Olivia Isacson

One Line Summary: The outcome of the general elections and its consequences for the future of the Tory party. 

The race to lead Britain’s conservatives was recently narrowed to two right-wing candidates on October 9th: Kemi Badenoch and Robert Jenrick. Founded in 1834, the Tory conservative party is one of the two dominant political groups in Britain. The ballots have been sent out, and on November 2nd, the winner will be announced to preside over Tory. Although both candidates seek to emulate Margaret Thatcher, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from 1979 to 1990 and Leader of the Conservative party from 1975 to 1990, Badenoch and Jenrick’s polarizing positions mean that no matter who is chosen, neither is likely to remain in the role for long enough to create as significant a legacy as the Iron Lady. Both candidates will likely continue the Conservative party’s recent trend of changing through Party Leaders in rapid succession: Liz Truss’s tenure famously lasted for only 44 days in 2022. Badenoch and Jenrick’s differences, as well as the Tory party’s previous failures, will likely result in neither candidate remaining in power for long, creating further division within the party. 

Kemi Badenoch is seen as a favorite to the right, as her political views align with those of many British republicans. Before running for office as leader of the Tory, Badenoch served as Minister for Women and Equalities, as well as Secretary of State for Business and Trade, where she connected with the British people and developed a conservative perspective. She states that she became more conservative as “a reaction to the very spoiled, entitled, privileged, metropolitan elite-in-training at university.” Badenoch grew up in Nigeria and later moved to London for her studies, viewing Margaret Thatcher as her heroine. Badenoch seeks to get rid of “nasty identity politics” and is known for her robust views, gaining widespread attention for describing maternity pay as “excessive” during the Conservative Party Conference in Birmingham. She first ran for conservative leader in 2022 following Boris Johnson’s resignation and came in fourth. 

Robert Jenrick served as the minister of state for immigration from the 25th of October 2022 to the 6th of December 2023. He resigned from his role due to his disapproval of Rishi Sunak’s emergency Rwanda legislation, which he claimed “does not go far enough” in creating stronger border control. Jenrick has spoken about Tory’s failures in cutting immigration, with plans to have the United Kingdom withdraw from the European Convention of Human Rights. In 2023, he gained fame for painting over murals of cartoon characters at children’s asylum centers, arguing that they were too welcoming. Jenrick also idolizes Margaret Thatcher, going so far as to give his daughter “Thatcher” as a middle name.

Robert Jenrick and Kemi Badenoch will both have a serious undertaking once in power to help rebuild the Tory party’s status. The right-of-center party suffered a loss in July at the hands of the Labor party, the center-left political party of the United Kingdom. The Tory party lost more than 200 seats to the Labor Party, bringing their total tally to 121 in the government. Their task will be to maintain the party’s reputation and return Tory to power at the next election. The Tory conservative party has dramatically reshaped Britain since being in power in 2010: cutting spending on public services, welfare, and public budgets for investments. Despite positioning themselves as a party of low taxation, taxes have increased over the past 10 years as a result of recent policies. After the conservative parties’ recent economic failures, it remains unclear if these candidates can appeal to the people’s needs to remain in office long enough to make significant changes. 

Many believe that the election of Badenoch or Jenrich will deter the party from gaining popularity and all but guarantee Labor’s reelection in 2029. The choice of the two candidates to lead Tory defied the pattern set by the previous round of voting, excluding two center-right candidates, James Cleverly and Tom Tugendhat. James Cleverly was an army reserve officer who had been serving as Shadow Home Secretary. He was known as “Mr. Nice Guy” and had less extreme views compared to Badenoch and Jenrick. The British people’s choice of the two much more conservative politicians highlights the lack of political cohesiveness present in England. According to a review by King’s College in London, people on both sides of the Brexit vote dislike the opposing side intensely even though they don’t disagree on their issues. The lack of a central party and point of view is shown through the choice of the two very right-wing candidates. Badenoch and Jenrick will not be able to appeal to any left-wing voters and will guarantee the reelection of the Labour Party, which represents a wide variety of political ideas. Chair of the Labour Party Ellie Reeves stated that “after months of gaffes, wild unfunded policies and infighting, Tory members now have the unenviable task of choosing between two of the architects of Tory failure.” 

Moreover, Jenrick and Badenoch’s policies highlight their lack of preparation in handling pressing British issues. Instead of focusing on Britain’s high taxation and struggling public services, Robert Jenrick chose to concentrate on capping immigration and “defending our culture”, whereas Badenoch has wanted to return to focusing on core conservative values. Tim Bale, professor of politics at the University of London, even said “the fact that the contest has come down to two avowedly Thatcherite culture warriors suggests we’re in for a few years of a Conservative Party obsessing about immigration, the trans issue, and the supposedly exorbitant cost of action on climate change, rather than what most voters really care about,” highlighting the inadequacies of both candidates in appealing to a wide range of voters. Although both candidates compare themselves to Margaret Thatcher, Thatcher was able to implement policies that transformed Britain’s stagnant economy, while both Badenoch and Jenrick seem to be focused on specific matters that are unable to create significant change. The candidate’s faults are also shown through their public images. Badenoch is also known for speaking her mind and often making ignorant claims. Jenrick has been accused of the opposite, being a “conviction politician” whose views quickly shift when evidence changes.  Ultimately, the election will likely result in neither candidate remaining in power for very long. Centrist Conservative groups refused to endorse Robert Jenrick or Kemi Badenoch and said in a statement that “both have used rhetoric and focused on issues which are far and away from the party at its best.” Conservative insiders have also questioned the likelihood of either candidate taking the party to the next general election in 2029, due to the lack of political unity within the party. Many are comparing the two candidates to Liz Truss, who left office after 44 days, or Rishi Sunak, who also left prematurely. A poll conducted by the Guardian found that half of Tory councils do not believe Jenrick or Badenoch can win the next election. Kemi Badenoch and Robert Jenrick’s views and policies will likely result in the failure of the Tory party in the next 2024 general election, as without the support and confidence of their own party, they are unlikely to convince the broader public.

Leave a Reply

Trending