Ethan Ly
One-Sentence summary: A contentious relationship between the U.S. and China persists; U.S.-Mexico trade relations increase.
For the past 20 years, China has acted as the U.S.’s top provider in imported items. The nation has since been dethroned from their position by Mexico, a nation that last exported a higher value of products over China to the U.S. in 2002. Statistics regarding U.S. trade in 2023 recently released by the U.S. Commerce Department revealed the state of the country’s handling of foreign affairs. The value of imports from Mexico increased by around 5% to over $475 billion. Chinese exports to the U.S. were evaluated to be at $427 billion, a large 20% drop from 2022 to 2023. The U.S.’s faltering and deteriorating relationship with China has seemingly worsened while Mexico has only ascended the economic ranks.
Tensions between the U.S. and China are high, and they only seem to rise. Chilly trade relations between the two nations, known as a “trade war”, developed most notably in April 2018. While trade conflict between the two nations arose prior to the discussed date, in April 2018, China imposed tariffs on 128 U.S. goods, taxing 25% of the valuation of the U.S. imports. A day after the incident, former U.S. President Trump responded with a plan for a 25% import tax on Chinese imports valued at around $50 billion. China subsequently levied around $50 billion of U.S. products. The two nations then spiraled into a state of a retaliatory taxing of imports. Until, in December, 2018, the U.S. and China agreed to pause their trade war and halt new tariffs for three months. After the 90-day halt, the pattern of constant and retaliative new imports taxes continued. In 2020, the “Phase One” trade agreement was enacted: the U.S. pledged to relax its trade taxes of Chinese goods and China agreed to increase its spending by $200 billion on American products. In March 2021, amidst conflicting perspectives on policies, President Biden seemingly continued Trump’s trade war against China, and chose to keep tariffs on Chinese products. An incessant trade war has certainly plagued the relationship of the world’s two largest economies.
Diplomatic relations have also set them back. Towards the end of 2020, the Trump administration’s blames on China over the spread of the COVID-19 escalated U.S.-China tensions. Similarly to the trade war in 2018, officials made baseless claims that the U.S. military was the cause of the virus leading to both sides continually blaming each other. Disputes over the South China Sea have headlined news stories: Beijing declared the territory as there own despite several other nations historically laying claim to the waters. The U.S., in favor of the freedom of navigation, claimed that China’s assertion of having complete sovereignty over the area was unfair. U.S. President Joe Biden sided against China with the Philippines in the dispute: “The United States’ defense commitment to the Philippines is ironclad.” The United States is clearly pulling back from trade with China, and its diplomatic relations with the nation are in a state of decline.
Mexico’s relationship with the U.S. has remained quite stable aside from hiccups regarding migration, drugs, and arms. As Mexico serves larger roles in international trade, its domestic problems become more noticeable and concerning. The reason its imports are experiencing exponential growth lies in its role as an enlarging nearshoring –outsourcing manufacturing tasks to nearby nations– base; the country is even seen as a replacement for manufacturing in China. However, with more and more companies basing operations in Mexico, the country’s infrastructure has shown its limitations. In 2022, during electric vehicle company Tesla’s initial setup in Nuevo León, Mexico, a drought struck, and many inhabitants of the area were stuck in a difficult and dangerous situation. Gang violence, headlining news stories, are also a challenge that Mexico is struggling with; around 30,000 people have died each year from gang-related incidents, and the number only seems to climb. If Mexico’s infrastructural problems continue, companies might be deterred from basing nearshoring operations in the country, which would ultimately lessen Mexico’s economic benefit.
The 2023 U.S. commerce figures raise the question: why is U.S. trade with China declining? The reason for a 20% decrease in U.S. trade with China lies in the trade war the two nations are engaged in. China’s exports to the United States have been on a steady decline; in 2017, its export market share in the U.S. was at 21.6%, but amidst U.S. trade complexities, that number now stands at 14%. President Biden’s continued tariffs on Chinese goods have only made China less inclined to buy U.S. products. The statistics corroborate: non-levied U.S. imports experienced greater growth, and highly-tariffed goods were less bought by China.
Despite their challenges, U.S. trade and a maintenance of relations with China might need to continue. The U.S. cannot cut off trade with China because around one million jobs in the United States are supported by U.S.-China trade. China also serves a source of cheap manufacturing for the U.S. China’s situation is similar: since it joined the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001, its economy has experienced growth of more than five-fold. In 2015, trade with the U.S. also supported approximately 1.8 million new jobs, and China’s trade with the country accounted for $165 billion in its GDP. If the U.S. and China were to cut off trade ties with each other, or significantly decrease spending in each other’s territory, both nations would likely face consequences to their economies.
U.S.-China tensions have not seemed to relax recently; meanwhile, U.S. trade with Mexico has flourished. Mexico’s economic prosperity only seems to continue; its domestic problems, however, also persist. With the recently released statistics in mind and diplomatic conflicts between the two countries, the future of U.S.-China relations only seems to be spiraling downwards.




Leave a Reply