Max Langhorst

One-Line Summary: Ecuador and El Salvador are both on the wrong track for gang violence

Ecuador and El Salvador have both been plagued with gang violence in recent years, but each has taken different paths in tackling the challenges they have faced. As a result, the two of them make for an interesting case study and comparison that allows us to understand the regional gang violence more deeply.

El Salvador:

El Salvador has long been known for its serious gang problem and extremely high homicide rates. From 2015 to 2018, there were an average of 81.6 homicides per 100,000 people. That is about 16 times more than the United States over the same period. However, President Nayib Bukele, elected in 2019, has massively cracked down on gangs, and it seems to be working: the homicide rate in 2023 was 7.8, a decrease of over 90%. While that may sound completely positive, there is an important caveat. 

In the process, he has committed numerous human rights offenses, intimidated members of the legislature, and undermined democracy. To drop homicide rates so significantly, the government arrested 60,000 people, about 1% of the country’s population. That gives them the highest incarceration rate ever recorded. Furthermore, Bukele’s government has declared a state of emergency, which has allowed them to suspend constitutional rights: the right to privacy (in communications), the right to assembly, and the right to be informed of one’s reason for arrest. Police forces have swept low-income, largely gang-controlled neighborhoods, arresting many without much evidence. It might be their appearance, background, anonymous phone calls or tips, or something else, but they barely seem to need a reason at all. 

Bekele has also shown himself to be corrupt and his actions have disregarded the El Salvadoran Constitution on two notable occasions. First, when the legislature (that his party has a supermajority in) took too long considering one of his crackdown policies, he marched into the chamber with security forces in full battle gear, before leaving and telling supporters outside that they would be back if the measure was not passed within a week. Second, the legislature ousted all the Supreme Court justices and replaced them with Bukele supporters. They then overruled a very specific ban on reelection in the El Salvadoran Constitution, declaring that Bukele (an incumbent) may run again in 2024. The United States embassy has condemned this decision, and for good reason: it is clearly the product of an incredibly corrupt court and a sign of Bukele’s continued effort to consolidate power. Despite all this, he has maintained an extremely high approval rating, as high as 90% in some polls, and polling suggests that he is on track to win the 2024 El Salvadorian Presidential Election without so much as a hiccup.

Bekele’s response to gang violence is unprecedented, and in my opinion, one that will only further cycles of violence. Many of the innocent people who have been put in jail will justifiably lose trust in the government and potentially become the gang members of the next generation. Bekele’s policies are a band-aid on an infected wound: they may look helpful in the short term, but they are doomed to fail in the long run. 

Ecuador 

In contrast to El Salvador, Ecuador was long regarded as one of the more crime-free countries in South and Central America. Its homicide rate, while high in comparison to the US, has been significantly lower than other countries in the region, such as El Salvador, especially in the past half-decade or so. Recently, however, gang violence has reared its ugly head once again, causing the homicide rate to skyrocket to 14.0 homicides per 100,000 people, about an 80% increase. As in El Salvador, the primary cause of the violence has been gangs. The recent violence began when it was discovered that a notorious gang leader, Adolfo Macías Villamar, had escaped before his impending move to a smaller and more secure prison. His escape sparked violence, both inside and outside of the prison system, across the country. 

Ordinarily, a prison change would not lead to significant violence in other prisons, but Ecuador’s prison system is unorthodox. Instead of the prisons being controlled by the government, they are to some extent controlled by the prisoners themselves. The prisoners, organized into gangs, can buy drugs, food, and water that have been smuggled in by the leaders. Over the past few years, these prison gangs, often held in different wings of the same prison, have fought against one another, causing many deaths. Gang leaders have also been escaping prison. 

The violence has not been isolated to the prisons. Gang violence has escalated around the country as gangs fight over territory. In one particularly frightening event, a television station in Guayaquil, a city of 2.5 million with a bustling harbor, was stormed by masked gunmen trying to force a presenter to read something for them. They were soon overpowered by police, but the event, which happened on air, scared many. During the attack, other gang-related violence was erupting across the city, long known as a hotspot for gang activity. Hours after the violence broke out, President Daniel Noboa declared a state of emergency, which allowed him to beef up the police force with the military, institute a curfew from 11 PM-5 AM, and suspend certain rights involving searches and seizures. According to Noboa, 30,000 people are involved in gangs throughout the country. He has promised to crack down on the gangs behind the violence and restore order, but military officials question how successful he will be. They say they don’t have enough equipment, ammo, and intelligence to continue the fight. To combat this, Noboa has appealed to other nations for help, stating that Ecuador “would gladly accept cooperation from the US.” Some Ecuadorians, such as 50-year-old businessman Humberto Poggi del Salto, who lives in Guayaquil, have encouraged Noboa to be more like Bekele, the president of El Salvador: “President Noboa must do what El Salvador did.”

Differences

Before I get to my own opinion on the violence in both El Salvador and Ecuador, it is important to note the major difference in how the gangs operate in the two countries. In El Salvador, the gangs largely make money by requiring residents of neighborhoods they control to pay rent for “security”. In Ecuador, gangs make money from cocaine smuggling, often taking advantage of Ecuador’s location between Peru and Colombia, where most of the world’s cocaine is produced, their use of the U.S. dollar to make money laundering easier, and the massive international harbor of Guayaquil, Ecuador’s largest city. The economic differences between El Salvadorian and Ecuadorian gangs lead to different power dynamics and different potential solutions.

The El Salvador-Ecuador comparison is an incredibly interesting one. In my opinion, neither country is moving in the right direction at the moment. In South and Central America, combating gang violence has become a seemingly impossible problem. Every time a country seems to have solved it, gangs regain power again. The reasons for this are numerous and complex, but one of the biggest ones is a focus on the short term. Presidents and governments, who are constantly trying to stay popular by mitigating gang violence, are focused on the here and now. They need to be focused on the longer-term, foundational issues that cause people, especially young men, to turn to gangs for economic, social, and political support. They need to focus on creating diversified economies and smart relationships with global powers. However, they can’t start doing any of that until they stop their gang problems. By themselves, it seems to me that South and Central American countries can’t break out of this Catch-22 — they need help from outside, be it direct military assistance, monetary propping-up, or other support. But no country wants to help, and for good reason: getting into any one of the countries experiencing gang violence would likely lead to minimal return at a great cost. 

Leave a Reply

Trending