Max Langhorst ’25

As the struggle between Israel and Hamas has escalated over the past few weeks, the conflict has been a controversial subject in the corporate world. Major companies have taken a variety of approaches to public statements regarding the matter in the Holy Land: releasing no statement, defending one side, or broadly supporting civilians in both Israel and Gaza. Given the historical complexity of Israel-Palestine relations and the outspoken public figures on both sides,  corporations are walking a thin line between two extremes. While a large swath of the corporate world has issued statements of some kind, they vary widely in terms of their specificity and support. 

Many large companies have expressed condolences for those affected by promoting peace and, when necessary, explaining plans to evacuate. Amazon CEO Andy Jassy said on Twitter, “The attacks against civilians in Israel are shocking and painful to watch. I have been in touch with our teammates there to make sure we do everything we can to help support their families and their safety, and to assist however we can in this very difficult time. We’re also in close contact with our humanitarian relief partners on the ground and will be supporting their efforts. Hoping that peace arrives as soon as possible.”1

Instead of taking a particular side, Jassy expressed sadness and promoted peace, neither of which would seem particularly controversial. However, even a statement like Jassy’s still draws criticism from those who feel taking sides is necessary. Additionally, especially in Western corporations, Arab employees sometimes feel scared to speak out for fear of losing their jobs, which has happened in some cases. As for Amazon, one anonymous Arab employee said, “A lot of us are dealing with harassment…[Arabs in the company] are scared to speak out.”2

It is important to make the distinction here between Hamas and Gaza: Hamas is a terrorist organization while Gaza is a region controlled by Israel made up of Palestinians, who are without a country. As Israel continues to escalate the war with air strikes and a possible ground invasion, it has become difficult to advocate for the humanitarian rights of Palestinians unconnected with Hamas without being called pro-terrorist or against Israel. There are plenty of Palestinians in Gaza who are not involved at all with Hamas, and they are suffering as much, or in some cases, more than Hamas.3 Advocating for these innocent people is further complicated by Hamas’s clear tactic to use them as human shields by preventing their evacuation.4

Other companies have decided not to release statements. This option has also faced backlash, primarily from those saying something along the lines of “doing nothing is complicit.” This is a very slippery slope for corporations, and they have had to face these situations more and more in recent years as they face public pressure to issue statements on a wide variety of cultural and geopolitical topics. Until this month, it has been becoming increasingly common for companies to release such statements, but there seems to have been a shift around the Israel-Hamas War: “Clients were asking us what they should say [about the Russia-Ukraine War], where and when,” said Dominic Reynolds, who works at a public relations company,  “This week, they’ve been asking if they should say anything at all.”5 This new war between Israel and Hamas is more complex than others because of the immense history of violence on both sides and the shared space between innocent civilians and an anti-Israel terror group, Hamas. 

One particular company whose response has been particularly interesting is Starbucks and its newly established union, Workers United. Workers United issued a since-deleted statement on X, saying “Solidarity with Palestine,” but this is not incredibly nuanced and is controversial, especially in the West. Additional statements from individual employees also supported Palestine.6 Starbucks quickly moved to condemn both these statements and Hamas’ attack on Israel.7 

Overall, the many different reactions from the corporate space serve to illustrate the immense social and cultural complexity of the Israel-Hamas War and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as a whole. 

Notes:

  1. https://twitter.com/ajassy/status/1711575743803933139 ↩︎
  2. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/10/22/google-amazon-meta-gaza-israel-contracts/ ↩︎
  3. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/27/world/middleeast/palestine-gazans-hamas-food.html#:~:text=Hamas%20has%20spent%20years%20stockpiling,has%20carved%20out%20under%20Gaza.&text=As%20supplies%20of%20virtually%20every,remains%20well%2Dstocked%3A%20Hamas. ↩︎
  4. https://www.timesofisrael.com/idf-gaza-resident-says-hamas-preventing-evacuations-thousands-return-north/ ↩︎
  5. https://www.ft.com/content/80bd2644-b810-4d6e-8a9c-d4a08432d9e4 ↩︎
  6. https://nypost.com/2023/10/12/starbucks-workers-union-voices-solidarity-with-palestine/ ↩︎
  7. https://one.starbucks.com/get-the-facts/workers-united-does-not-speak-for-starbucks/ ↩︎

Leave a Reply

Trending