Stella Seong ’27

One-Line Summary: On October 18th, 2023, protestors from Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow took to Capitol Hill to call for a cease-fire in the Israel-Hamas conflict in support of the Palestinian people. 

Due to the recent developments following the Hamas surprise attack on October 7th and the subsequent Israeli siege on Gaza, the complex history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been heightened. People around the world have initiated support for a side. In the U.S., clashing opinions rooted in an individual’s history and values with the circumstances have triggered an uproar. U.S. citizens have exercised the right to protest, and the two groups, Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow, have held demonstrations regarding this situation.

On October 18th, 2023, two Jewish peace activist groups, Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow, organized a demonstration of thousands of Jews and allies in front of Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C..1 Protestors held up signs that read “Ceasefire” and “Let Gaza Live.” Hundreds of demonstrators entered the Cannon House Office Building and sat on the floor clapping and singing. The U.S. Capitol Police warned protestors to leave the building, subsequently leading to around 300 arrests on the spot. The number of detained demonstrators now nears 400 following processing over the last few days.2 

The two groups organized the protest in response to Israel’s bombing campaign on the Gaza Strip that erupted following Hamas’ surprise attack. The Gaza Strip has become the location of a humanitarian and moral crisis. Almost 5,000 Palestinians have been killed as of October 25th, and millions more have been displaced. Jewish-American communities that are a part of these activist groups have expressed their outrage by showing support for an immediate ceasefire and calling for President Joe Biden to cut off funding to Israel.3

Jewish Voice for Peace was founded in 1996 and has 440,000 members across 30 states. IfNotNow began in 2014 and has tens of thousands of members. The core value of both groups is to bring safety to Palestine and end the decade-long occupation. “The work of our movements over the past nine years and decades of work by our predecessors has been preparing all of us to meet this horrific, genocidal moment,” Eva Borgwardt, political director of IfNotNow, stated.4 

However, the Jewish identity of these groups creates an added layer of complexity. Borgwardt stresses that Jews must realize that the language used to discriminate against Palestinians by the Israeli Prime Minister is reminiscent of the language used during the holocaust. “As Jewish people…, when we hear Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Yoav Gallant use words like ‘the children of darkness’… we feel the resonances of that in our bones,” stated Borgwardt. Borgwardt believes it is essential for Jewish Americans to use the slogan ‘Never Again,’ to stress that the situation in Palestine is dangerously approaching a reflection of the genocide of Jews during World War II.5 

However, this demonstration of allyship between Jewish Americans and Palestinians has put the two activist groups in conflict with their allies within the U.S. The Anti-Defamation League (ADL), a pro-Israel group that has worked with Jewish Voices for Peace in the past, has called the protestors “far-left radical[s]” and “anti-Zionists that challenge Israel’s very right to exist” in a public statement.6 Rabbi Alissa Wise, a council member of Jewish Voice for Peace, disagrees with the views mentioned above and considers herself separate from Zionism despite being Jewish. “I reject the idea that critiquing the politics of a government is antisemitic. Israel is not a Jew, Israel is a state,” Wise stated.7 

With the ADL and Jewish Voice for Peace taking opposing sides in the conflict following the capitol protests, a rift has been created in the Jewish-American community. Both the ADL and Jewish Voice for Peace hold influence with the opinions they disclose. Consequently, many Jewish Americans are starting to side with one group’s ideas and dispute with the other. Some Jewish Americans agree with the ADL and support Israel as it is a land with great historical significance in Jewish belief. However, others support the ideas that fueled the capitol protests and wish to separate their identity as Jews from Israel as a state. 

The Israel-Hamas conflict continues to rage on across the world. In the Gaza Strip, the World Health Organization warns that hospitals are running out of supplies in the wake of daily bombings and airstrikes.8 In the coming weeks, group protests will continue as people speak up about their opinions. The Capitol demonstrations stimulated student organizations to hold similar protests on University campuses across the nation, sometimes resulting in potential campus violence.9 As Brant Rosen, a rabbi from Los Angeles, stated to demonstrators in Capitol Hill, regardless of background or belief, we are witnessing “one of the most consequential moral moments that any of us will experience in our lifetime.”10

Notes:

Leave a Reply

Trending