Ethan Ly ’27
One Line summary: Boeing’s recent safety concern of a door plug blowing out of its own 737 Max 9 shines a light on the company’s faulty manufacturing.
On January 5th, Alaska Airlines passengers flying aboard a Boeing 737 Max 9 experienced a moment of sheer terror. At 5:07 P.M., only a few minutes after departing from Portland, Oregon en-route to Ontario, California, a door on the aircraft blew out of the plane. Fortunately, pilots were able to perform an emergency landing at the Portland International Airport; the jet touched down at 5:26 p.m.
A day after the incident, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) ordered the suspension of a number of Boeing 737-9 MAX planes. The aviation regulators mandated an Emergency Airworthiness Directive (EAD) which required inspections of around 171 airplanes worldwide, which will be able to return once deemed safe to fly. This disturbance has led many to speculate as to who the party at fault was.
The problematic history of the plane in question, the Boeing 737 Max 9, began around a month before being sent to Alaska Airlines. In October 2023, the door panel that recently blew out was removed and then reattached to the Max 9 by workers at Boeing’s factory in Renton, Washington, where the emergency exit area was filled in by a “door plug.” The handling of the doorpiece raises questions about Boeing’s manufacturing process. While the Alaska Airlines incident left all 174 passengers safe with several experiencing minor injuries, past events involving faulty Boeing jets have incurred large death tolls.
Fatal plane crashes are relatively uncommon; the probability of such a disaster is a 1 in 11 million event. Thus, occurrences of crashes and mid-flight disturbances are highly publicized. Despite defects in jets playing a large role in fatal mid-air incidents, deadly crashes can also involve the crew of a plane to be at fault. In May 2010, navigating in a Boeing 737-800, Air India Express’s flight 812 claimed 158 lives after an error on the part of the pilot, who missed the runway.
Boeing in particular has been in the spotlight for jet-related accidents. More recent crashes, Lion Air’s Flight 610 in October 2018 and Ethiopian Airlines’ Flight 302 in March 2019, called direct attention to Boeing’s jet manufacturing process. Both cases involved a Boeing 737 Max 8 and were caused by certain design issues. In October 2018, the catalyst of the Lion Air flight crash, flying from Jakarta, Indonesia to Sumatra, an island in Indonesia, was a malfunction in the plane’s automated flight-control system called MCAS. Similarly, the Ethiopian Airlines incident in March 2019 –around five months after Lion Air’s disaster– involved a faulty MCAS system. In both scenarios, MCAS was automatically and erroneously activated, sending the nose of the aircraft increasingly lower and ultimately leading to their crashes. Subsequently, after the Ethiopian Airlines crash, national aviation regulators took steps to ground the 737 Max; China was the first to suspend the plane while others followed suit, including the FAA of the United States.
The worldwide grounding of the 737 Max had huge setbacks for Boeing. In July 2019, the company reported a historically low quarterly deficit. Boeing also fired two of its top executives: Kevin McAllister, the director of its commercial airplanes division in October 2019 and CEO Denis Muilenburg in December 2020. In November 2020, the 737 Max grounding decree was lifted. However, not only Boeing took a hit from the suspension of the 737 Max, as airlines blamed huge losses in seats and revenue on the plane’s grounding. Similarly, the recent Alaska Airlines incident has already proved an economic challenge to airlines. In compliance with the EAD, aircraft carrier companies like Alaska Airlines and United Airlines have lost money from forced cancellations of hundreds of flights supposed to navigate with a now-suspended jet model. Alaska Airlines announced that the suspension of the 737 Max 9 would set them back around $150 million in full-year profit. United Airlines possesses 79 out of the 171 aircraft grounded by the FAA; the carrier also expects a loss in revenue in the first quarter of 2024. For Boeing, its shares dropped around 9 percent following the door plug incident, suggesting dire effects on the future of the company if plane manufacturing problems continue to headline news stories.
In both incidents involving the suspension of 737 Max jets –in 2019 following two fatal crashes and most recently the blowout of the door plug of a plane– Boeing faced and is facing class action lawsuits from both clients and shareholders. In November 2021, Boeing executives settled a $237.5 million case with shareholders on the quality of manufacturing of the company’s aircraft. In September 2019, Boeing settled its first lawsuit involving the fatal crash of Lion Air Flight 610, with families who lost loved ones in the incident receiving at least $1.2 million each. These events could potentially occur again for the plane manufacturer amidst the grounding of its crafts and questions increasingly being raised about the safety of machines. Passengers aboard the Alaska Airlines flight are also seeking reparations for their injuries from when a section of their flight’s 737 Max 9 blew out at around 16,000 feet elevation.
The recent grounding of Boeing’s 737 Max 9 not only poses a serious issue for the future of the flight industry but also elicits the question: are Boeing planes even safe? The company certainly took steps to improve its planes’ MCAS –the automated system used to correct the aircraft’s angle of flight– that malfunctioned in the deadly Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes. However, as of the incident on January 5th, the plane manufacturer’s safety precautions come back into question. The FAA’s decision to ground the 737 Max 9 serves as an effective measure to regulate the safety of Boeing planes, specifically with regard to door plugs. While facing the consequences of having its plane grounded, Boeing must also address a lawsuit finding heaps of faults at a plant in Kansas. As the company’s defects in its aircraft models continue to stack up, the future will require Boeing to immediately delve into a search for solutions to its problems.
Sources:
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/24/business/boeing-max-9-door-plug.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/24/business/boeing-max-united-alaska-resume.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/05/business/alaska-airlines-flight-portland-landing.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/08/business/dealbook/boeing-stock-max-9-grounding.html
https://abcnews.go.com/US/die-passengers-alaska-airlines-jet-speak-door-plug/story?id=106250955
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/boeing-alaska-airlines-door-blowout-passengers-file-class-action-lawsuit-737-max9/
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/23/world/asia/boeing-737-max-lion-air-crash.html
https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/boeings-worst-crashes-over-last-decade-2022-03-21
https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/boeings-ongoing-737-max-crisis-2024-01-06
https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN1WA1VD
https://www.boeing.com/Commercial/737max/737-max-update/737-max-software-updates





Leave a Reply