Cate Cummings

One-Line Summary: Global climate injustice occurs when poor countries that contributed less to climate change are affected by it disproportionately and bear a significant burden of combating it. Being the world’s largest contributor to accumulative greenhouse gas emissions, the United States should lead the effort to rectify the situation both domestically and globally. 

Across the globe, scientists, political leaders, economists, and the ordinary citizen all have increasingly recognized climate change as a serious threat to the sustainability of our environment and human existence. Both the Kyoto Agreement in 1997 and the Paris Agreement in 2015 have been used to guide collective efforts in combating greenhouse emissions and climate change on a global scale. Today, unfortunately, we have continuously observed rising sea levels, increased global temperature, and extreme weather events such as flooding, heating, drought, and hurricanes that led to the inundation of small island states, human morbidity, and damage to our ecosystems. It is estimated that 68 to 135 million more people will be forced into poverty by 2030 because of climate change.

The prevailing view on climate change suggests that human actions are the major causes, primarily due to greenhouse gas emissions produced by industrial and energy-intensive economies. Compared to the pre-industrial age, greenhouse gas emissions, especially carbon dioxide, have risen by 40% and reached approximately 400 parts per million. In particular, wealthy regions and countries, such as North America, Europe, and Japan, through intensified industrialization and mass production, have contributed substantially to rising greenhouse gas emissions and exacerbated the consequences of climate change. 

Ironically, poorer developing countries have been affected by climate change significantly more than the wealthy nations causing it. Between 2010 and 2020, extreme weather conditions such as droughts, floods, and storms, killed 15 times as many people in these countries as in the wealthiest countries. A recent devastating flood in Pakistan, for instance, killed over 1,000 people and resulted in nearly $40 billion in climate costs. Two factors have contributed to this disparity. The first is that poor countries, especially those located in small island states or arid territories such as Bangladesh, Philippines, Malaysia, and the Sahel region of Africa, etc. are often geographically vulnerable to climate change and rise in sea levels. The second is that poor countries have fewer economic resources and capabilities to deal with climate change and the need for adaptation.

Thus, global climate injustice occurs when poorer countries that contribute minimally to the causes of climate change bear a significant burden of combating it due to limited economic resources, insufficient state capacities, and weak infrastructures. These countries are largely innocent bystanders of climate change as wealthy nations single-mindedly pursue their national interests and accumulation of economic advantages. The poorer countries have helplessly endured the costs of climate change and suffered undeserved consequences. Therefore, on the grounds of equality and fairness, wealthy countries should assume the major responsibility for climate change and have the moral obligation to help poorer countries resolve their vulnerabilities. 

Among the wealthy nations, the United States has played a particularly active role in both contributing to and combating climate change. This begs the question: how does the U.S. contribute to global climate injustice? Based on a report by the International Monetary Fund, CO2 emissions per capita in the United States are about 20 metric tons a year, which is nearly double the amount per person in the European Union or China, and almost 10 times the amount in India. Historically, “United States’ accumulative emissions are 25 percent of the total, the European Union’s 22 percent, China’s 13 percent, and India’s 3 percent”. Despite this hard data, the U.S. has tried to direct the climate change attention to China whose greenhouse gas emissions increased considerably over the past couple of decades. However, the reality is that “it could be another 30 years before China overtakes the US on cumulative emissions,” predicted Robbie Andrew, who is a senior researcher and climate data expert at the Center for International Climate Research in Norway. 

The US must rectify the situation by demonstrating leadership in combating climate change both domestically and globally. Indeed, The Fifth National Climate Assessment (NCA5) shows US emissions have fallen since 2007 and the efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and adapt to climate change have expanded since 2018. President Biden recently signed Executive Order (14008) to revitalize the US’s commitment to environmental justice. Consequently, the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) designed a $27 billion Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund to build climate change resilience and equality in communities across the country. Climate change regulations and rules, such as The Clean Air Act, The American Innovation and Manufacturing (AIM) Act of 2020, Mercury and Air Toxics Standards (MATS), and Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), to name a few, illustrate that the US has been scaling up actions to reach net-zero emissions by 2050 and limit the global temperature increase to 1.5°C, a global initiative set collectively at the UN summit COP26. These efforts aim at reducing the US’s contribution to global greenhouse gas emissions and incorporating environmental justice into its political agenda.  

