Lisa de Boer

One-Line Summary: Chinese car manufacturers should get ready for protectionist measures in foreign markets.
Chinese company BYD surpassed Tesla, the renowned ‘vanguard of green vehicle manufacturing,’ in EV (electric vehicle) sales in the final quarter of 2023. In a reckoning between both companies’ record quarterly sales, BYD, which stands for Build Your Dreams, sold 525,409 battery electric vehicles compared to 484,507 by Tesla. Although international authorities are concerned China will dominate the emerging market with cutthroat prices as it did in the EU solar panel industry, many consumers view this instead as an opportunity for the green transition.
Since 2009, China has been heavily promoting the development of the EV industry. Domestically, the government has put in place strong incentives and stringent regulations to turn the steamboat of vehicle purchases toward electric vehicles. Pricing, for instance, is an important measure employed to encourage the EV industry; it is extremely expensive and nearly impossible to get a number plate for a gasoline or diesel car in China, whereas ‘green’ number plates are being given out free for many electric models. When a taxi driver in Beijing was asked why he drove an electric car, he responded that it was the cheapest option. Internationally, BYD and other Chinese EV manufacturers have also been on the rise due to their affordable pricing and relatively advanced features and design.
To combat the popularity of BYD, Tesla initiated a price reduction strategy in China to attract customers at the start of 2023, sparking an intense price war. While the lowered prices have driven up sales, they drastically reduced both companies’ revenue, diminishing their profit margins. According to data released by the Chinese Passenger Car Association, China’s car industry observed a profit margin of 5% in 2024, a decline from 5.7% in 2022 and 6.1% in 2021. To counterbalance the decelerating domestic market, Chinese car manufacturers have sought growth beyond the mainland by expanding their presence in Europe, Australia, and Southeast Asia. Despite BYD’s expanding global market shares, Tesla continues to dominate in the US market. This is primarily due to the ongoing U.S.-China trade war, intensified in 2020 by the Trump administration. The trade tensions led BYD to abstain from selling in the US, as the vehicles would be subjected to a 27.5% import tariff. Perhaps thanks to its foothold in American markets, although falling behind in the last quarter of 2023, Tesla was still ahead of BYD for annual sales at 1.8 million and 1.57 million vehicles respectively.
In Europe however, the market share of electric vehicles from China has been steeply on the rise. Chinese car manufacturers account for 8.4% of the European EV market, up from 6.2% in 2022 and almost nothing in 2019, according to independent auto analyst Matthias Schmidt’s data. BYD sent a big delegation to a car show in Germany in September 2023, as well as announcing a new EV factory in Hungary in December, showing its commitment to expanding overseas markets. The influx of Chinese-manufactured electric vehicles has made the European Commission accuse China of using government subsidies to gain an unfair price advantage. On October 4, 2023, the European Commission officially launched an investigation allowing for 13 months to assess whether to impose a tariff above the standard 10% EU rate for cars. The Chinese Chamber of Commerce opposed the investigation, asserting that the competitive advantage in the electric vehicle sector did not stem from subsidies. According to consulting firm AlixPartners, Chinese state subsidies for electric and hybrid vehicles were $57 billion from 2016-2022, but the generous subsidy scheme terminated in 2022.
Although subsidies played a large role in getting the Chinese EV started, the MIT Technology Review states that “subsidies and tax breaks are … not the whole picture.” One advantage BYD holds over its US and EU counterparts is its capacity for in-house production of electric vehicle batteries. Despite being a global leader in rechargeable batteries, Tesla faces challenges as it depends on external suppliers and anticipates lithium shortages in the future, posing a potential supply chain hurdle. In contrast, BYD has proactively addressed this concern by acquiring a stake in a Chinese lithium producer and expressing interest in acquiring mines in Africa and South America.
Despite cheap electric vehicles being a key component needed for the EU’s green transition, Europe does not seem keen on these coming from China. Instead, it is seeking to reduce its reliance on the Asian country, possibly fearing a recurrence of events from a decade ago, when the EU solar panel industry was decimated by cheap Chinese imports. Ironically, BYD and other Chinese car manufacturers are not the only ones who would be targeted by the European Commission’s tariff. The anti-subsidy investigation covers battery-powered cars from China, and therefore also includes non-Chinese brands with factories in China, such as Tesla, Renault and BMW.
Executives at Airways, a startup headed by Volvo’s former China sales chief, dismissed claims of Beijing’s assistance. “We’re not selling inside China, we’re not being subsidized in China,” emphasized Alexander Klose, vice president of overseas operations. He stressed that the EU should focus on achieving a green future “rather than keeping competition out.” Indeed, to the average European consumer, it doesn’t matter where their car comes from, only that it is green and affordable. Nations and companies should set aside competitive differences and work together to establish a framework that encourages eco-friendly practices and facilitates the growth of the electric vehicle industry.




Leave a Reply