John Fernandez Suarez ’25
When the Spanish first made landfall in the New World, it didn’t take long for them to start building. In every Latin American city, mandated by royal decree, a dominant city square took center stage. Here, the symbols of governmental power were erected. The governor’s mansion, the main cathedral, and the administrative bureaucracy. Ironically, it was in these squares, which were designed to show the strength of the Spanish Empire, that new republics were declared. The successive governments that inherited these squares added to them with new architecture and impressive displays of this power, with the architecture often reflecting the current political ideology. It was in these centers that the politics of the nation played out. They bore witness to numerous conflicts between federalists vs centralists, oligarchs vs the urban poor, and between the communists and fascists.
Latin America is a continent in constant flux. Whether it be from economic booms and busts, wars, or radical new social movements, the region seems to be engulfed in chaos. This is especially true in the last few years in the political world. To truly understand the current rapid change in political alignments in the region, one must begin to discuss the impact of the Cold War. The Cold War, in simple terms, was not kind to Latin America. It turned the region into a battleground between pro-american, and pro-soviet factions that were engaged in a constant and bloody struggle. The United States in particular was very interested in the region as ever since Castro’s successful bloody revolution there was a constant worry surrounding the expansion of communism in America’s backyard. Thus, the United States funded and backed military juntas to maintain pro-American sentiment. This was done through Operation Condor, a CIA-backed operation that gave training, military support, and money to military juntas to maintain control over their countries, this resulted in the deaths of an unknown amount of people. The communist Guerrillas with the support of the Soviet Union and the CCP engaged in acts of terror led by groups like Monternos in Argentina, and the Shining Path in Peru.
Once the Cold War ended, Latin America emerged battered and bruised due to a debt crisis that harmed countries like Brazil, Mexico, and Argentina with many moderate democratic governments in charge. These governments, as a result of the debt crisis, embraced neoliberal ideas popularized at the time to reduce government expenditure. These liberalizing reforms were met with sharp opposition by many sectors of the population that viewed the shrinking wealthfare state and foreign investment as a betrayal, which led to what is known as the Pink Tide in the early 2000s. The term ‘Pink Tide’ refers to the generally more left-leaning ideologies and policies of these leaders, including Evo Morales in Bolivia, Cristina Fernández De Kircherner in Argentina, and Hugo Chavez in Venezuela, who generally increased social wealthfare programs and reversed or scrapped neoliberal policies as a whole. They also emphasized regional cooperation between the Latin American countries through the foundation of the multinational Union of South American Nations. This was done in an attempt to boost economic growth for member countries and to repeal American influence in the region. These policies were possible thanks to the commodities boom of the 2000s when large amounts of raw resources like food and minerals were in high demand thanks to a more interconnected world and an increase in population. This benefited these nations as their primary exports were commodities.
The Pink Tide crashed against the rocks when the commodities boom faded and all the investment and money left these nations leading to an economic downturn. In the subsequent election cycle, more conservative parties, also known as the ‘new right,’ won elections in the majority of these nations, with Bolsonaro and Macri being prominent among this group. These administrations attempted to fix economic woes and the crime that came with it by gradually cutting back on wealthfare programs and cracking down on organized crime. These measures in general failed due to a combination of public outcry and time of implementation.
These failures spurred on what has recently been dubbed a second ‘Pink Tide’ with more radical left-wingers getting into office than ever before, with Chile electing a socialist, Argentina returning to the Kirchners, and Columbia electing its first left-wing president, who was part of the infamous M19 guerrillas. These governments fared no better than their predecessors and thanks to Covid and their more lenient spending policies, a debt crisis has once again reared its ugly head in the continent.
Currently, Latin America is at a crossroads, with new factions and ideas coming to the forefront. The second Pink Wave has lost its momentum, as seen with the defeat of the Chilean constitutional reform as well as the rise of libertarian Javier Mieli. In particular, Mieli represents a departure from the norm. Instead of pushing gradualist or socialist policies that have been popular for decades, Mieli has brought libertarian ideas of a small state and minimal government intervention to the forefront. His victory came as a surprise to the political establishment of Argentina and the world, and in his short tenure to date, he has begun to take Argentina in a new direction. Another notable figure has been Nayib Bukele, a young right-wing leader who has dramatically crushed cartel activity within El Salvador, making him extremely popular. However, some international observers fear his methods may infringe on human rights, having said this he set to win a landslide victory on Sunday. This is not to say that the Pink Tide is finished as seen by the continued support of the left-wing Colombian president Gustavo Petro, and the election of the former left-wing president of Brazil Lula de Silva.
The future is certainly uncertain in Latin America. However, the continent has always been a place full of resilience; and at some point, it will come out ahead.
Sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor
https://yipinstitute.org/article/operation-condor-and-the-horrors-of-u-s-foreign-policy




Leave a Reply