However, environmental justice and global climate injustice in particular need to be translated into concrete actions to help reduce climate costs to poorer countries. US’s early effort in this direction, unfortunately, fell short of expectations. During the UN climate change conference COP27 in 2022, activists and campaigners called the US the “colossal fossil” and criticized the US for lacking commitment to the new “loss and damage” fund to poorer countries that unfairly suffered severe climate impacts. Although the US is open to discussing this initiative, according to John Kerry, the US climate change diplomat, it remains unclear if the US will step up to pay its share of global climate injustice. In addition, the new climate change agreement, which emerged from Cop28 in 2023, on “transition away” from fossil fuel is likely to create greater challenges for the US and wealthy countries like the UK and Canada, as they are contemplating gearing up oil and gas production. This further casts doubts on when and how global climate injustice can be ratified.

Achieving a balance between self-interest and public good is more than a philosophical debate. In a civil world, we expect people to respect the boundaries of others and pay for damages to those who are harmed by unwanted actions. Social welfare systems are designed to protect innocent people whose rights are violated and whose livelihoods are endangered by others. Similarly, wealthy nations such as the US that have initiated and sustained climate change should actively develop programs, form alliances, and raise funds to assist poorer countries in dealing with the damaging consequences of climate change. Strengthening global cooperation to combat climate injustice also means rejoining the Paris Agreement, establishing multilateral climate financing, and leading concerted efforts in building a sustainable global supply chain.

In addition to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 and transitioning away from fossil fuels in the domestic market, the US should consider forming alliances with the UK, Canada, EU, China, and even India to discuss how they can collaboratively provide direct assistance to countries that suffer climate injustice. Such assistance should primarily focus on helping these countries to increase their adaptation to climate change, build resilience to natural disasters, and manage climate costs. For example, the US has committed over $26 billion in infrastructure funds to seek nature-based solutions for ecosystem restoration, reduction of wildfire risks, and the development of climate-smart agricultural practices. The knowledge generated from these efforts can be applied to developing countries around the world to help them conserve and restore forests and build sustainable agriculture economies. In addition, the US’s active involvement with private sectors such as heavy industry and transportation would bring additional investment and innovative solutions to these vulnerable countries. 

The US should also involve leaders of developing countries vulnerable to climate impacts in the global cooperation initiative to understand where the assistance can be delivered. For example, hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) emissions are increasing particularly in developing countries due to increased demand for refrigeration and air conditioning. Under the amendment to the Montreal Protocol in Kigali, Rwanda, it is expected that the global production and consumption of HFCs will be reduced by more than 80 percent over the next 30 years. In particular, developing countries will need to freeze consumption either by 2024 or no later than 2028. The US could spearhead the financing process for these countries under the global cooperation initiative and help them transition to climate-friendly alternatives. Indeed, the US is forming new partnerships with South Africa, Indonesia, Vietnam, and Egypt to accelerate their clean energy transitions. 

The degree of assistance should be a function of a country’s cumulative greenhouse gas emissions such that the high polluters are obligated to pay more to the climate injustice assistance funds and programs. This means the US should lead by example and become the top sponsor of the UN’s multilateral  “loss and damage” climate injustice fund. President Biden, for instance, promised to work with Congress to “quadruple U.S. support for developing countries – and enhance finance for adaptation efforts six-fold – by 2024”. 

To strengthen the global commitment to halt climate injustice, the US should continue to work closely with the UN to develop and monitor ongoing climate injustice welfare systems and adaptation programs to support countries that contributed little to the causes of climate change but suffered the most debilitating impacts. This would allow poorer countries to develop better infrastructure, improve environmental sustainability practices, strengthen healthcare accessibility, and establish stronger financial and telecommunication systems. In the process, the US will achieve a balance between maintaining sovereignty and contributing to the sustainability of our world.

Leave a Reply

Trending