David Song
One-Line Summary: Restrictive local zoning laws will prevent Harris from stimulating affordable housing
Rent and home pricing have steadily increased over the last decade and a half. Millions of Americans today find themselves unable to afford housing, which is why voters are glad that the issue is finally receiving the attention it deserves. Vice President Kamala Harris has made an effort to place the housing crisis at the forefront of her campaign; she recently released an ad outlining her plan to address the affordable housing issue. Her policy consists of three main goals: down payment assistance for first-time homebuyers, regulating corporate investors and landlords, and constructing three million new affordable housing units. Prominent economists and the Federal Reserve Chair agree that the core of the housing issue is low supply. There are simply too many housing units on the market period, contributing to the lack of affordable homes. Indeed, Zillow reports a deficit of 1.35 million homes across 35 surveyed metropolitan areas. The proposed 25,000 dollar down payment assistance for first-time homebuyers will not necessarily have positive effects if supply does not increase. In fact, it is possible that housing prices may even inflate further as demand increases for the few affordable homes on the market. Thus, the success of Harris’ plan will be primarily determined by whether or not she will be able to complete the second and third parts of her plan. I argue that the monopolized housing construction market and restrictive laws will prevent governments from effectively stimulating affordable housing construction, and tightening restrictions for corporations will have adverse, unintended consequences.
After the 2006 US housing bubble, most developers were forced out of the market or to merge with others in order to stay afloat. Housing construction today essentially qualifies as a monopolistic competition between several large corporations, the largest of these being D.R. Horton. Although construction corporations such as D.R. Horton have begun shifting towards affordable housing—housing for which a (low or moderate income) occupant is paying no more than 30 percent of their income for housing costs—to meet the high demand, they cannot be relied on to alleviate the problem. What’s more, the majority of these new housing units are multi-family, which is averse to the demands of younger consumers. The corporations build when it is lucrative and a safe investment, constructing homes on high-value, suburbanized land, and avoiding the construction of affordable housing. Building so many new housing units will require diversifying the construction landscape and allowing smaller developers to regain a foothold in the market.
Harris outlines several strategies to stimulate affordable home construction on a local scale. She explains that the policy would aim to “streamline permitting processes and reviews, including for transit-oriented and conversion development, so builders can get homes on the market sooner and bring down costs.” Her explanation here is vague, and it is unclear how exactly she will remove these barriers. Harris also plans to spend 40 billion on a housing innovation fund for local governments to design their own solutions to tackle the housing issue. This money will likely go towards supporting smaller building agencies, however, one major blockade still stands in the way of rapid construction: NIMBY (Not In My Backyard) backed zoning laws. These city and town laws set strict single-family zoning regulations, making it illegal to build apartments in nearly all residential areas and increasing minimum lot sizes. These laws are deeply rooted in local communities within states like Massachusetts, California, and New York, and removing them will certainly upset a large number of voters. Although views are slowly being shifted to support the construction of affordable housing, zoning laws are unlikely to become more lenient in near future. Additionally, Increasing home supply and affordability would cause homeowners’ properties to depreciate, making home-owning a less reliable investment and wealth-building strategy and undermining the single largest asset for middle-class generational wealth accumulation in America.
Assuming the policy is able to expedite permit processes and stimulate affordable housing construction across the country, Harris still has to ensure that houses go to residents and not to corporate investors and landlords, or if they do, that rent prices will be kept low enough to be affordable. Harris’ Stop Predatory Investing Act will remove Federal tax benefits from investors which buy up large numbers of single family rental homes. According to CoreLogic, a quarter of single family homes sold in 2022 were bought by investors, many of whom were affiliated with large hedge funds. Investors often sell or rent out these homes, systematically raising prices to turn huge profits; although a considerable number of these investors are local and small scale, even small scale investors can contribute to cost increases. In reality, Harris’ act may not do much to actually stop this investment; purchasing, renting out, and even just holding large amounts of residential real estate has turned corporations enormous profits in the last decade. Cutting tax credits may not be enough to disincentivize corporate investment into residential real estate. Because renting property becomes more and more profitable at scale, a majority of apartment complexes are owned by big businesses, and Harris can do nothing about that. These large landlords are in a position to raise rent prices and take advantage of vulnerable citizens. To control widespread rent increases, Harris proposes tighter rent control policies. But prominent economists stand against rent control for a reason; rent control disincentivizes businesses from acquiring large multi-family properties, thus reducing the demand for construction of those properties. While central bank interest rate hikes influenced the lack of investment in new building permits, September 2022 rent control policies also likely contributed to the staggering 50 percent decrease in permits. Reducing construction is precisely the opposite of what Harris wants to do, and while this may provide an opportunity for new builders, backed by the policy’s innovation funds, to make some headway, it is unlikely that 40 billion, spread across the whole nation, can meet this demand.
Because all the funds and tax incentives can only do so much to bring small developers and first-time homebuyers into the market, Harris’ policy may not be able to restrain corporations or produce new housing. However, what Harris has done is placed the affordable housing conversation into the limelight and put forth a real actionable plan to address the issue, continuing and fueling discourse among economists and everyday people to work towards a collective solution.





Leave a Reply