Luke Fernandez Suarez ’25

One-Line Summary: Examining the history of Argentina’s economic situation.

There is an old saying in economics: “Throughout history, there have been only four kinds of economies in the world: advanced, developing, Japan, and Argentina.” 

The South American nation is at a turning point. It is faced with two options: to continue down its path of decay and poverty or to try something completely different. For decades, the Latin American nation has experienced cycles of stagnation, hyperinflation, and violence, which, combined, amount to one of the worst economies in the world. The question to ask is how Argentina got here, and secondly, what is the plan to get it out? 

At the turn of the 20th century, Argentina was one of the ten wealthiest economies in the world. It was experiencing large-scale immigration, and the nation’s capital, Buenos Aires, was known as the Paris of South America. During this time, the average Argentine was four times wealthier than the average citizen of their larger neighbor, Brazil, and had a per capita average income 50 percent greater than Italy. This statistic was impressive, especially considering that only 40 years before, Argentina had endured an almost four-decade civil war and had almost no industry or modern transportation to speak of. By 1913, Argentina had one of the most intricate and elaborate railroad systems in the world, with nearly 21,000 miles of railroad track in its nation. By the time the world entered the First World War, Argentina was experiencing annual GDP growth of 6 percent, the fastest of any other country. The increase was largely thanks to liberal economic policies expressed in the country’s constitution, which encouraged foreign investment and capital growth. 

Despite the economic flourishing, flaws in the social order started to emerge. During this time, Argentina had an extremely uneven wealth distribution, with a few hundred families constituting an oligarchy that held power for much of the late and early 20th centuries. The country was also heavily reliant on exporting raw goods to European nations, with little homegrown industry. The lack of homegrown produce made Argentina extremely susceptible to global economic scares and overly dependent upon other nations. Foreign investors, especially those from Britain, also had immense influence and control in the nation, with English companies controlling over two-thirds of rail transport. This agro-exporter model led to Argentina’s decline following World War I. During the interwar period, foreign investment declined as nations like the UK and France began to look inward, and the great depression further worsened the prosperity of Argentina. 

By the 1940s, a new social movement took root in Argentina. Peronism, a political ideology created by President Juan Domingo Peron, sought to nationalize many sectors of the Argentine economy while isolating it from the rest of the world. In addition, Peron wanted to introduce several socialist policies, such as heavy state interventionism and centralizing a large welfare state. These policies made many Argentine industries uncompetitive in the world market, further exasperating Argentina’s economic stagnation. A consequence that came with the decline of Argentina’s economy was the country’s incapability to pay for its massive social spending. Argentina began to take on enormous debt, which would become a trend in the following decades. Even when Peron was ousted from power, overspending did not stop, leading to decades of slow economic growth, rising debt, and inflation.

At the same time, Argentina was suffering from internal strife. Constant military coup d’etats weakened the nation even further. From the 1950s to 2000, Argentina suffered three unprecedented hyperinflationary crises. The constant cycle of taking on debt, printing money to pay it off, and eventually defaulting on foreign loans caused Argentina today to have a poverty rate of close to 60%, in stark contrast to the 20% it started with in the 1990s. The recent administrations of Cristina de Kirchner, Mauricio Macri, and Alberto Fernandez failed to address the crisis. Rampant corruption did not help either, with the aforementioned socialist president Cristina de Kirchner being convicted of nepotism. Today, Argentina is a nation that faces 211% inflation, a national debt of 400 billion dollars, and 48% percent of the working population in the informal economy. Compared to the situation only one century ago, Argentina is a shadow of its former self. 

So, what does this all mean for the land of silver? Economically speaking, Argentina is a time bomb. They have exhausted their creditors, and the central bank, for the last few years, has been relying on Leliqs, short-term, high-interest 28-day bonds, to turn a profit. These Leliqs put the government in an even worse position as this scheme has caused the Argentine peso to lose even more value. In addition, hyperinflation, heavy regulation, and the high business costs in Argentina make attracting industry to the nation difficult. On paper, this may initially seem like an unsolvable solution, but Argentina has things going in its favor. It has vast natural resources, such as some of the most fertile land in the world and vast lithium reserves, which will prove invaluable in the coming decades. If Argentina stabilizes itself, it can easily become a strong regional power, if not a global one, with enough time. 

The newly elected President, Javier Melei, promises to fix the nation. The self-described Ancro-Capitalist has vowed to cut expenditure, dollarize the economy, and introduce more free-market policies in Argentina. Late in December, he announced an extraordinary 300 measures to deregulate commerce. The election of Melei represents a complete shift in the political order, as he is Argentina’s most fiscally liberal president in decades. The newly elected president expresses the frustration of many young Argentines with the current situation. Most do not want to inherit the struggles that their parents, grandparents, and grandparents had to endure just to survive. As President Javier Melei said, “You cannot expect change with the same old people.” The political outsider managed to channel the disillusionment of many Argentines, especially in the poorest neighborhoods in the last election, promising stability and order. He vows to restore Argentina to what it once was: an emerging world power. Time will tell if this Latin American nation can rise from its circumstances.  

Sources:

​​https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/argentina/overview

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-04-11/argentina-100-per-cent-inflation-crisis/102179458

https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/argentina-poverty-rate-rises-401-first-half-2023-2023-09-27/

https://apnews.com/article/argentina-poverty-inflation-massa-milei-d515d077f61147b203149d9e2a6a164c

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Peronist

https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/barbecue-off-menu-argentina-inflation-nears-200-2024-01-11/

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1037255/informal-employment-share-argentina/

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/12/6/argentina-court-sentences-vp-kirchner-to-six-years-in-prison

https://www.reuters.com/markets/argentinas-400-bln-debt-bomb-threatens-default-number-10-2023-12-13/

https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/argentine-president-calls-extraordinary-sessions-congress-speed-up-reforms-2023-12-23/

https://www.reuters.com/markets/rates-bonds/argentina-switch-benchmark-interest-rate-1-day-reverse-repo-2023-12-18/

https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/editorcharts/qzjpqwjdxpx/index.html

https://www.cato.org/blog/can-argentinas-milei-afford-delay-dollarization#:~:text=Leliqs,percent%20of%20commercial%20banks’%20assets.

Leave a Reply

Trending