Katerina Browder ’26

One-Line Summary: China, Russia, Iran, and Jordan have all declared their support of Palestine.

On October 7, 2023, thousands of Hamas terrorists launched a brutal surprise attack on Israel by air, sea, and land, brutally murdering 1,400 Israeli citizens and taking 203 hostages for detainment in Gaza. In retaliation, Israel has vowed to “destroy Hamas” by responding with airstrikes along the Gaza strip, which have killed 8,000 people and left 350,000 people displaced.1 They have begun to deprive Gaza of food, water, and fuel and are assembling thousands of troops for an upcoming invasion. The conflict between Israel and Palestine has existed for hundreds of years, but this recent conflict has prompted numerous nations worldwide to declare their support for either Israel or Palestine publically.

Of particular note is Russia’s stance in favor of Palestine. The Russian U.N. ambassador, Vassily Nebenzia, delivered a speech blaming the United States for the “looming war” and condemning Israeli attacks against Palestinian civilians. Notably, this speech omitted any reference to the terrorist organization Hamas. Nebenzia also argued for pro-Palestinian peace negotiations and a sovereign Palestinian state, stating that  “the Security Council must act to put an end to the bloodshed and restart peace negotiations with a view to establishing a Palestinian state as it was supposed to do so long ago.” Russia’s support for Palestine appears to be influenced by multiple factors, including their foreign policy objective of diverting global attention from the ongoing war in Ukraine. Indeed, as the conflict between Hamas and Israel rages on, the world’s news headlines have, for the most part, excluded Ukraine. 

Additionally, the U.S. military has begun to transfer military support originally intended for Ukraine to Israel, including tens of thousands of 155mm artillery shells from emergency stocks.2 Meanwhile, within Russia, officials have leaked fake propaganda that accuses Ukraine of arming Hamas while being disguised as a fake BBC report.3 Russia is supporting Hamas diplomatically while simultaneously continuing a violent conflict in Ukraine with the world distracted.

Similarly, the Chinese government has publicly supported Palestine after President Xi Jinping argued for the establishment of a sovereign Palestinian government through a two-state solution. Such, according to Xi, is the “fundamental way out,” of the conflict.4 He believes this will prevent the conflict from spreading and causing a severe humanitarian crisis. This view is consistent with Beijing’s stance on issues relating to Palestine since 1997. Similar to Russia, China has failed to condemn Hamas’ attacks publicly, but as Israel retaliates with airstrikes, Beijing has toughened its criticisms of Israel. Interestingly, China’s envoy to the Middle East, Zhai Jun, met with Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Mikhail Bogdanov in Qatar and said Beijing is willing to “maintain communication and coordination” with Moscow to de-escalate the situation. The Russian and Chinese collaboration and the statement by Jun that says, “China and Russia have the same position on the Palestine question,” suggests that both countries share the same message: Israel is in the wrong.

The Arab countries bordering Palestine and Israel have exhibited varying motivations for their stances. In particular, Jordan, although supportive of Palestine, maintains a cautious position on the matter. The Jordanian King Abdullah II warned US Secretary of State Tony Blinken against Israeli attempts to “forcibly displace Palestinians from all Palestinian territories or cause their internal displacement.”5 This approach stems from concerns that escalating conflict and tension in the West Bank could cause a large influx of Palestinian refugees into Jordan, and Jordan lacks the adequate resources and capacity to accommodate refugees. Moreover, Foreign Minister Ayman Safadi expressed concerns that the ongoing conflict could ignite widespread violence and potentially spill across regional borders as already there have been missile strikes from Yemen, killings in the West Bank, and attacks in Syria.6 However, the public view differs significantly from the government’s standpoint. On October 18, thousands of young demonstrators took to the streets near the Israeli embassy, chanting various slogans in support of Hamas. Their demands included the expulsion of the Israeli ambassador and the closure of the embassy.7

The leadership of Iran, on the other hand, has explicitly applauded the Hamas attack on Israel. Tehran has praised the damage being inflicted on Israel, and the state news media has highlighted Iran’s role in providing weapons and artillery to help Hamas destroy Israeli communities. Iran has long been supporting Hamas militarily through the design and production of a domestic missile and rocket system. Some believe that a tight circle of leaders from Iran, Hezbollah and Hamas had been coordinating the October 7th attack long in advance. However, Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has denied any involvement in the attack even whilst publicly praising the carnage, stating that “[Iran] kisses the foreheads and arms of the resourceful and intelligent designers.” Despite governmental support for Palestine, many citizens in Iran do not see the Palestinian struggle as their fight and are opposed to the government’s funding of proxy militant groups around the Middle East.8

Notes:

Leave a Reply

Trending