Isabella Park
One-Line Summary: Although Trump’s unfounded confidence and Harris’ idealistic humanitarianism highly contrast in their messaging, neither candidate has a viable plan for Gaza.
During the first debate between US presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump on September 10, Gaza was only mentioned in four statements throughout the one hour and 45 minutes total running time. Hence, it is unsurprising that the few statements made did not shed light on any novel or specific policy initiatives on the issue. Although both candidates declared vague ideological standings, neither clarified definite plans on how to de-escalate the violence in the region. While Trump is far more ardent in his support of Netanyahu, Harris is comparatively focused on rectifying humanitarian impacts. Yet, neither is making concrete promises on bringing Hamas and the Israel Defense Force (IDF) to the negotiation table.
Harris’ stance on the War in Gaza has been quite consistent since her tenure as the Vice President under the Biden Administration. Aligned with the decades-long pro-Israeli stance of the U.S. government, she opposes arms embargoes and emphasizes the release of hostages. These stances were evident when Harris stated that “Israel has a right to defend itself” during the first presidential debate. However, she is comparatively moderate in regard to the violence committed in Gaza, stating during the presidential debate “how [Israel] does so matters,” meaning Israel’s right to self-defense does not justify extreme collateral damage. Other statements made during the debate included her emphasis on how “we must have a two-state solution where we can rebuild Gaza” where Palestinians have “security, self-determination and the dignity they so rightfully deserve.” Such statements corroborate concern for the state of civilians, which she showed as well previously when she said she “will not be silent” about the casualties in Gaza. Her message at the presidential debate has made it clear that she will not be implementing any substantial legislative shifts if elected, given the lack of statements on changes.
Former President Trump has historically been far more supportive of Netanyahu in general and has aligned himself with the general U.S. government stance of protecting Israeli sovereignty. Yet, similarly to Harris, Trump’s only statement during the debate on how he would improve the situation was his assertion that he would “get that settled and fast” without clarifying how that would be possible. However, he believes a two-state solution is unrealistic given current circumstances, along with the consideration of how his two-state solution negotiations failed during his own presidency for failing to gain Palestinian support. His previous sentiments regarding Netanyahu, such as his comment on their “very good relationship” during Netanyahu’s July visit, further signal that Trump will be more supportive compared to Harris, at least in public. Trump has also commented on the negative impacts of a prolonged war on the Israeli public image, and reversed the U.S. government’s decades-long opposition to the Israeli settlement of Palestinian territory during his presidency. In regards to his ideal resolution of the War in Gaza, Trump has told Netanyahu during a meeting in late-July to “get your victory and get it over with” because “the killing has to stop”; all of these statements point to a Trump administration with increased public support for Israeli military interests.
On the wider topic of general stances on the pro-Palestine protests and anti-semitism, Harris and Trump have shown very different views. In response to the rise of pro-Palestinian protests, Harris commented during an interview in July with The Nation that she “understand[s] the emotion behind it” even though she doesn’t “wholesale endorse their points.” To address the increasing anti-semitism, the Biden-Harris administration also released the first-ever national strategy against such actions. On the contrary, Trump has called protestors “pro-Hamas thugs” and “jihad sympathizers” during his meeting with Netanyahu in late-July, calling for police crackdowns. He has also employed a very wide definition of antisemitism, labeling any criticism of Israel as antisemitism.
Despite their seemingly different approaches to the War in Gaza, neither candidate has a sufficiently concrete plan for de-escalation; it is hence doubtful how much practical weight any statements carry. Even though Harris had commented multiple times on the importance of humanitarian priorities, it is unclear how she could effectively protect Palestinian civilians while not completely alienating Netanyahu. Due to America’s relationship with Israel and the role the state plays as the sole unitarily Western ally in an overwhelmingly Arab region, it will be impossible for Harris to be independent of Netanhyahu’s interests. However, Netanyahu’s priorities are focused on cementing his political power in the short term instead of achieving long-term peace and stability in the region. This was clear in 2020 when he discredited any police action or prosecution for his charges of bribery, fraud, and breach of trust, denouncing his opposition as traitors. Such priorities are incompatible with the U.S. priorities of de-escalating the conflict. Regardless of Harris’ personal support for refugees or civilians, there is no guarantee that tangible improvements in quality of life can be achieved while the U.S. is allied with Israel. Biden clearly did not succeed in achieving this balance, as shown by his inability to influence Netanyahu on the issue of humanitarian aid, which led to him being criticized for being held to Netanyahu’s demands. Additionally, her neutral approach to wording opinions on pro-Palestine protestors and antisemitism will cause less chaos relative to Trump’s volatile language, but her vague statements could simultaneously lead to dissatisfaction from politically active voters. The Uncommitted movement, a pro-Palestine group originally focused on pressuring a ceasefire, has already demonstrated this issue by stating that it is “impossible for us to endorse her campaign, [but] we still recognize very clearly that there’s a need to oppose Donald Trump.”
Trump’s plans are equally unviable. Although he will certainly cater to Netanyahu’s priorities, such plans will not gain cooperation from Hamas. As seen by the failure of his previous “Deal of the Century” (a Middle East peace plan that did not guarantee a sovereign Palestinian state) that was rejected by the Palestinian Authority, the chances of Trump proposing a charitable plan that meets the demands of Hamas is all but nonexistent. It is regrettable, then, that he has not provided any alternative to the two-state solution that he has determined to be impractical. Instead, most of his rhetoric has focused on the ideological cause of protecting Israel and achieving victory, which directly contradicts any points that he has made about protecting hostages or civilians. As of now, it is unclear what his plan is for swiftly ending the war once in office, for the only realistic solution without negotiation would be increased military support; direct action by the U.S. government to aid Israeli military operations in residential areas would elicit extreme international criticism, however. Even as his plan is unclear, it is guaranteed that Trump’s opposition to pro-Palestine protests and the possibility of police crackdowns will worsen domestic chaos.
Given the useless nature of both approaches to Gaza along with the diminished significance of Gaza for domestic voters, it might seem as if such statements will not influence the election in November. Although the sheer number of single-issue voters on the War in Gaza is extremely small (foreign policy was the most important issue for only one percent of voters), the U.S. electoral college means that the close margins in swing states could be influenced by this issue. For example, Cori Bush, a democrat lost her primary in Missouri as an incumbent by a close margin. This was because the super PAC United Democracy Movement,which was tied to a pro-Israel lobby, spent nearly $9 million endorsing the winning candidate. In regions such as Michigan or Detroit with high concentrations of Americans that claim Middle Eastern descent, actions such as the declaration of over 100,000 voters in the Michigan primaries as uncommitted in February could easily swing the election to either side.
Harris might support negotiations and criticize casualties but has no viable plan on how to achieve that while maintaining a semblance of allyship with Netanyahu. Trump’s statements point to significantly larger support for Israel’s military actions to ensure a victory, which would be devastating for civilians. Either way, neither candidate has a concrete plan to de-escalate the region with minimal casualties. Despite this unfortunate reality, the war in Gaza could be crucial in deciding a winner in November.





Leave a Reply