John Fernandez Suarez

One sentence summary: The potential TikTok ban being discussed in Congress reveals the danger of big technology that is influenced by a potentially malignant threat.

From meme culture to viral trends, it is no secret that social media has a deep grip on our society nowadays. There are numerous giants in the social media space, but TikTok is by far the most popular and addicting. The app, originally called Musically, was created in Shanghai, China in 2014. The social media platform was soon bought up by Bytedance and exploded in popularity in China and worldwide. The main appeal of the app is its short-form content mixed with attention-grabbing stunts or recent trends. There are over 170 million users on TikTok in the U.S. alone, with 60 percent of these belonging to Generation Z, the largest demographic within the country. The app generates revenue using ads and in-app gift purchases, and it explicitly mentions that it does not make money through selling users’ data.

Why are lawmakers in Washington wanting to ban the application? Other big social media companies have similar business models and practices, so why is TikTok unique? Firstly, TikTok has a unique ownership structure. As a Chinese company, there are concerns that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) could use the extensive data collected by TikTok on U.S citizens for potentially damaging reasons for the U.S. This data could be used to blackmail or influence important people to create a desired effect. This is because, in China, there are several strict laws governing cyber and data security, which could be used as a loophole to access said information. The most powerful of these was passed in 1993, which forced Chinese companies to establish a small CCP presence within their applications (AXIOS).  TikTok has contested this, however, stating that their company is now officially registered in the Cayman Islands and is no longer under the authority of the Chinese government. 

There is also a secondary, possibly more important, reason connected to the first, which is the immense cultural power TikTok has, especially amongst the youth. Many in Congress see this cultural power as a possible national security liability. The nightmare situation for the U.S government is, in the middle of an important geopolitical situation, for its populace to turn against the state, thereby harming the bargaining strength of the nation. The most potentially dangerous possibility is if the CCP makes a move on Taiwan, a nominal U.S ally which President Joe Biden has pledged to protect from invasion. The current bill proposed by Congress is designed to remove the perceived liability by forcing the parent company of TikTok, Bytedance, to sell the app within nine months or face a nationwide ban. 

The prospect of a ban on TikTok has led to numerous reactions, with many hailing it as a positive move due to the often harmful trends and antics the app elicits, while others are worried about how this impacts free speech. Personally, I lean more towards the former camp. While I am not a personal user of the app, I find that the human cost of the app is high. In the last few years, there have been tons of deaths from TikTok challenges, the majority of which have involved children. One of the most infamous of these has been the ‘Blackout Challenge,’ which has claimed the lives of 20 children. The reason why children are so drawn to TikTok is the ability to access vast amounts of content in a short period of time, making the app highly addictive. In addition, there has been proof that the app actually does illegally track user data, with one of the lawsuits claiming that “In-app browser usage makes TikTok privy to any confidential information that the user inputs on this third-party website, without the user knowing,” as stated by Forbes.

The main argument against the ban is that it would interfere with freedom of speech. While this is true to a certain extent, that being it could potentially deplatform many people, it also does not take into account that there are numerous other social media sites that people could use such as Snapchat, Instagram, and YouTube. Perhaps a compromise can be reached where TikTok has stricter enforcement on what is allowed on its platform and how it manages data; this way both main issues of the app are resolved. However, at the moment, this seems unlikely, as Washington is out for blood. We will all have to wait to see what the future may bring for TikTok, an app that holds such a profound place in the American conscience and future.

Leave a Reply

Trending