Andrew Liu

One-Line Summary: The recent changes to FEMA leave some issues on the table while solving others, all while acting as a temporary solution to the broader issue of climate change.
As the flames died down last August in the small town of Lahaina, survivors were left with a new battle. How would they survive with their homes charred to the ground? In the coming days and weeks they would live through a much too common struggle, the chaos of the National Guard, Red Cross, Coast Guard, and FEMA all rushing in, and not knowing where to seek help even with an abundance of disaster relief. The reality is that disaster management in this country is uncoordinated at best, and negligent at worst. Much of this is due to issues with FEMA, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which is in charge of leading the federal response to natural disasters.
The issue of natural disasters has become a regular occurrence. From yearly western wildfire rampages to the hurricanes that slam the East Coast every summer, the number of disasters seems to be increasing. This isn’t an illusion. According to the National Centers for Environmental Information, the number of adjusted billion-dollar natural disasters has increased substantially over the past few decades. With more disasters and more areas being affected, the need for adequate FEMA and disaster support is greater than ever.
In response to inadequate funding, staffing, and program coverage, the Biden Administration recently announced sweeping changes to FEMA expected to be implemented by March. In general, the effect will be a much-needed overhaul to eligibility requirements. Previous regulations, such as needing to be rejected for a Small Business Administration loan before seeking FEMA assistance, will be removed to create clarity in the application process. Moreover, paperwork requirements will also be broadened, eliminating previous discriminatory effects against poorer populations who may not have deeds to inherited housing. Considering that FEMA has rejected around 46 percent of applicants in previous years, these updates will make it easier to access FEMA for those in need and eliminate the arduous legal process so that aid can be provided faster.
Unfortunately, despite these novel changes, several issues still remain with the US’s federal response to natural disasters. For instance, new changes still don’t address the problem of interagency cooperation. Survivors of natural disasters will still find themselves confused as different programs and organizations continue to overlap or contradict in hectic disaster zones. A truly improved system would consolidate efforts to reduce stress and difficulty for victims of disasters. Another problem is that the amount of actual monetary aid will not be greatly changed. Even though more people will receive benefits, the average payment of under $4000 is still far from sufficient to rebuild homes and rebuild lives.
Another broader issue regards insurance. FEMA was always meant to work in conjunction with existing personal insurance programs. However, with insurance prices increasing across the board, many people find themselves priced out of adequate insurance. This is exacerbated by many insurance companies removing disaster insurance from their coverage, citing increased disasters from climate change as an area for increased losses. The result is more people being financially vulnerable to natural disasters, and a heavier burden placed on FEMA. Instead of solely focusing on FEMA, federal solutions must approach insurance as one of their root problems if this issue is to be solved.
Lastly and most importantly, from a more conceptual perspective, aid packages for FEMA will always be a band-aid solution for the larger issue of climate change. As climate disasters increase in frequency year over year, increased damage is inevitable, no matter the level of support provided to affected areas. It is like improving patient comfort without treating the disease. Considering the billions of dollars in financing gaps for the fight against climate change, greater focus must be placed on treating the problem at its source. The increased need for disaster assistance should not be treated as an isolated problem, but rather as a wake-up call for the global issue of climate change. The current effects are only precursors for future problems to come.
This certainly isn’t a slight against FEMA or other disaster management agencies that help millions of people each year. However, with emissions continuing to increase worldwide, such disaster programs are simply a band-aid solution for an ever-increasing wound. The human brain has a propensity to find solutions with immediate benefit. After all, disaster relief gives an immediate benefit that is tangible to both victims and the general public. However, to address broader climate change and lower the number of natural disasters in the future, more fundamental problems must be tackled with a long-term perspective.




Leave a Reply