Stella Seong

One-Line Summary: The Supreme Court begins to hear arguments regarding former President Donald Trump’s ballot eligibility for the 2024 Presidential election.

On February 8th, 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court began to hear arguments regarding former President Donald Trump’s ballot eligibility for the 2024 Presidential election. In December of 2023, the Colorado Supreme Court ruled to prevent Trump’s name from being listed on the state’s primary ballot on the basis that he had violated a provision in the 14th Amendment. This, coupled with a similar decision determined by the Secretary of State in Maine, puts the fate of the 2024 Presidential election into the hands of the Supreme Court. 

The context related to this case stems from January 6th, 2021, when rioters breached the capitol in reaction to Trump’s loss in the 2020 election. According to the Colorado Supreme Court, January 6th classifies as an insurrection, where Trump engaged in the insurrection by inciting it. Observing this decision, Trump would be ineligible to become the U.S. President again in 2024, as this violates Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. The provision prevents those who “[have] previously taken an oath… to support the Constitution of the United States” and “engaged in insurrection” to “hold any office.” 

To investigate Trump’s ballot eligibility concerning this clause, a five-day trial took place in Denver, Colorado in November of 2023. District Judge Sarah B. Wallace ruled that, while January 6th was an insurrection that Trump engaged with, the clause was not clear about its application to the presidency, so Trump’s name remained on the state ballot. However, this was quickly appealed by Colorado voters and was eventually overturned by the state’s Supreme Court in a 4-3 decision that decided that Trump’s name was to be taken off the Colorado ballot. Similarly, Maine’s Democratic Secretary of State, Shenna Bellows, deemed Trump ineligible to appear on Maine’s ballot. 

These decisions prompted Trump and his lawyers to create an appeal, which was accepted by the Supreme Court on January 5th. The issues within the case are best demonstrated in Trump’s defense, which mainly discusses the wording of the insurrection clause. The defense argues that Section 3 does not apply to the presidential office since the presidential oath does not require one to “support” the Constitution, as Section 3 entails. Instead, Trump has only sworn to “preserve, protect, and defend” the Constitution, and his defense argues that this means that Section 3 has no relation to him. 

The defense also challenged the foundation of the argument using Section 3 against Trump, contesting that the events of January 6th did not qualify as an insurrection. Further, even if it were to be classified as an insurrection, the defense argued that Trump was not engaged in the riot as he was not physically present, and rather indirectly engaged in it through his words. However, Norma Anderson, the Colorado Republican voter leading the case against Trump along with five other voters, remains adamant about getting Trump’s name off of the ballot. The Colorado Supreme Court wrote, “President Trump asks us to hold that Section 3 disqualifies every oath-breaking insurrectionist except the most powerful one and that it bars oath-breakers from virtually every office, both state and federal, except the highest one in the land.” 

The premise of the case, formally titled Trump v. Anderson, has made the landmark jump from state courts to the U.S. Supreme Court. Section 3 was passed in 1868 to prevent former Confederates from holding public office, and has rarely been in use since 1872. Trump v. Anderson is also historic for the justices on the Supreme Court, as the court often rejects cases that are closely tied to a specific figure in presidential politics. The last time they played such a prominent role in the presidential election was in the 5-4 decision in Bush v. Gore in 2000 which ensured George W. Bush’s presidential victory. The idea that this clause could be used to disqualify a presidential candidate, the current front-runner for the Republican nomination, is unprecedented. This means the results of this case will have a significant impact on future politics, with the possibility of the Supreme Court’s involvement in presidential politics increasing. 

The case also takes into consideration the partisan politics of the current U.S. government. Although all seven justices on the Colorado Supreme Court were appointed by Democrats, they were split 4-3. However, the case brought before the Supreme Court was on behalf of four Republicans and two independent voters. In this sense, Trump v. Anderson has blurred the line between political parties, without a clear answer arising based on one’s political affiliation. Therefore, although six of the current Supreme Court justices were nominated by Republican presidents, with three nominated by Trump himself, the outcomes of the case can not be easily concluded. 

Most legal scholars predict that the Supreme Court will overturn the Colorado Supreme Court’s ruling and allow Trump’s name to appear on all state ballots. This is supported by the irrefutable fact that millions of U.S. citizens plan to vote for Trump in the upcoming presidential election. However, there is also another likely case that the court will not make a definitive ruling and rather pass the issue of the validity of the Section 3 argument against Trump to Congress. This would mean that the 2024 presidential election would likely be ridden with complications as state courts and voters around the U.S. continue to protest against Trump’s eligibility. Voters in 15 states will cast ballots for the Republican primary on March 5th. Without a certified decision from the Supreme Court soon, the incidents and controversy that played out in the 2020 election may return in 2024.

Leave a Reply

Trending