Russell Robinson ’25

Six months have passed since the Supreme Court overturned the nearly 50-year precedent of Roe v. Wade, which protected the right to an abortion in all states. Since then numerous states have begun to take official stances on the issue by both enforcing and repealing abortion access. In a world without Roe v. Wade, millions of women are left wondering how to navigate the further confusing act of childbirth. 

The United States still remains relatively divided on abortion, with little change in views over the past 20 years. According to a poll from the Pew Research center, 6 in 10 Americans believe that abortion should be legal in most, if not all cases. Despite the continued controversy posed by abortion, the New York Times reports that abortion is actually increasing in the states where it is legal. Due to the fractured mess of laws that has originated as a consequence of  Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, it is impossible to discuss abortion in the US without describing abortion in the states leading the charge in abortion: Texas, Idaho, Ohio, New York and California. These states are good weathervanes for the current political climate in the US and where abortion could go in the future.

Texas has routinely been one of the most extreme states on abortion, currently with a ban after conception. On multiple occasions bills have been proposed that would allow women who received an abortion to be tried for the death penalty. Most recently in a highly televised case, Texas resident Kate Cox sued to obtain an abortion after learning that her fetus has trisomy 18, a fatal chromosomal condition, as well as other health issues. Texas’s top court ruled that she cannot terminate her non-viable pregnancy despite risks to her life and future fertility. Cox fled her home state to obtain an abortion. Texas and 15 other states would have forced Cox to risk her life for a child that could not be born. With the entire southeast region home to the nearly 28 million women of reproductive age inaccessible for abortions, fleeing the state for abortions is an expensive option. 

The greatest cause for concern for these new anti-abortion laws is the safety of the mother. In many cases doctors are unable to terminate a pregnancy in instances where the fetus has no chance of survival. Doctors of obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYNs) in Idaho— a state with some of the country’s most strict abortion laws— are fleeing the state in droves. This leaves only a few towns with expert prenatal care for the pregnant women. Nearly 50% of all OB/GYNs in Idaho have considered leaving or are already leaving the state. Many lawmakers did not anticipate the exodus as a result of the legislation, and further action will have to be taken to prevent a mass departure of OB/GYNs in the rest of the abortion banned states. 

In November, Ohio, a mainly red state, put forth a constitutional amendment to preserve abortion up to a vote, and overwhelmingly 57% of the voters voted to keep abortion access. While many far right legislators are trying to undo this vote, Ohio has proved that there is a lot of will to keep abortion legal which could become a key factor in the upcoming 2024 elections. 

New York, Colorado and a few other blue states have positioned themselves as bastions for abortion access. These states have seen a record number of abortions from people fleeing their state for abortions. 30% of Colorado’s abortions are now due to out of state patients, the majority of them from Texas. However, the increase in patients is putting a strain on the healthcare system already weakened by COVID-19. Furthermore, out-of-state patients tell harrowing stories of barely being able to afford the trip and driving dozens of hours to receive an abortion pill. These stories appear to have no sign of slowing as we enter 2024. 

Abortion access continues to be under threat; The Supreme Court has promised to hear a case brought by a group of anti-abortion doctors against the Food and Drug Administration regarding mifepristone to limit its access. Mifepristone and a similar pill called misoprostol is the most common way to induce abortion. A ban on these medications could make abortion significantly more difficult. 

While it is simple to argue the ethics of abortion or read statistics on the procedure, the stories of individuals and their different relationship to abortion crystalize the toll of these restrictive policies. The 2024 elections signify more than simple polls to gauge public support for issues; they will bring pieces of legislation that will affect millions of Americans. Further bans on abortion will lead to even more unintended side effects and dangerous situations for women. Regardless of what side the public votes for, 2024 will be a crucial chapter in the history for reproductive rights.

Sources:

https://www.npr.org/2024/01/05/1216284896/supreme-court-allows-idaho-abortion-ban-to-be-enacted-first-such-ruling-since-do

https://www.npr.org/2023/12/21/1221040446/what-the-current-landscape-of-abortion-rights-looks-like-going-into-2024

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_Texas#2020s

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/aug/22/abortion-idaho-women-rights-healthcare

https://www.propublica.org/article/us-abortion-legislation-2023

https://www.cpr.org/2023/09/11/abortion-numbers-rise-sharply-in-colorado-driven-by-out-of-state-patients/

Leave a Reply

Trending