Storrie Kulynych-Irvin

One-line Summary: In his February 6 interview with Vladimir Putin, Tucker Carlson failed to press the Russian president for direct answers about the current conflict in Ukraine.

American political commentator and writer Tucker Carlson enjoyed himself last week on his first trip to Russia, as he emphasized the cleanliness of Moscow’s Kiyevskaya Metro Station and visited a Moscow grocery store. Carlson has both supported and criticized the Kremlin’s actions in recent years. But his latest comments praising Russia’s supermarket prices and clean infrastructure create an incomplete, positive assessment of Russia as opposed to the U.S.

The main event in Carlson’s trip was his February 6 evening interview with Russian President Vladimir Putin. In the introduction to the interview, which was posted on Twitter, Carlson, standing before the Kremlin, said that his channel found Putin’s long-winded remarks “a sincere expression of what he thinks,” not a “filibustering technique.” 

Carlson’s assessment glaringly overlooks the fact that Putin deflected or ignored many of Carlson’s questions. No one knows whether or not Putin really believes his own version of events, but it’s clear that Putin wasn’t interested in answering questions like the first one Carlson posed: Why did Putin start a war with Ukraine, in February 2022, specifically? Instead, Putin immediately commandeered the exchange. Rather than addressing his current decision to continue fighting Ukraine, Putin adopted a lightly patronizing attitude as he launched into a half-hour history lesson loosely related to Russia and Ukraine. 

Carlson allowed Putin to relay his version of Russian-Ukrainian history, starting from Rurik’s 862 accession in Novgorod, for over half an hour. Putin spent much time describing the formation of the Russian state, and other Eastern European countries like Poland, only tangentially connecting to Ukraine. Carlson first interrupted Putin to clarify the timeline of the Russian president’s oral history. Eventually, Carlson broke into Putin’s monologue to ask how Putin’s remarks were relevant to the invasion two years ago. Putin ignored the question and motioned for a stack of historical documents, which he presented to Carlson to translate into English later. 

Putin handily controlled the narrative, with little opposition from Carlson, for the rest of the over two-hour interview. Putin returned to his own agenda whenever he wanted to deflect one of Carlson’s questions. The Russian president portrayed the Kremlin as a good-faith actor lied to by the West, meaning NATO, Europe, and the U.S. Putin said that U.S. Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush made one-on-one promises to him on issues like joining NATO and preventing eastward NATO expansion — promises that other U.S. agents broke. He reversed a Carlson question about propaganda within Russia, asserting that Russian media did not have the finances to compete with U.S. media’s global propaganda of false narratives about Russia. He added that China, with its higher population and larger economy, poses as a much bigger rival for global power to the U.S. than Russia. 

When Putin actually addressed his denial of Ukraine’s legitimacy, he focused on points most supportive of his narrative. Putin dwelled on the aftermath of World War II. He said that Ukrainianization – part of broader korenizatsiya (indigenization) – was a Bolshevik project, and emphasized that the U.S.S.R. officially created the Ukrainian state. This occurred with the help, according to Putin, of the Austrian General Staff, who promoted Ukrainianization prior to WWI to delegitimize Russia. He brought up a “funny” anecdote about encountering Hungarians in Ukrainian territory to focus on how some ethnicities like Hungarians may claim territory in western Ukraine. This story implied that Ukraine did not have a right to claim lands populated by other ethnicities. 

Asked whether he had accomplished his objectives in Ukraine, Putin responded no, because he hadn’t yet achieved “denazification.” Some ethnic Ukrainians did join Hitler’s forces in the Second World War – a conflict in which Russia undeniably suffered the most losses of any nation in defending itself against the Nazis. But Putin did not acknowledge that far-right parties and neo-Nazi militias are in the minority; most Ukrainians today who support an independent Ukrainian state do not embrace neo-Nazi ideology or symbolism. 

Putin has refused interviews from many news outlets since the war started; he decided to sit down with Carlson almost certainly because Putin saw a conversation he could control to his advantage. The questions of why fight this war now, in the 24th year since Putin came to power, and what Putin’s ultimate ends are, remain unanswered. If American viewers make it through the entire interview, they will lack any context, fact-checking, or pushback to frame Putin’s claims. In allowing Putin to tell his version of events unchecked, Carlson’s interview hardly threatens to challenge the views of supporters of the Kremlin and the Russian president. 

Leave a Reply

Trending