Lisa de Boer

One-Line Summary: Biden’s moratorium on LNG projects stops the greatest “Carbon Bomb” of his administration

On January 26, 2024, President Joe Biden halted approvals for all pending and future Liquid Natural Gas (LNG) projects, including extraction facilities, storage tanks, export and import terminals, and more. The president declared energy costs, America’s energy security, and the environment as reasons for the moratorium. There have been vast efforts by climate groups to push against the rise of American LNG exports, as they contradict President Biden’s pledge to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 50% by 2030. The decision is a cause for celebration among many. Industry groups and many right-wing media outlets, on the other hand, have denounced the decision as a “win for Russia.”

Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, American natural gas exports have risen steeply. The US’s LNG capacity has doubled in recent years, and in 2023 the US overtook Qatar and Australia as the greatest LNG exporter worldwide. The rise of American LNG has been commended as a key geopolitical weapon in reducing the on Russian natural gas. As a result, The Economist criticized Biden’s decision, stating that it could “harm foreign relations” by undermining allies’ trust in the US for dependable trade. However, various analyses have shown that much of the increase in US gas exports is not bound for European allies. US Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm also assured that the President’s announcement would not have any effects on current LNG exports and that European allies would still be receiving the gas needed to reduce reliance on Russia.

One key reason the government provided for the pause on new LNG projects is how exports have been driving up gas prices for domestic US consumers. Modeling by Energy Innovation, a non-partisan research firm focusing on energy and climate policy, indicates a 9-14% rise in domestic gas prices in the medium term if currently paused LNG export terminals were constructed. This pause allows for a thorough evaluation of the broader implications and the development of policies that align with both economic and environmental considerations.

Among the projects put on halt is the Calcasieu Pass 2 (CP2), a massive LNG export terminal that environmentalists have dubbed a ‘carbon bomb.’ CP2 would ship up to 20 million tons of LNG per year, making it one of the largest export facilities in the world. LNG leaks methane from drilling, transport, and shipping, which, if taken into account, would make it a much greater driver of climate change than coal. Many environmental groups vehemently fought against the building of the CP2 terminal, including the “Keep it in the Ground” movement, 65 federal lawmakers, and Phillips Academy students with the Andover Climate Lobby. As such, the pause on this project is a major cause for celebration among these groups. 

However, some experts fear the decision will not have the desired effect on the climate, not least because if former President Donald Trump is re-elected he promised to “drill, baby drill,” but also because Qatar and Australia are expected to make up for the lack in supply left by the US. They see the pause on new projects as a lost opportunity for a greater share of the global market. Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm argues instead that “we need to have an even greater understanding of the (global energy) market need, the long-term supply and demand of energy resources, and the environmental factors,” so that we can be “better informed to avoid export authorizations that diminish our domestic energy availability, that weaken our security or that undermine our economy.” 

Despite the uncertainty as to whether President Biden’s announcement will have any real effect, for the current moment, CP2 and other ‘climate bombs’ have been put on hold. The Natural Gas Act of 1938 made it so that approving LNG projects was the default unless there was a direct conflict of public interest. Biden’s announcement looks to change this. Moreover, “It is a powerful statement that we can no longer allow these industries to continue operating without considering the health and safety of the people living in these areas,” says Roishetta Ozane, an activist in Louisiana. Indeed, if nothing else, the White House’s decision serves as a political message and reminder to people that climate change is a serious “existential threat.” 

Leave a Reply

Trending