David Song

One-Line Summary: Rwanda will take in Britain’s refugees, but may not be able to provide the best life for them.

U.K. Prime Minister Rishi Sunak and the Conservative Party have pushed for the removal of asylum seekers to third-world countries since 2022. Boris Johnson was the first to introduce the plan, with the aim of reducing the number of illegal crossings of the English Channel. The U.K.’s Supreme Court ruled unanimously against the plan in November of 2023, on the basis that the U.K.-Rwanda Treaty infringes the European Convention on Human Rights — a legal instrument which is effective in UK law — because transferring asylum seekers to Rwanda would put them at risk of refoulement. However, with the passing of the Safety of Rwanda Act, which forces courts and houses to affirm Rwanda is a safe country, the Treaty was able to bypass the court ruling. The U.K.-Rwanda Treaty passed through both Houses and was given Royal Assent by the King on Thursday, April 25, under which the U.K. is legally allowed to send its asylum seekers to Rwanda to have their claims processed. In return, Rwanda will receive £10m over three years in addition to the £220m already paid: £120m once the first 300 asylum seekers are moved, and an additional £171,000 per person to cover a five-year integration program. The Treaty promises that asylum seekers will not be expelled from Rwanda and can either be given asylum or permanent residence. According to Sunak, the first Rwanda flight is set to take off in 10 to 12 weeks.

The Treaty has faced significant pushback from the UN Refugee Agency and various human rights groups, who argue that the plan violates international refugee law and shifts responsibility for the safety of refugees and asylum seekers. There has been extensive coverage of U.K. politics, but what about Rwanda’s perspective on the issue? Why does Kagame want to take the U.K.’s asylum seekers? Holding asylum seekers is expensive, and there would be the additional challenge of integrating new cultures, religions, and ethnic groups into a relatively culturally and ethnically homogenous society. The U.K.-Rwanda plan paints Rwanda as an altruistic haven for refugees, drawing attention away from the human rights abuses which have occurred under Kagame’s regime and furthering the narrative of reconstruction and growth after genocide. Additionally, most asylum seekers do not want to integrate into the country, which already faces issues of poverty and overpopulation. Rwanda will serve only as a transit point for asylum seekers, not a permanent solution to the migration problem. 

Racial divisions in Rwanda, introduced by the German and Belgian colonizers, led to civil war, which culminated in the Rwandan genocide of 1994 — a 100-day long massacre of 800,000 Tutsi civilians, perpetrated by Hutus who had once been neighbors, friends, and family. The genocide was ended by the Rwandan Patriotic Front, establishing a new majority Tutsi unified government led by President Paul Kagame. In the 30 years since then, Rwanda has made significant strides to rebuild the country and better the lives of its people. Rwanda’s GDP has grown an average of 8 percent per year over the last decade, and Rwanda is also considered to have potential to lead Africa in technological innovation. The poverty rate has dropped from 78 percent to 45 percent. Additionally, Rwanda has made significant efforts to have women be at the forefront of this change; roughly 56 percent of the house seats are held by women. But rebuilding efforts have not been quite as effective as they are made out to be. In rural areas, the rate of unemployment remains at a staggering 42 percent, and the infrastructure is far less developed. Though Rwanda’s GDP has grown, the economy is still highly dependent on agriculture and illegitimate exports of coltan from the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). Most Rwandans are concerned about having to share their already limited resources with foreigners.

The plan is also an attempt to portray Rwanda as a place of peace and stability. Rwanda has taken leading roles in the African Union, African Development Bank, and various other organizations. Rwanda came to the aid of the Mozambican government in 2017 by sending soldiers to help quell violent uprisings. But the government of Rwanda has recently come under scrutiny for suspected involvement in the violence in the DRC and abuse of human rights, including torture, censoring opposing media, as well as the killing and jailing of opposing political figures. In the Karongi district, 12 refugees were gunned down by Rwandan police in a protest. Rwanda is only a democratic state in name; it is a one party state in effect. Kagame has held the presidency for 30 years, amending the original 2003 constitution to allow him to serve more than two terms. Rwanda’s political turbulence and tyranny contradict UK claims that it is a safe and stable country for refugees.

The inadequate living conditions within most of Rwanda’s current refugee camps give us a glimpse into what life might be like for asylum seekers in Rwanda once money runs out. Rwanda has taken in a significant number of refugees from nearby, war-torn countries such as the DRC. Nkamira Transit Camp, which holds nearly 6,500 Congolese refugees, provides safety but not much else. The camp is a clutter of plastic houses, and there have been significant budget cuts on food, mattresses, healthcare services, and sanitary necessities. Most Congolese refugees have nowhere to return to after the violence ends, but do not intend on staying in Rwanda. 

In order for Rwanda to pull off this plan financially and symbolically, the asylum seekers need to stay in Rwanda. If they choose to apply for asylum or permanent residence in another country, Rwanda will have to house them for longer while they await decisions. But the U.K.’s financial aid will only account for the costs of five years of housing, plus cash assistance and services after refugee status is granted. To prevent the same backlog that plagues the U.K.’s asylum system, Rwanda will want to take in all the asylum seekers that are sent to Rwanda. But there is an issue with this plan: most refugees see no future in this small, overpopulated, impoverished country. Berenice Nonga, who currently resides in the Gashora Transit Camp, is happy with what Rwanda has given her, but she and the other 2,000 refugees at the Gashora camp have all chosen to move to another country. 

The plan is an attempt by the Rwandan government to embellish their human rights record and strengthen their ‘genocide credit.’ The stark contrast between the empty Hope Hostel in the rich Kagugu suburb of Kigali and the typical camps are evidence of that. It’s also a very short term solution — if the U.K. were to send large numbers of asylum seekers to Rwanda, the number of people awaiting processing would build up as it has in the U.K., causing massive, long term housing costs which neither the funds from the U.K. or Rwanda’s economy can support. 

Leave a Reply

Trending