
By Isabella Park
One-line Summary: The US will need to decide between relinquishing strategic goals in the Gaza Strip and restoring stability in the Red Sea when responding to recent Houthi escalations.
After taking the 25 crew members of a cargo ship hostage in November 2023, frequent Houthi attacks in the Red Sea have disrupted global trade. These attacks on commercial and naval vessels have expanded to missile strikes, with the number of attacks surpassing 30. The US began retaliatory strikes in January which continued in February, and imposed sanctions on Yemen on the 16th. As past sanctions have proven ineffective in curbing the attacks, the US will be forced to choose between objectives in Israel and Yemen if it decides to take definitive action.
Established in the 1990s, the Houthis are an Iran-backed militant group with the objective of gaining complete control over Yemen. As a key player in the 2014 Yemeni Civil War, it became intertwined with the Saudi-Iran proxy war when the two countries stepped into the conflict. In November of 2023, the Houthis hijacked Galaxy Leader, a cargo ship linked to an Israeli billionaire, as a show of solidarity with Palestine in the Israel-Hamas war. The Houthis have further attacked 30 vessels since then, often without an obvious Israeli connection. As 12 percent of all global trade is transported through the Red Sea, these attacks have forced shipping companies to reroute ships and substantially raise prices on goods. Although several countries have imposed non-military punitive measures such as sanctions, many countries are reluctant to retaliate militarily due to the potentially massive humanitarian consequences.
Houthi attacks on marine vessels have occurred in the past, most notably the 2016 strike on a United Arab Emirates aid vessel during the Yemeni Civil War. The Houthis justified this strike by accusing the vessel of carrying military supplies. In the following two days, the US and the Houthis executed strikes on strategic marine and land targets. Within 72 hours, the UN facilitated a ceasefire between the two sides. Although the US still indirectly backed the Saudi-led coalition in the Yemeni Civil War, the ceasefire signalled a decline in direct engagement.
Although the 2016 exchange of fire and the current escalation both occurred in the Red Sea and were supported by Iran, the reasons behind the attacks are different. In 2016, the Houthis were engaged in active conflict against the Saudi alliance in Yemen, and the missile strikes on aid vessels were a part of the conflict. Their continued involvement in the conflict already legitimised their cause, which is why it only targeted US military vessels following an initial US response. Accordingly, the ceasefire was attainable because it did not damage Houthi success in the conflict against the Saudi alliance.
On the other hand, the current situation that the Houthis face domestically adds symbolic significance to the recent attacks. Although the Yemeni Civil War is ongoing, the Houthis maintain control over parts of Yemen, including the capital. In September of 2023, protests erupted against the Houthi government in response to its failure to pay public-sector salaries, signalling an increasing dissatisfaction with Houthi governance. The Israel-Hamas War allowed the Houthis to garner support around the “Axis of Resistance” against US allies; this increase in support is already clear in recent protests condemning the US-UK airstrikes. To avoid reinforcing this linkage between Red Sea escalations and Houthi messaging, the US voted against a clause in the UNSC linking the attacks to the Gaza Strip. The significance of recent attacks in bolstering Houthi legitimacy means that a ceasefire will entail far greater concessions from the US and other allies than in 2016.
After launching airstrikes last week on strategic Houthi locations, the US government will decide on pursuing a diplomatic or military resolution. Numerous Houthi leaders have been sanctioned since the beginning of the Yemeni Civil War, and the group has already been designated a “Foreign Terrorist Organization” in 2020 under the Trump administration. As long as Iran continues to back the group as part of its long-enduring proxy conflict against Saudi Arabia in the Middle East, such measures will not immobilize the Houthis. Since the Houthis will continue to receive support, widespread sanctions imposed on the 16th will disproportionately harm Yemeni civilians. Although the US plans to inform civilians about the recent sanctions, such a mass information campaign is unrealistic in the conflict-torn region. Yet, military action is not guaranteed to be effective or internationally backed. The US military already conducted missile strikes against the Houthis during the Yemeni Civil War, and the prevailing Houthi government is proof of their inefficacy. The numerous critical statements and warnings issued preceding substantive air strikes last week have already undermined deterrence as well. Because the Houthis are so prevalent in Yemen, if the US government attempted to inflict more damage by conducting wider strikes, the global community would condemn its destabilization of the country and the resulting humanitarian crisis.
Simultaneously, the significance of the recent escalation to Houthi legitimacy means that a diplomatic solution will require the US to sacrifice major objectives in Israel-Palestine. The Houthis have already stated that they will not cease attacks until the US withdraws from the Israel-Hamas war. Negotiating such a ceasefire would greatly improve global trade, but the US has been clear regarding its involvement: it has no plans to withdraw from Israel-Palestine. As the Houthis vow not to stop in the face of US airstrikes, the US will have to decide between recommencing global trade and maintaining peace in Yemen or continuing its strategic objectives in the Israel-Hamas war.




Leave a Reply