Saya Jameson

One-Line Summary: How U.S. gun policy compares to foreign nations–and what we can do better.

In the U.S., gun violence is responsible for 15% of deaths of individuals under 20 years old, a shocking statistic to most other countries in the world. In 2007, a study found that there were on average 89 guns for every 100 people in the U.S. Among wealthy nations, the U.S. has the highest rate of gun violence, a rate that is only increasing, making this a national public health crisis. But how do other nations fare dramatically better in gun safety than the U.S.? The answer is not so simple.

Much of the answer lies in the different processes of acquiring guns in other nations. In the U.S., the prerequisite to buying firearms is largely one step: an immediate background check surveying criminal history and immigration status. In other words, any individual over 18 without a record of crime is, for the most part, free to purchase a gun. The process is dramatically shorter than in most other wealthy countries, including New Zealand, South Africa, India, and Germany, which all require either a training program or an examination on the handling of guns before allowing a purchase. Japan, a nation that has one of the most stringent gun policies, as well as the lowest gun violence rates, requires multiple background checks, including a mental illness assessment of both the purchaser and their relatives. These additional steps, which may sound frivolous at first, are arguably at the crux of Japan’s successes, especially given that over half of the U.S. gun violence deaths are suicides. In Austria, a required “cool down” period of 3 days between purchasing a gun and having access to it minimizes the likelihood of impulse violence. 

What led many countries to have the gun laws they have today? Take Australia, which, until the mid-1990s, had a similar gun policy to the U.S. Following the Port Arthur mass shooting in 1996, the country turned gun ownership into a privilege rather than a right as it had previously been. This meant that owners had to have a valid reason to own a gun and earn the privilege, rather than have firearms as a right to self-defense. New Zealand banned most semi-automatic weapons following a mass shooting in a mosque in 2019. Past and present, many instances of gun violence in wealthy foreign nations have been met with policy change and reflection from the government. The U.S., on the other hand, has historically been extremely stringent on changing gun policy, likely rooted in the country’s history of turning gun policy based on values over statistics. Countries like Yemen have very loose rules on gun control, and individuals can purchase firearms without a background check of any sort. Even then, the number of guns owned per capita is significantly lower than that of the U.S. Such statistics highlight that the higher rates of gun ownership in the U.S. are at least in part cultural, and do not completely lie in the availability of firearms. The Second Amendment of the Constitution establishes the ownership of firearms as a right, not a privilege, providing a cultural framework in which gun culture is built upon the belief that firearms protect the liberty of its citizens. When the argument becomes one of values over one of life and death and faces extreme politicization, the statistics and policy matter less than political (liberal or conservative) allegiance. 

How could America take inspiration from other countries and incorporate safer gun laws? These are just three proposals, although not a complete fix, could dramatically minimize avoidable gun violence:

  1. Requiring background checks. The U.S. currently uses the National Instant Criminal Background Check System, which has many cracks in the system—it allowed an individual who had domestic violence records in the Air Force to purchase firearms and kill 26 people. A more thorough background check and a system that punishes the federal agencies that don’t update their criminal records could potentially reduce the likelihood of repeat offenders.
  2. Raising the minimum age to buy guns from 18 to 21. The ages 18 to 20 are considered a high-risk time for gun use, with the greatest amount of murder convictions coming from that age group. In addition, states that have already banned guns for all under 21 see lower rates of suicide by guns. Both the Sandy Hook shooter and the Parkland shooter, for example, bought their guns legally right after turning 18, and those shootings could have potentially been avoided with a higher minimum age.
  3. Install ‘red flag’ laws. Five states have already implemented these, which allow courts to restrict individuals from owning firearms when family members and the police have alerted extreme danger signs. These laws hope to reduce suicide gun deaths in particular, as families are more likely to help prevent individual cases than law enforcement.

By reevaluating values based on statistics rather than taking values at face value, America can hopefully draw inspiration from other countries to minimize the epidemic of gun violence.

Leave a Reply

Trending