Camille Davis
One-Line Summary: Harris’ fight to appeal to moderates and the risks in her actions
On July 21, 2024, Vice President Kamala Harris, a woman of color, assumed a historic role as President Joe Biden’s replacement in the 2025 presidential election. Former President Donald Trump has since sought to subtly criticize and raise questions about Harris’ identities to attract voters. JD Vance, Trump’s running mate, has referred to Harris as a ‘chameleon,’ questioning her accent and demeanors in varied circumstances. Harris has faced further antipathy concerning her perceived character as a ‘radical liberal.’ U.S. Senator Steve Daines remarked at the weekly Republican Senate Leadership press conference that “[Harris] is unelectable because her positions are radical.” Amidst this tension, Harris has been working tirelessly to maintain her reputation as ideologically steady. These efforts manifest greatly in her policies.
Perhaps the group feeling most threatened by Harris’ recent perception is moderates. Moderate voters, or centrist voters, are generally considered to hold more balanced political views. And unfortunately, this underlooked sector of American voters is exponentially valuable this year. While it’s irrefutable that American elected officials have become increasingly politically polarized, research by several professors, including Anthony Fowler from the University of Chicago, has revealed that this does not always mean that voters are following suit. In truth, moderates are more swayed by the personal qualities and ideologies of a political candidate than their party affiliation itself. Fowler and others have managed to remodel the way we segment the electorate in order to reveal what they deem ‘genuine moderates,’ that is, moderates whose beliefs are actually considered balanced. Through such modeling, they’ve been able to see that these moderates leverage particular power in electoral change. On one hand, then, it makes sense that Harris has attempted several times to reverse her past opinions and proposals on certain policies, such as her backtrack on a mandatory buyback program for assault weapons, as well as her previous pursuit to ban fracking. However, these efforts contradict the very image of consistency she aims to project. Since a large reason for Harris’ policy reversals is to appear less radical, her instability in her convictions risks looking insincere. Harris’ efforts to retreat on some of her previously progressive policy proposals will likely exacerbate claims of her being a ‘political chameleon,’ as these reversals may be understood as further evidence of inconsistency. Such a perception could critically deter the very sector that she seeks to win: moderate voters who value consistent and clear ideological stances.
For context, let us examine these reversals. Since 2019, when Harris ran for Democratic presidential nomination, a great deal of her claims and projections have either changed or completely flipped. During a campaign at a forum in Las Vegas five years ago, she said: “We have to have a [firearm] buyback program and I support a mandatory buyback program.” However, she has since asserted herself as a gun-owner and sought to appear more lax when regarding potentially less dangerous firearms. According to BBC, she has dropped her past support for a buyback program for assault weapons. Furthermore, Harris’ previous call for a ban on fracking, a method of extracting oil and natural gas from the ground, has seemed to fade. On Jimmy Fallon’s ‘Tonight Show’ in 2019, Harris stated that she was committed to “putting an end to fracking once and for all.” However, in an interview with CNN in August, Harris vowed to cease her pursuit of a complete ban on fracking, putting greater emphasis on environmental consequences but allowing it to continue. This certainly has something to do with the fact that the crucial swing state of Pennsylvania greatly supports fracking as a source of employment.
Yet, the pressure for these policy reversals is understandable. A few political scientists from Stanford bring up essential points. Primarily, they point to the ‘pull to pander,’ a term referring to a politician’s inclination to cater to public desire in exchange for votes and endorsement. Ken Shotts, a professor of political economy at Stanford Graduate School of Business, examines a co-authored game-theoretic model for the behaviors of current office holders pursuing reelection. In one regard, politicians have the ability to demonstrate a so-called ‘true leadership,’ in which they choose to follow a better policy even in the face of public disgruntlement. However, on the flipside, politicians can pander and support the policy that will earn them votes and public grace, albeit against the best interest of their audience. A lot of the time this theory is dependent upon the time the person has spent in office, the time they have to collect votes, as well as their eligibility to be reelected in the future. Then, this situation seems against Harris, considering that when Biden dropped out, she lacked ample time to organize stances and weigh such options. This idea is affirmed by Shotts, as he says that new leaders who exemplify favorable leadership are privileged with time to allow the public to understand the necessity of their policies. Thus, most politicians would have an electoral incentive to avoid pandering. Conversely, a lack of time would actually increase an incentive to pander, which we would be seeing in Harris’ situation. Another important factor is the closeness in the presidential race. In Pennsylvania, a Washington Post poll finds that Harris and Trump are locked in a “statistical tie.” Pressure in circumstances like this would naturally supplement Harris’ perceived need to pander. However, even with this being true, proposed policy reversals aren’t necessarily the most effective step.
If Harris seeks to truly influence moderate voters on the basis of her ideological stability, then she need not cater to the policies that they want to see, but instead, show consistent doctrines and personality. The affirmation of the convictions on which her policies rest would be a lot more powerful than changing these policies and causing people to question her convictions. Although Harris’ beliefs are most likely genuine, if her policy proposal reversals continue, she will risk undermining public confidence in her ability to uphold her principles.





Leave a Reply