Olivia Isacson ’26

One-Line Summary: Javier Milei’s radical campaign promises and if he will follow through with them.

How can a country with natural resources as abundant as Canada’s have 40% percent of its population living below the poverty rate? How can Argentina, which previously enjoyed centuries of economic prosperity, have an inflation rate of 145% today? The answer is 70 years of poor leadership. Argentina had been governed by Peronists, an ideology named after Juan Peron, the president of Argentina in 1946, who instituted a variant of left-wing populism during his presidency. The first non-Peronist in decades, Javier Milei, was elected on the 10th of December 2023 and has big plans to change the Argentinian government and economy. Will Javier Milei’s radical ideas save Argentina or continue its economic downfall?

Javier Milei, born in 1970, served as an economics professor and researcher before his foray into politics. In the early 2010s, Milei became well known for appearing on debates, criticizing prominent Argentinian figures and broadcasting controversial opinions. He notably called Pope Francis a “filthy leftist” as well as Al Capone “a hero”. He also shared his views as a proud climate change denier and an anti-abortionist, contributing to his contentious reputation with the Argentinians. In July 2021, Javier Milei assumed the role of deputy for the city of Buenos Aires, his popularity rising with inflation rates. The self-defined anarcho-capitalist’s speeches and promises of a new Argentina led him to become popular toward the end of the election.

Javier Milei has made election promises throughout his campaign, including eliminating sex education and withdrawing from the Paris Agreement. Most notably, he ran on a radical “shock therapy plan” for the economy: devaluing the peso. Milei believes that this plan would make Argentinian products and the currency itself less expensive to foreigners, growing the economy. Argentina’s economic minister, Luis Caputo, stated that devaluing the peso would incentivize industrial businesses to increase production. However, opponents have criticized Milei’s plan as a short-term solution that could lead to even more inflation. Milei has also argued that switching the currency to dollars could make the economy less volatile and eliminate the need for a Central Bank. Most Argentinians already have their savings in dollars, facilitating this switch. Argentinian debt is also paid back in dollars, so switching the currency would solve potential exchange rate issues when Argentina pays back its debt. However, by switching the currency to dollars, Argentina would relinquish money supply controls, making it so that the South American country could not set its own interest rate. Milei also believes that he can pay back the country’s extensive debt and carry out the plan of switching currency, which would take 35 billion dollars, by borrowing using bonds. However, investors are unlikely to lend the country money, given its history of defaults. 

To deal with the rising worldwide price of oil, Javier Milei suggests reducing energy and transportation rates through subsidies by cutting media subsidies, which has been accused of being inefficient and not a long term solution as the media subsidies would not cover the cost of reducing energy and transportation rates. Furthermore, in another effort to revitalize the Argentinian economy, Milei is also promising tax hikes on imports to push Argentinians to purchase domestic products. Lastly, Javier Milei has sworn to double Argentina’s universal health care plan and increase the food card program by 50%. Realistically, however, Argentina likely does not have the money to accomplish such a goal.

Upon coming into office, Milei made good on his promises of reducing the size of the government, cutting the number of ministries from 18 to 9, secretariats to 54 from 106, and firing the new government hires. Although it may seem that cutting down the government is a positive change, Milei is getting rid of vital ministries because he does not deem them to be necessary. For example, he cut the livestock and agriculture ministry, the territorial development and habitat sector aiming to protect the indigenous people of Argentina, and the Women’s Affairs sections of the government. Milei has also reduced government money to Argentinian provinces and halted new infrastructure payments. While these measures will save a considerable amount of money; cutting infrastructure payments will lead to unfinished buildings in Buenos Aires, which could dwindle tourism rates.

Furthermore, Milei set the official exchange rate to 800 pesos per dollar versus 366 pesos in an attempt to close the gap with other markets. While this radical shift may help in the short term, it could lead to inflation and increase poverty among the Argentinian people, potentially leading to the collapse of the economy due to the gastronomically high inflation rates. Lastly, Milei attempted to implement a series of labor reforms that would have increased the probation period for workers from three to eight months, given fewer compensation payments to dismissed employees, and shortened pregnancy leave. Although these reforms may have increased government savings, they are ridding Argentinians of basic human rights and could lead to an uprising of the people and a general discontent towards the president. Fortunately, the Argentinian judicial system was able to stop such reforms.

Milei has been described as the “Argentinian Trump,” and based on his campaign promises and his ongoing radical reforms, this may very well be true. Like Trump, Milei is unafraid to share his controversial views and radical ideas. However, as Americans did with Trump, Argentina’s citizens have mistakenly not taken Milei at his word. We saw what Trump did to America; Javier Milei has plans to do just that to Argentina. Milei’s economic ideas are short-term solutions that will, in the long run, worsen Argentina’s inflation and put them in even more debt. He is defunding important components of the state and is proving to be a danger to the women and indigenous people of Argentina. Power-hungry and politically inexperienced, Milei won the election by giving the Argentinian people false hope for a new economy, a promise that he is unlikely to deliver.

Sources:

Shock therapy plan

Argentina’s New President explained

CBN News

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/nov/20/who-is-javier-milei-argentina-new-president-far-right-what-does-he-stand-for

https://www.britannica.com/biography/Javier-Milei

https://apnews.com/article/javier-milei-profile-argentina-election-82488d49cca5aee10d4b911bde530922

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/argentinas-new-president-implements-shock-economic-measures-devalues-currency-and-cuts-subsidies

https://www.forbes.com/sites/lorenzomontanari/2023/11/20/javier-milei-and-the-new-libertarian-revolution-in-argentina/?sh=41bf98eb7990

Leave a Reply

Trending