Mia Isacson ’26
One-Line Summary: American employers are hiring children to work at jobs with undesirable conditions.
Currently, there is a migration crisis in the United States. In the year 2023, 2.5 million encounters with migrants occurred at the U.S.-Mexico border—a historic high. In 2021, there were 18 million U.S. migrants under the age of 18 inside the United States. Since then, nearly 400,000 children have come to the United States without their parents. Last year, the number of unaccompanied minors entering the country soared to 130,000, three times what it was five years ago. This issue has come to the federal government’s attention, and the Department of Health and Human Services ensures sponsors will support and protect the children. However, the vast number of refugees has made it impossible to quickly ramp up staffers and shelters. The migrant children usually come to the US alone with little money. They, therefore, have to pay rent and support themselves, their family, and sometimes their sponsor, sending money back home when they can. Hence, the children tend to be constrained to taking whatever jobs they can, working long hours in dangerous facilities, and not attending school.
The influx of migrants into the United States results from multiple different reasons. Most recently, there has been an inflow of people from Venezuela because of its drastic economic decline. The UNHCR calls this the second largest displacement in the world, with more than seven million migrants leaving Venezuela for countries in Latin America, the Caribbean, and the US. Despite this, migrants also come from a lot of other countries: 23.7% of migrants in the United States are from Mexico, 6.0% from India, 4.7% from China, 4.4% from the Philippines, 3.1% from El Salvador, 2.9% from Vietnam, 2.8% from Cuba, 2.8% from the Dominican Republic, and 2.4% from Guatemala.
Unaccompanied migrant children are soon prompted to work as quickly as they arrive for multiple reasons. For one, living is incredibly expensive, especially in the US, and the children must pay for themselves. Hannah Dreier, an investigative reporter at the New York Times, met a 13-year-old boy who would work 12-hour shifts at an egg farm six days a week. Dreier wrote, “He told me that he wanted to go to school, but he hadn’t understood how expensive things were in this country.” As well, children are often sending money back home to their family, so not only do they need to provide enough for themself but also for family back home. Then lastly, children are also abused and taken advantage of by their sponsors, who are someone who is paired up with a child and supposed to support the child and account for their mental well-being. Sponsors are supposed to ensure the child they are looking over is attending school, but many push their child to work and either have to juggle classes and heavy workloads or quit school entirely. For example, 13-year-old Neru Cutzal was 13 when his sponsor sent him threatening text messages to keep working. He began working till 3 am most nights. Also, while many migrant children are pushed to go to the United States by their parents because of unlivable conditions and better opportunities, others are persuaded to come by adults who plan to profit from their labor.
Many children work at everyday household items brands like Hyundai cars or Cheerios around the United States. A New York Times investigation found widespread illegal child labor in factories that are making these products. Investigative journalist Hannah Dreier has interviewed more than 100 migrant children across the states working in violation of child labor laws. When accounting her talks, Drier says, ” I talked to a 12-year-old in Florida who came to this country and the next day was put to work roofing houses.” Roofing is a hazardous job that entails putting up a roof with perilous implications where one slip can be fatal. For example, A 16-year-old in Arkansas fell off a roof and shattered his back. A 15-year-old in Florida was burned all over after he slipped from a roof and onto a vat of hot tar. Jobs like roofing aren’t very desirable, so they end up going to child migrants who are desperate for work. Dreir highlights that when she says, “These are jobs that used to go to undocumented immigrants. Now they go to undocumented child migrants.”
The main issue? No one is properly checking on these kids. Dreir highlighted that “children are being put in situations that a child should never be put in, and yet there is no support.” Namely, a migrant child named Juanito has been calling health and human services for help because of the abuse he has been facing from his sponsor, who was constantly recording him and stealing his paychecks, but the child never heard anything back. After the New York Times confronted health and human services on the issue, they said they would usually never call back the kids who called but are now deciding to change their policy.
Some people in power aren’t trying to help the situation but make it worse. The Washington Post reporter Jacob Bogage states that a Florida-based conservative think tank named the Foundation for Government Accountability and its lobbying group, The Opportunity Solutions Project, is trying to loosen child labor laws nationwide. In April 2023, they passed a bill allowing minors as young as 14 to work night shifts, and states like Missouri and Ohio are considering bills that would allow teenagers to work longer hours in previously deemed dangerous jobs. Meanwhile, it is essential to understand that Child labor is not a criminal offense, and a maximum fine of 15,000 dollars for big companies, compared to their profits, is nothing. Child labor laws are already very relaxed now; from the looks of it, they will only worsen in the future.
This problem has come to the government and some companies’ attention, so reparations are in the process. Health and Human Services and the Biden administration have said that they had no idea so many of these children were working full-time in dangerous jobs. The federal government has started hiring child welfare agencies to track minors who are deemed to be at risk. Again, the New York Times interviewed more than 60 caseworkers, and most independently estimated that about two-thirds of unaccompanied migrant children are working full-time. The U.S. Department of Labor also announced that Packers Sanitation Services Inc., one of the nation’s largest food sanitation companies, had agreed to pay 1.5 million in civil penalties after the federal investigators discovered a violation of child labor laws. They found the company had illegally employed more than 100 children, ages 13 to 17, all working in dangerous jobs at 13 meat processing facilities.
Child migrant work is becoming a huge issue that the United States needs to start prioritizing. Labor laws need to be stricter; there needs to be more safety and energy put into protecting unaccompanied child migrants, and also a better background check for the sponsors. Reparations are happening, thanks notably to the New York Times for shedding light on this problem with their thorough investigation, but there is still a long road ahead.
Sources:
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/12/14/us/roofing-children-immigrants.html
https://www.npr.org/2023/05/04/1173697113/immigrant-child-labor-crisis





Leave a Reply