Max Langhorst ’25

One-Line Summary: Political polarization is preventing us from solving immigration.

One thing that average Americans and politicians on both sides of the aisle seem to agree on is that the United States immigration system is overwhelmed and broken. 75% of respondents to a recent CBS poll said the situation at the border was “a crisis” or a “serious problem,” and 70% of people disapprove of how Joe Biden handles it. The statistic is higher than Biden’s disapproval rating on inflation, the Israel-Hamas conflict, and the economy.1  In this article, I seek to reveal the political polarization that is preventing the implementation of an immigration solution, and lay out a possible solution. 

Entering the 2024 elections, Republicans are turning immigration into one of their top issues, with 60 Republicans in the house visiting the border to pressure Biden on immigration last week.2 Donald Trump, the GOP frontrunner, has continued to use anti-immigrant rhetoric as a very successful scare tactic in his 2024 campaign. At a rally in Iowa in December, he said that immigrants were “poisoning the blood of our country,” rhetoric eerily reminiscent of Hitler’s Mein Kampf, where he writes, “All great cultures of the past perished only because the originally creative race died out from blood poisoning”. To be clear, I am not equating Hitler with Trump; however it should be noted that this xenophobic rhetoric has been invoked throughout history.3 4Almost half of Americans responding to a CBS poll said they agreed with Trump’s blood-poisoning rhetoric.5 According to Charles Chamberlain, “[Racist attacks are] how [Trump] started his campaign. Then over the last four years all we’ve seen is more and more of that. … I wouldn’t call it a pattern, I would call it the foundation of the Trump presidency.”

Notably, Democrats have been calling for immigration action from Biden as well. Mayors, like Mike Johnston of Denver and Eric Adams of New York, have called the situation at the border a crisis and have increasingly pressured President Biden to do something about the incredible amount of migrants surging into their cities.6 In Massachusetts, the existing shelter system is at its breaking point; according to state reporting, maintaining it is going to cost $2 billion in the next two years.7 What’s causing this surge in northern migration? By and large, it is the migrant-packed buses and planes sent by Governor Greg Abbot of Texas. He has been attacked for using human beings as props, but his political stunt is working: as northern cities struggle to accommodate migrants, they are turning immigration into an even bigger problem for President Biden.8 

In my opinion, the consensus opinion is correct: our immigration system is defective and in need of serious change. However, it is not some impossibly massive issue that cannot be solved. Quite the opposite, in fact. A substantial increase in funding for border facilities, agents, review officers, and judges, combined with a more secure border, would go a long way to alleviating the growing issue that is immigration.9 Many would agree that the ideal immigration policy is a high wall and a wide gate. That is, there are lower numbers of illegal crossings but higher numbers of legal ones. We need to continue allowing hardworking immigrants into the country to stem population decline, provide cheap labor for many of America’s industries, and maintain our spot as the premier place for the absolute best intellectuals to come to further their careers. The latter is an often overlooked part of why we must be seen as a pro-immigrant country. Our continued success as a nation requires that we be top-notch in high-skill industries, and immigrants are a big part of that. Right now, almost 40% of software developers and 30% of physical scientists are immigrants.10 However, illegal entries cause problems for everybody. They cause problems for the migrants, who often have to take great risks in their crossings. Over 500 migrants died crossing the border last year, and many families were separated.111213 It also causes problems for businesses and communities, as illegal immigrants can lower wages, usually because employers can get away with underpaying them.1415 But you don’t just have to take it from me; take it from Barack Obama in a 2008 speech: “Passions may fly on immigration, but I don’t know anyone who benefits when a mother is separated from her infant child or an employer undercuts American wages by hiring illegal workers.” In the long term, we need to reduce the flow to the border, which means investment in the countries sending migrants and new or expanded ways to apply for asylum without entering America. Therefore, what needs to happen is something that neither political party seems to be proposing: funding for the high wall, for the wide gate, and for the countries sending migrants in the first place. 

Sadly, the potential steps I have just laid out (broad as they may be) are not being implemented or advocated for by either political side. Democrats are so afraid of sounding like Trump that they’ve stopped recognizing the legitimate problems caused by illegal immigrants, and Republicans have embraced Trump and his authoritarian, illogical, cruel, and disingenuous immigration ideas. 

As the age of Trump has progressed in American politics, Democrats have moved further and further from a moderate immigration stance. We are not hearing anything similar to the perspective expressed by Obama. Trump’s immigration ideas have rightfully repulsed Democrats, but they have swung too far back the other way. In recent years, Democrats and Republicans have been drifting away from each other on how positively or negatively they speak about immigrants, at least according to an analysis of their speeches.16 The analysis, which looked at 200,000 US congressional speeches and 5,000 presidential communications with humans and machine learning, showed that while rhetoric on immigration is relatively positive right now, the difference between the speeches of Democrats and Republicans has been growing for the past few years. 

Republicans, especially Trump, are even worse. They have been promoting xenophobic, racist, and inaccurate fear-mongering for years at this point. One example is the way they discuss the relationship between illegal drugs, such as fentanyl, and the migrants coming over the border. They paint the image of  migrants carrying bags of fentanyl on their backs as they sneak over the completely unprotected border: “When Mexico sends its people […] They’re bringing drugs.”17 When told his claim was not backed up by evidence, Trump just doubles down: “Democrats, they say ‘It all comes through the ports of entry.’ Wrong, it’s wrong. It’s just a lie. …They say, ‘Walls don’t work.’ Walls work 100%.”18 In fact, Trump is the one who is wrong here. Only 12% of fentanyl seizures occurred between ports of entry, according to the DEA’s National Drug Threat Assessment.19 The source of drugs is not the migrants coming across the border illegally or applying for asylum; it’s the cartels smuggling drugs through points of entry. Trump (and many other MAGA Republicans) posit that the solution to these serious problems is building a massive border wall, increasing border security, and massively decreasing the number of immigrants we allow into our country. A wall is a horrible idea that would have previously been considered radical. As previously discussed, immigrants are essential to our country’s survival. 

Even though realistic and comprehensive solutions to our border crisis do exist, we (and our politicians as a result) are handicapped by our increasing polarization. We need to take a more moderate stance on immigration: one that considers the perspectives of everyone involved and one that is humane, good for both Americans and migrants and free from political chaos. 

Leave a Reply

Trending