Andrew Liu
One-Line Summary: With March inflation data emphasizing the trend of rising prices, it may be time for the Federal Reserve of the United States to swallow the pill and double down on inflation.
Although inflation has always been important to the American people, it has rarely become so pervasive in daily life — filling newsfeeds, radios, TV channels, and the like. Inflation has become a topic for the dinner table, not just in business meetings. Following the COVID-19 pandemic, a roaring economy paired with soaring inflation. The current rebalancing initiative now represents a classic double bind: lowering inflation through higher interest rates will invariably damage the economy, while choosing to protect the economy through lower interest rates will let inflation run rampant. The Federal Reserve (Fed) has only one solution: to thread the needle between the two evils. For this, perfect economic conditions are not a bonus but rather a contingency.
It is in this environment of low margins that the most recent inflation data from March can be unpacked. From a bird’s-eye view, inflation can best be analyzed through consumer price index (CPI) data — a measure of the average change in prices for a basket of goods. Overall, the year-to-year CPI change in March was +2.7 percent, a critical increase from +2.5 percent in February. This was accentuated in the core CPI, which excludes the volatile prices of fuel and food, providing a net change of +2.8 percent. The magnitudes of these figures are important, but they matter far less than the relative chronological change. An increase in inflation from February to March does not simply mean an increase in inflation; it means an issue with the Fed’s current economic outlook. At a moment where steady decreases in inflation are required, the March bump represents a need for change in the Fed’s actions.
To paint a picture, the inflation data from March is not an outlier. Rather, it is part of a slowdown in Fed progress that began with the start of the calendar year. Both January and February experienced upticks in CPI and personal consumption expenditures (PCE) data. Moreover, consumer sentiment over the pricing of goods became a rising issue starting with the first two months of the year. Along these lines, the March increase in inflation is simply the latest crux in a wider trend of rising prices. Considering this, action from the Fed cannot be vacillating or vague. As this trend forms, the scale begins to tip towards truly addressing the issue of inflation, rather than worrying about the potential risks of a recession.
By outlining not only a problem but a greater theme of the economy that must be corrected, the latest March data effectively rules out early rate cuts. Recent historical examples, such as the economic situation of Argentina, show the dangers of populist policies that risk inflation. If the economy suffers, it will be a necessary sacrifice to curb inflation. In this light of the absence of rate cuts, two solutions remain: maintaining current interest rates and, alternatively, raising rates. Each has its own set of caveats. For instance, a decision to keep current interest rates operates on the assumption that these rates are effectively weighing on the economy, which may not be accurate. Opposingly, a decision to raise rates could cause a panic in the market, creating a recession as traders attempt to price in the decision. The March data narrows the Fed’s decision to these two prospects, both of which require full commitment.
With these decisions, it is hard to measure the pressure put on Jay Powell, the chair of the Federal Reserve. In the decision to hold rates steady, there is the pressure of the American people who expect the surging economy to continue. Although immaterial, with this option also comes the pressure of a presidential election in the fall and the issue of strong growth prior to the ballots. On the other side of the aisle, the pressure to raise rates comes from a place of uncertainty. A continued increase in inflation is only a risk, but if that risk occurs, the progress lost would represent years of failure. To raise rates would be the safe option, with a guaranteed price. Keeping rates comes with a risk, but also has a chance at threading the needle.
In such periods of difficulty, perhaps it is beneficial to look to the past. In the 1970s, stagflation caused by the oil crisis created significant inflation in the U.S. Faced with an insurmountable task, then-Fed-Chairman Paul Volcker made the decision to bite the bullet. Implementing sustained double-digit interest rates, inflation was lowered to three percent within 10 years. The cost: a brief recession that took place from 1981 to 1982. In Volcker’s time, the safe route of intense interest rates was worth the cost of recessionary forces. Perhaps it is now Jay Powell’s turn to bite the bullet.




Leave a Reply