Ethan Ly
One-Line Summary: Democrat Tim Walz and Republican JD Vance offer clashing policies.
This election season has been a tumultuous one. President Biden’s decision to end his efforts at reelection put Vice President Harris on the spot not just on her proposed policies but also on her pick for vice president. So, two weeks after Biden stepped out of the race, she selected Tim Walz, the current governor of Minnesota to be her vice-presidential pick. As for former President Trump’s vice presidential nomination, he selected and received approval for federal Senator JD Vance from the state of Ohio, a switch from his last term and bid for reelection in 2020, where he ran alongside Mike Pence. The change, however, does not come as a surprise. Pence disapproved of Trump’s attempts to overturn the 2020 election. And during the January 6, 2021 insurrection, supporters of the former president stormed the Capitol chanting for Pence’s hanging. In the midst of this consequential election, what can we learn about Vance and Walz?
Walz grew up in a rural patch of Nebraska; his town’s population consisted of only around 3,000 people. After graduating high school, Walz joined the National Guard in 1982, allowing him to collect tuition aid from the G.I. Bill and enroll at Nebraska’s Chadron State College. He ultimately ended up in Mankato, Minnesota in 1996 to teach at the town’s high school. In 2006, Walz ran for and won Minnesota’s first congressional district seat for the House as a Democrat, becoming the second in his party in around a century to be elected to the position. He was reelected to the role five times. And in 2018, he was chosen as Minnesota’s governor and reelected in 2022.
In Congress, where he held his role for 12 years, Walz acted as a centrist-Democrat—leaning left on social issues, such as abortion, but swaying right or moderate on economic issues. The Lugar Center at Georgetown University positioned Walz seventh on their report of the most bipartisan members in the House of Representatives. Members of his own party corroborate those statements, including former Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, who referred to him as “right down the middle, he’s a heartland-of-America Democrat” on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe.” Republicans, however, believe otherwise. The party’s vice-presidential nominee JD Vance said that “[Walz has] been one of the most far-left radicals in the entire United States government at any level.”
One of Walz’s appeals in this election is his relatability to members of the working class and draw in the Midwest. This is evident when Walz, as Minnesota’s governor, advocated for and passed legislation allocating a great deal of tax credit—a number in the hundreds of millions of dollars—to parents in the state, alleviating their financial burdens at the state level. Walz has also done much to improve taxation for Minnesotans. With a $3.71 billion surplus in the state’s 2024 to 2025 budget, he enacted legislation providing payments to state residents up to a set income, passing the highest tax cut in state history. Overall, his economic policies mainly protect the financial stability of the middle class.
Trump and his 2024 running-mate Vance differ from each other in their origins. While the former president was raised by a well-off real estate tycoon, Vance grew up in a middle class family surrounded by domestic issues. He was born in Middletown, Ohio, and throughout a part of his youth, he lived in Jackson, Kentucky with his mother’s grandparents as his mother battled a drug addiction. Published in 2016, he wrote about Appalachian culture in Kentucky and his hometown’s socioeconomic issues in a memoir titled Hillbilly Elegy. After graduating from Yale Law School, he worked three stints over two years: working for Republican Senator John Cornyn, clerking for a district judge in Kentucky, and serving as a corporate lawyer for Sidley Austin. Vance then moved to Silicon Valley, spending a brief five years in the venture capital industry. He began working for right-leaning venture capitalist Peter Thiel, who would fund his later pursuits, both venture-capital-related and political. Ultimately, Vance’s memoir and narrative of social mobility have largely shaped his populist appeal.
A flashpoint highlighting his venture into politics were his comments and views during the 2016 election and shortly afterwards sharp criticism of then-candidate Trump. Vance made clear his dislike for the Republican presidential candidate. In August 2016, during an interview with NPR, Vance expressed his refusal to endorse Trump, revealing his voting options: “I might have to hold my nose and vote for Hillary Clinton […] [b]ut I think that I’m going to vote third party because I can’t stomach Trump.” In his 2022 campaign to serve as a Senator at the federal level, however, he rescinded his harsh criticism of Trump, apologizing for his own comments and rising as a firm supporter. An example of political opportunism? Vance’s 180-degree turnaround from referring to Trump as “America’s Hilter” to being one of his biggest advocates and running mate.
Vance’s stance on policies closely align with that of his running mate. Abortion is a hot issue this season, and Vance has said that he stands firmly pro-life. As for economic policy, Vance has advocated for protectionist ideas since campaigning for Senator in Ohio, such as tariffs on foreign—notably Chinese—imports to support U.S. jobs and manufacturing. Protectionist policies, however, function to an extent. Too extreme tariffs—including Trump’s proposed 10 percent levies on all imports of foreign products—could backfire since they tend to increase the price of imports. Since these levies also allow domestic manufacturers to exploit higher prices, taking advantage of profits, U.S. consumers end up taxed. Both Vance and Trump stand strongly against the flow of immigrants across the Southern border into the U.S., an issue that Trump emphasized in his 2016 election run for president. If elected, Trump says he would carry out efforts of mass deportation, which according to him would be, “the largest deportation in American history.” Vance has insistently echoed Trump’s false rumors of Haitian immigrants eating pets in Springfield, Ohio.
As U.S. voters weigh their thoughts on Walz, they should consider his moderate status in congress, verified by The Lugar Center’s report on the most bipartisan members in the House. Additionally, they should note his efforts as Minnesota’s Governor to improve taxation in the state. His advocacy of tax cuts for the working class should also be paid attention to.
Vance, however, has portrayed himself as someone mired in controversy. Spreading the rumors of Haitian immigrants eating pets in Ohio only backfired on him, resulting in debunkings of his statements by the state’s Republican governor. He is painting himself as an untrustworthy leader. Even worse, he doubled down on his comments, saying, “I want to take aim at the left, specifically the childless left, because I think the rejection of the American family is perhaps the most pernicious and most evil thing that the left has done in this country.” He seemingly fails to understand the importance of single female voters this election season.Vance will most likely lose such voters, who account for a significant portion of the female population. Overall, polls have found Vance less likable in the public’s view since his naming as Trump’s vice-presidential nominee.
Currently, the Republican vice-presidential nominee trails his Democratic opponent. One can only assume that the favorability of Tim Walz and JD Vance will impact the 2024 presidential election in November.





Leave a Reply