Storrie Kulynych-Irvin ’24
In the United States, the Constitution delineates the limits of government power. However, not all democracies have a written document formally outlining the powers of the government and checks between legislative branches. Israel, a 75-year-old parliamentary democracy, has a Declaration of Independence but no official constitution. The prime minister – currently Benjamin Netanyahu – wields executive power, while the president serves a ceremonial role. Israel’s legislature, the Knesset, has a single chamber, and Netanyahu’s party, Likud, is the largest of the current coalition. Due to these factors, the only checks on Netanyahu are other influential politicians and the Supreme Court. In 2023, Israel’s Netanyahu-led executive branch attempted to change existing quasi-constitutional laws describing key government functions, resulting in mass protests and exposing fundamental questions about Israel’s democratic structure just before the Israel-Hamas war broke out.
“Throughout Israel’s history, even before independence, there have been multiple powerful attempts at drafting a constitution, and every single one has failed,” analyst Dahlia Scheindlin writes in +972 Magazine. Scheindlin argues that opposition to an Equality Law ensuring equal rights for every individual citizen has caused these failures. During Israel’s founding, Prime Minister Ben-Gurion delayed establishing a constitution, arguing that future Israeli immigrants should have a say in the document. By postponing the drafting of the Constitution, however, Ben-Gurion also sought to maximize his own authority as executive. Haredim also wanted to maintain their privileges and disproportionate power to assert family, dietary, and religious observance rules. In the current system, coalitions have more incentive to include minority groups like Haredim because there are no constitutional laws on procedure. Though the 1947 UN Partition Plan required draft constitutions for both the Jewish and Arab states, the Israelis drafted but never passed a constitution.
The 1950 Harari Decision by the First Knesset initiated the adoption of Basic Laws over a full constitution. Some consider Basic Laws as chapters in Israel’s future constitution; others expect them to take a constitution’s place, along with court decisions and parliamentary practice (LOC). Though some Knesset parties blocked attempts in the 1960s and 1970s to adopt a bill of rights outlining individual liberties and powers in relation to the government, the Knesset has since passed several Basic Laws encompassing some of these rights. By the 1990s, these included the Human Dignity and Liberty and Freedom of Occupation Basic Laws. While some Knesset laws and Supreme Court decisions have codified equality principles, like gender equality, equal pay, and an anti-discrimination law, Netanyahu and his right-populist coalitions have since narrowed individual rights, most notably with the 2018 Jewish Nation-State Basic Law.
On July 4, 2023, Israel’s Knesset adopted Basic Law: The Judiciary (Amendment No. 3). This amendment, also known as the reasonableness bill, was part of the initial stage of controversial proposed reforms. The Israeli judiciary is one of the few checks with executive power in Israel, protecting the country from tyranny. On January 1, 2024, the Court nullified Netanyahu’s reasonableness bill, marking the first time a judiciary struck down a Basic Law. The reasonableness bill would have removed the judiciary’s authority to deny or block unreasonable Knesset decisions and laws, a key check on legislative power. The Court argued that Netanyahu’s proposed alteration of the reasonableness law would cause severe harm to Israel’s future as a democratic state. Without a constitution, the question remains whether the Court is fully guaranteed judicial review.
Netanyahu proposed various other amendments, including increasing government representation on a committee that appoints Supreme Court judges, ending the requirement that ministers follow their legal advisers’ advice, and a simple Knesset majority to overrule Court decisions, which Netanyahu eventually abandoned due to its radical nature. These reforms would concentrate more power in the executive branch, currently led by Netanyahu-chaired HaLikud, “the most right-wing and religiously conservative government in the country’s history,” according to PBS. With the passage of these reforms, the right-wing agenda would dominate Israeli politics. Additionally, proceedings in Netanyahu’s corruption trial resumed in December 2023. Netanyahu denied wrongdoing, and some speculate he attempted to limit the Court’s powers at least in part to avoid sentencing. Netanyahu’s reforms, in addition to threatening Israeli democracy, may also be a political ploy to evade corruption charges for personal benefit.
Thousands of Israelis and foreigners protested the legislative package in the spring and summer of 2023. Furthermore, some military reservists threatened to resign out of fear of an unchecked tyrannical executive authority. However, Hamas’s October 7 attack would put a temporary halt to these protests by unifying the country during a time of war.
Now during wartime, civil unrest over Netanyahu’s proposed amendments has waned. However, we have yet to see how much the Court’s recent decision will affect Netanyahu’s political strategy and how the amendments will shape Israeli perceptions of Netanyahu. Already, reporters argue that Israeli approval for the Likud party has begun to drop, and an election held now would most likely result in the loss of Likud seats within the Knesset. The question remains: will Netanyahu respect the court’s decision to block the reasonableness bill? Whether or not Israel’s Basic Laws ever become a formal constitution, the expectation remains that Netanyahu and the Knesset will follow them. If they do not, a constitutional crisis will almost certainly ensue.
Sources
https://www.972mag.com/constitution-equality-basic-laws-israel/





Leave a Reply