Olivia Isacson
One-Line Summary: Due to the increasing rates of violence in Haiti, the UN has mandated a multinational security mission in Haiti and other countries have stepped in to deal with the current political situation.
Haiti is the oldest republic and the country that produces the most sugar and coffee in the Caribbean. Yet, due to their debt to France stemming from painful decolonization and poor political leadership, Haiti has become the poorest and most unstable country in the Western Hemisphere. According to the UN, 50 percent of the population is facing food insecurity and 80 percent of the city’s capital, Port-au-Prince, is now controlled by gangs. In 2023, Haiti saw 4,000 people killed and 3,000 more kidnapped in gang-related violence. To deal with the crisis, The UN Security Council authorized a security support mission seven months ago in response to the violence and political insecurity across Haiti. Skeptics, however, have argued that the help will not be as productive as the UN might think. Given the lack of unity in the country already, it does not need more countries interfering or attempting to interfere.
Since the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse in July of 2021, armed gangs have taken over Haiti. Two days after his death, Ariel Henry, a Haitian neurosurgeon and politician, was put into power without elections — much to the dismay of the Haitian people. Although Henry has promised that an election is to come, it has been 33 months since he was put in power, and it seems there is yet to be proper planning for one.
Originally a neurosurgeon who didn’t occupy a non-medicinal role in the government until 2008, he lacks the proper experience to run a country. Henry has failed to give the people the proper election that they want, and has done close to nothing to prevent the violence emerging in Haiti. During Henry’s candidacy, from 2022 to 2023, the number of gang-related violent incidents grew 122 percent. In order to protest Ariel Henry’s presidency, the two largest gangs in Haiti G9 and Gpèpe have decided to join forces. On February 29, Gpèpe and G9 attacked Port-au-Prince targeting government buildings, airports, police stations, and government buildings. The head of G9, Jimmy “Barbecue” Chérizier, explained that the attack was a front to prevent Ariel Henry from coming back from his conference in Kenya during that week. He ultimately wants to address Haiti’s political issues, stating that the current Haitian government is “a cruel system in which a small group of people control all the country’s wealth.” On March 2, in order to contest the prison system, gangs overran two of Haiti’s largest prisons freeing 4,700 inmates. Haiti’s police force, out of fear of being attacked, has yet to fight back against the gangs and failed to do so on that day. March 4, international airports were attacked and closed off, meaning that unless a citizen could rent a helicopter for $10,000 it was impossible to get out of the country. Because of these attacks, the population has been put at risk. Gangs have stolen 260 containers of humanitarian supplies. Around 160,000 people have had to seek refuge in camps with little access to water, food, or shelter, and 300,000 people have been displaced overall. Six out of 10 hospitals had to close due to the lack of supplies to help the swarms of bullet wound victims. Due to the humanitarian crisis in Haiti, the UN and its allied countries as well as the 15-nation Caribbean Country CARICOM have decided to get involved.
While Ariel Henry has been away, multiple forces have decided to come in and help. At a CARICOM conference, Henry was forced to resign by several countries in the Caribbean: Antigua, Barbuda, and Guyana. To take his place, a nine-person transitional government composed of very few Haitians, will deal with the issue and elect a new prime minister and cabinet. A major concern on their part is how to prevent the new government from being run by gangs and desire to elect officials who can serve as a leeway. A worldwide effort has been put in place to aid Haiti. The UN has approved a mandate to start a multinational security support mission to fix the current issue with gangs. Kenya has decided to lead this mission by sending 1,000 officers over to Haiti. Other countries have volunteered their forces: Benin has offered to send 2,000 officers, Bangladesh, Barbados and Chad have volunteered for this mission, and the U.S. has volunteered to fund this mission. However, these current efforts have been put on pause as there are only $11 million set for what will be a $600 million operation. Kenya’s high court also ruled that it was unconstitutional to deploy the nation’s police officers. It has become increasingly clear that this mission led by the UN may not come at the predicted time or even at all.
Although this plan may seem well-intentioned, it is doing nothing but repeating what similar countries have been doing for centuries in Haiti. Haiti gained independence from France in 1804 however the country had to pay 150 million francs to France, making them the first and only country to have actually had to pay colonizers post independence. With a double debt consisting of the fee to pay France as well as the loans having to be taken out, the total amount came to $580 million. The double debt put Haiti on a path leading to economic instability. Following that the U.S. decided to get involved in Haitian politics. In 1994, the U.S. was on the verge of invading Haiti after the country’s first democratically elected president was deposed three years prior. However, then a senator, President Joe Biden argued against the invasion. A decade later, the U.S. military intervened again after rebels threatened to invade the capital in 2004. Neither of the Americans’ plans were accomplished, and they only further complicated relations with Haiti. It is notably a coalition of countries including the U.S., France, and Canada which has been pushing Haiti to keep Ariel Henry in power as he has been helpful in maintaining trade relations. While the country’s gang violence and the number of inhabitants living under the poverty line has dramatically increased, Brian Nicols, assistant secretary of state in the U.S. for Western Hemispheres affairs stated that “[Ariel Henry] is taking difficult steps. Those are actions that we have wanted to see in Haiti for quite some time.” As the population is being put at risk because of Ariel Henry’s mismanagement, the U.S. is backing him up at every turn, even when mistakes are made.
Haiti lost a sense of unity and political independence due to numerous countries’ opposing colonial forces of the people and the government. Barbecue stated that “we will fight Ariel Henry until our last drop of blood, until he resigns. If the international community continues to support Ariel Henry, they will lead us into civil war.” Furthermore, other countries’ involvement in Haitian politics leads to discontent among the current people in power, because bringing in officers will not help with Haiti’s lack of political structure and cohesiveness. These officers don’t speak French or Creole, have trouble asserting authority, and fail to understand the underlying problem with Haitians issues with its governance. Security analyst for Kenya, Francis Maina, stated, “Our police officers cannot and can never be able to contain the threat of the criminality in Haiti.”
Instead of sending their officers into another country, the UN should use the money they have pulled to finance Haitian-led civil society groups that help democratic consolidation. For example, the Haitian Advocacy Working Group (HAWG) seeks to amplify Haitian voices and promote local solutions. HAWG works with the UN and international financial institutions to positively influence U.S. foreign policy towards Haiti. Monique Clesca, Haitian communications specialist stated that: “Civil society got very tired of just saying, ‘This is bad, we condemn, decry,’ etcetera, They decided, ‘Let’s put our money where our mouth is. Let’s be active participants.’” Instead of putting in place missions that will not pan out, it is time to give Haiti the funding and independence to save their own country.




Leave a Reply