Linda De Boer

A ground-shaking breakthrough in climate activism took place on April 9th as the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Switzerland had violated the human rights of its citizens by not meeting its carbon reduction goals. Over 2,000 Swiss women above the age of 64 brought a case arguing that heat waves caused by global warming posed severe risks to their health. They claimed that their age and gender made them especially susceptible to the risk of death, and that the Swiss government’s inaction to climate change was a violation against their rights. The group, called KlimaSeniorinnen or Senior Women for Climate Protection, won the case and succeeded in legally binding Switzerland to meeting its climate goals, threatening further financial penalties if progress is insufficient. The success of their case is revolutionary in the realm of climate activism, opening a new way to hold organizations accountable, which is expected to gain traction in the future.¹

The approach taken by KlimaSeniorinnen can be used as a model for other climate activist groups taking action against governments for not meeting previously set climate goals. As climate change inevitably rises, governments could be sued for the immense danger and billions of dollars worth of property damage the resulting natural disasters pose to civilians. The list of legal complications that climate change can cause is endless. It is not just dangerous to the lives and health of people, but also to animals and habitats. The 2020 California wildfires alone burned through 81,000 acres of ancient redwoods and 16,000 acres of giant sequoia trees.² If these damages were caused by vandalists, they would unquestionably face charges for the environmental and economic impacts of their actions. Now that the legal responsibility for climate change has been placed onto the government, it will be much easier to hold them accountable.

However, the success of KlimaSeniorinnen is undeniably a rare one: the same court has rejected two other cases relating to climate change, one being brought by a group of six Portuguese youth and another by the ex-mayor of a French coastal town¹. What brought KlimaSeniorinnen’s case success was its appeal to human rights, which Switzerland is eager to maintain a good reputation in. Therefore, although there are currently numerous other cases of citizens and organizations attempting to sue their governments, this approach may not be applicable to other governments and situations.

Nevertheless this case can be studied to help lead other groups to success. For example, the winning case was proposed by over 2,000 women, while proposals by smaller groups were rejected, so large numbers are evidently beneficial to the appeal. Another point is that KlimaSeniorinnen chose to appeal to one of Switzerland’s top priorities – human rights – demonstrating how it’s important to understand the interests of the government being dealt with, and how those interests can be aligned with the case.

While KlimaSeniorinnen’s success may not apply to other cases and governments at this time, the success of this activism format changes the game. Activists have been given a successful case which can be used as a blueprint for future endeavors – it has opened up an entirely new and legally binding format for large-scale climate protection.

Leave a Reply

Trending