Andrew Liu
One Line Summary: In its latest rate cut, the Federal Reserve has set its focus on economic health rather than inflation.
The Federal Reserve’s purpose can be likened to balancing a seesaw. On one side sits price control: the need to prevent inflation and overheating of the economy. On the other side sits employment maximization: the hope of keeping enough economic growth so that new jobs are always in supply. In this, the Fed targets an unemployment rate of under 5% and an inflation rate of under 2%. As the Federal Reserve attempts to guide the U.S. economy using a mix of interest rates and open market operations, there is always a tradeoff between these two parts of its dual mandate. When interest rates go up to control prices, the ability to create jobs decreases. Vice versa, when interest rates go down to create jobs, prices and inflation are liable to increase. It is extremely difficult for the Federal Reserve to succeed in keeping all parts of the economy healthy, especially after fiscal shocks during the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet, as the sole guide to economic control in the U.S., it must try to strike the balance. After all, the jobs and livelihoods of over 300 million people rest on the impacts of its decisions.
Over the past year, the Federal Reserve has focused on the price control side of the seesaw. By keeping interest rates hiked at 5.25 to 5.5 percent, the central bank has hoped to prevent the continued rise of inflation. It has done this by sacrificing economic growth and job growth by extension. Through the lens of benefitting the average American, inflation is particularly harmful because for every dollar that prices rise, workers and families find it more difficult to purchase food and basic necessities. Often, this disproportionately affects working-class Americans whose wealth consists of less appreciable assets like stocks or real estate. Following the skyrocketing prices of 2022, the Federal Reserve made the decision that preventing the rise of inflation would be more important for Americans than a loss of jobs. This was the reasoning behind the interest rate hike. However, the period of tightening over the past year has stood out compared to previous interest rate cycles in the past few decades.
When interest rates are held high, the rate of economic growth slows as the price of capital increases. When the Federal Reserve raises its target rates, it is increasing the interest rate at which banks can lend money to each other, known as the Federal Funds rate. As banks find it more costly to lend money to each other, to compensate they will begin to raise the rates on the loans that they offer to consumers. Ordinary people soon find it more expensive to take out loans and access capital, explaining why higher interest rates prevent startups and stall business growth. Moreover, as an extension of the Loanable Funds Market, services like mortgages become far more expensive. This increases the cost of housing, which is tied to the cost of mortgages. During the seventies stagflation, for example, not only did high interest rates lead to stagnant economic growth, but those same interest rates failed to prevent inflation, albeit due to outside factors such as the oil embargo. Although that would truly be the worst scenario, interestingly, the recent rate hold has not impacted the growth of the economy as greatly as expected. Unemployment has only begun to creep towards the Fed’s limit of 5% this summer, disregarding the unemployment jump from incorrect job data in May of 2020. Amidst this, the rate of GDP growth has also remained stable. There are many reasons for this resilience against high interest rates, including arguments about how excess savings during the pandemic helped boost the consumer economy. By cutting rates now, they have the opportunity to stifle inflation whilst simultaneously keeping economic growth. In doing so, they would help preserve hundreds of thousands of jobs.
To understand the Federal Reserve’s process in the recent rate cut, it is critical to understand the options at hand. Firstly, at this point, holding interest rates for even longer was not much of an option for Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell. From the start, the purpose of the holdout since 2023 was not to decrease inflation further. The bulk of inflation had already finished by the first quarter of 2023. Rather, the purpose of the interest hold was to prevent any symptoms of bounceback with inflation. In accordance with this goal, the high interest rates have indeed kept inflation stable at three percent, going on two percent through the entire time period. Although this is not yet at the sub-two percent expectations from the 2010s, it no longer represents the danger that it did in 2022. Certainly, at this point, inflation no longer heavily outweighs job creation in the Federal Reserve’s view. As a result, when early summer produced poor job data, it was almost guaranteed that a rate cut would occur. In fact, Chair Powell signaled the September rate cut almost a month in advance. This preliminary announcement was received well in the business sphere but led to some cautionary thoughts in the academic community at first.
The Federal Reserve had two options, a 0.25 percent increment or a 0.5 percent increment. A 0.25 percent increment decrease would have represented the norm for interest rate changes. On the other hand, a hypothetical 0.5 percent increment decrease would be the path of more rapid rate cuts, at the cost of higher risk. Chair Powell and the entirety of the Federal Open Market Committee—except for the lone dissenter of Federal Reserve Governor Bowman—decided to go with the 0.5 percent increment decrease. The big reveal of the decision, went against the predictions of most academic economists who had expected the Federal Reserve to take the safer route in shifting focus towards the economy. Yet, from an overhead point of view, the choice was not overly drastic.
The average 12-month period it takes for an economic policy change to disseminate its effects on the wider market means that the quarter of a percent difference will not rapidly accelerate inflation. Even if it does allow inflation to loosen, the effects will occur over an extended timeframe. As such, the greater increment simply represents that at this moment, a possible recession is a greater danger to the general population than a one percent increase in inflation. Alternatively, some have said that the increased increment may simply be a correction for not starting the process eight weeks earlier at the previous Federal Reserve meeting. No matter what, the key is that the Federal Reserve has begun shifting its attention towards its other mandate of economic growth and job creation.
At this point, with the Federal Reserve seemingly focusing less on price control, it is easy to ask why prices have not dropped for general consumers. Unfortunately, prices will stay where they are, and in fact they will continue to increase. After all, the Federal Reserve’s goal was only to prevent the uncontrolled growth of inflation, still allowing the economy to undergo stable inflation as a stimulant for growth.
When the average consumer talks about lowering prices, the metric they should be looking for is average wage growth against inflation. Although inflation has outpaced wage growth during the past few years, the purpose of taming inflation was precisely to allow wage growth gain. The moment when wage growth passes inflation will be the moment when consumers can ‘perceive’ prices to have lowered. Since the American economy is almost uniquely reliant upon consumerism and the willingness to continue buying, this perception of pricing in the market relative to income is actually key to overall economic growth. Over the past year, the Federal Reserve tried so hard to tame inflation precisely for this reason, to prevent the loss of the consumerist mentality. Unfortunately, the average growth of wages is much slower than most people think, so it will take several years for a readjustment back to the relative prices of the 2010s to occur. However, at least we have not slipped into an anti-consumerist deflationary period, similar to China’s current situation.
The sectors in which the rate cut will have the most immediate large-scale impact are housing and other types of consumer loans. Since the banks that have been instantly impacted by lowered rates are the same entities that issue consumer loans, financial items such as mortgages will be the first to see readjustments following the rate cut.
All in all, as the Federal Reserve shifts its focus from price control to economic stimulation, we finally see the path that Chair Powell is willing to take. With the presidential elections coming up and both the cost of living and job security being key issues, the Federal Reserve will play a key role in the months ahead.





Leave a Reply