “Wearing masks in the community probably makes little or no difference…compared to not wearing masks.” These new research findings, however, are not adequately incorporated into the current public health mitigation policies. For example, the CDC still recommends that children ages two years and older “wear masks or respirators to protect themselves and others from COVID-19”. Some institutions, such as Kaiser Permanente, Lionsgate, Upstate Medical University, and Morris Brown College, reinstated mask mandates amid a recent uptick in COVID-19 cases. In addition, the FDA’s approval of the fall boosters is based on limited evidence – 10 mice data from Pfizer and a randomized trial of 50 people from Moderna. In terms of fall booster recommendations, added benefits for healthy groups may not justify society’s resources being used because “…there is no clear evidence that the healthy groups, especially with existing immunities, are at risk of serious illness,” said Dr. Paul Offit, an FDA vaccine Advisor.

Third, government policies should consider potential collateral damages when crafting and implementing responses to curb the pandemic and protect public health. In response to the uncontrollable spread of the novel COVID-19 virus, China quickly announced a lockdown measure in Wuhan, a city of 11 million people, where the virus was first detected. Soon after, the United States and many other countries also implemented lockdown measures to control its spread on a global scale. The largest school system in the U.S. – the New York City public school system— shut down, later followed by other public school systems because children were believed to be “…vectors of COVID-19 and emerging variant”. Together, these strict measures produced unintended and devastating social and economic consequences. Delayed medical treatment, deteriorating mental health, small business closures, and global inflation are just a few to mention. The World Bank predicted that COVID-19 could plunge the global economy into the worst recession since World War II. Between 2020 and 2022, millions worldwide suffered from food insecurity and loss of education or employment. In the U.S., 45% of mothers had to stay home to attend to their children, disproportionately affecting women of color. There was a 91% increase in chronic absenteeism in public schools between the 2018-2019 and 2021-2022 school years, and the significant loss in students’ learning and development is immoral. Such negative consequences are likely to affect our society for years to come. 

In hindsight, we are all geniuses now. At the same time, we must remember and honor the servitude that our government and public agencies have demonstrated in this unprecedented time. They have strived to mitigate risks and protect citizens from harm under extreme uncertainty. When the next pandemic arrives, which is inevitable in human history, we have gained additional wisdom in attenuating it, through our unfolding collective reflection today. 

Leave a Reply

Trending