Linda de Boer

One sentence summary: There is infinite potential for collaborative solutions to climate change, and the necessity of global cooperation is essential.

Climate change is the most pressing problem of our generation. It is an incredible threat to our societies, but combating it requires tremendous change that not all countries can afford. Since the damage of climate change is so large, the toll it takes on vulnerable and less developed countries is enough to cause mass emigration and “climate warfare” by increasing competition for resources, especially clean water. Those leaving countries already impacted by climate change or those without the financial means to adapt to environmental changes make up 90% of the world’s refugees¹. 

Our world heavily relies on unsustainable resources – in the US, 80% of energy comes from oil, natural gas, and coal². In the UK, 78% of energy comes from oil, coal, and natural gas³. In Singapore, natural gas accounts for a shocking 92% of energy production⁴ (to clarify, natural gas is also a fossil fuel and an unsustainable energy source despite what the name implies). These are only a fraction of the many countries whose energy sources are primarily rooted in unsustainable energies. As these fuels inevitably run out, and as the consequences of using them start to hit countries harder with increased natural disasters, habitat loss, crop failure, desertification, and more, the hope for climate diplomacy seems to become slimmer and slimmer. How can countries collaborate when wars start to break out over resources, and the focus isn’t helping others anymore but the fundamental need to survive? How can we provide funding for other countries to transition to renewable energies when we need more funding to help ourselves?

Indonesia is a country especially vulnerable to climate change because of its large coastal populations, which are in danger of flooding and sea level rise. Its capital Jakarta is considered the most vulnerable city in the world to environmental threats. In Indonesia, 84.41% of energy produced in 2021 came from fossil fuels⁵. PLN, a state-owned company generating 60.7% of Indonesia’s electricity⁶ as Indonesia’s main source of energy, has relied heavily on fossil fuels for energy production in the past⁷, and will need investments totaling up to 172 billion USD for its renewable energy projects to be able to add 60 GW of renewable energy capacity to its electricity production⁸. 

The JETP (Just Energy Transition Partnership) agreement was signed between the President of Indonesia and the IPG (International Partners Group) led by the US and Japan on the 15th of November 2022, mobilizing USD 20 billion to support several carbon-reduction goals, including reaching Net Zero Emissions in the power sector by 2050⁹. The focus of this deal is coal retirement, and so funding is intended for coal power plants to retire early, as coal makes up 40% of Indonesia’s energy production⁰. However, retiring all of Indonesia’s 118 coal plants would cost an estimated USD 37 billion¹¹, and the nature of the agreement in itself doesn’t bring Indonesia new business. The JETP agreement focused on ending Indonesia’s use of coal instead of proposing a course of action that keeps Indonesia’s economy at the same level or better than it was before the agreement, thus being unhelpful to Indonesia.

In December 2023, PLN signed seven MoUs (Memorium of Understanding, a nonbinding agreement stating each party’s intentions in courses of action, partnerships, business transactions, etc¹²) with various Chinese banks and organizations. Combined with PLN’s agreement between two large clean energy companies from China (State Grid Corporation of China and Trina Solar China) signed during the President of Indonesia’s presidential visit to China, the deals’ total collaboration value exceed USD 54 billion¹³. These agreements propose courses of action to achieve several goals, including increasing investment between China and Indonesia to support Indonesia’s energy transition into renewable energy production. The MoU between SGCC and Trina Solar China proposes developing smart grids as the backbone for clean energy in Indonesia. Smart grids are electricity networks that can detect and match the supply and demand of electricity in real time, reducing electrical waste, maintaining stability, and minimizing costs¹⁴. 

These deals invite other companies in China and Indonesia to invest in renewable energy with increased collaboration between the two countries. Not only does it bring business, viable courses of action, and collaboration to both countries, but it also aids them significantly in their energy transitions to clean energy. This is a monumental milestone for two of the world’s top carbon emitters and also poses a win-win example for other countries in which both parties benefit their economy and energy transitions at the same time. While climate diplomacy can be challenging, deals like this help us find ways to collaborate and work with instead of against each other. Even as climate change raises the stakes and increases the pressure for all of us, the only way we can face the problem threatening all of us is for all of us to face the problem together. Climate diplomacy: is collaboration between nations possible? Absolutely.

Leave a Reply

Trending