Yara Handschin

One Line Summary: As the 2024 election nears, Harris and Trump push opposing immigration policies focused on enforcement, lacking systemic reform.

With the 2024 presidential race underway, the two major party candidates Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump are doubling down on their attempts to mobilize a common electorate for their respective campaigns. One significant issue emerging in these concurrent efforts is immigration. The U.S.-Mexico border has been a contentious political issue for the last decade, prompting a lengthy series of federal responses which both loosened border restrictions, like the 2012 Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), and tightened them, like the 2017 family separation policy. For the general public, opinion on the topic has soured severely, but distaste for an open border cannot solely be attributed to an uptick in crossings. Nevertheless, the widespread discontent with the state of border security and the handling of recurring migrant influxes has set the stage for more severe political action and rhetoric in the coming election cycle. 

Immigration, whether legal or not, has had an overall positive effect on the state of the nation. Some policymakers and the general public have blamed immigration for slowing U.S. wage growth since the 1970s, a notion that most academic research contradicts. Available evidence from the U.S. Census Bureau suggests that immigration leads to more innovation, a more educated workforce, greater occupational specialization, better matching of the workforce with jobs, and higher overall economic productivity. U.S. citizens seem ignorant of these positive impacts—a fact that may be partly ascribable to the exploitation of immigration as a political catalyst to appeal to voters. So far in the 2024 election cycle, Trump’s rally speeches have consistently showcased a barrage of exaggerations as well as blatant lies on the subject of immigrants and crime—a pattern that suggests a deliberate amplification of fear as a means to galvanize the American public. Notable exemplifiers of what journalist Daniel Dale describes as Trump’s “lying spree” include his comments about immigrants in Springfield, Ohio: “eating the pets”; a colorful story about Venezuelan authorities busing gang members into the U.S.; and a claim about large numbers of migrants entering the country from mental health facilities that foreign governments had intentionally emptied.

The harsh public outcry towards immigration may appear unwarranted, but it has certainly had a substantial impact on U.S. policy. This is particularly noticeable within the Democratic Party, which has been increasingly embracing stronger border policies and making a departure from previous, more liberal positions. In June, the Biden-Harris ticket issued a sweeping asylum ban that allows migrants caught crossing the border illegally to be quickly deported or turned back to Mexico once the daily average number of border arrests surpasses 2,500 for seven straight days. More recently, Harris has also endorsed a bipartisan proposal that would increase border patrol agents and tighten asylum criteria—steps so patently conservative that Trump faced major backlash from Senior Senate Republicans for his continued rallying against them.

Despite the rightward shift democratic immigration policy has experienced, the two parties still differ greatly in the severity of their approaches to the issue. While Harris is pledging to be “tough” on the border, Trump aims to tackle the crisis with the iron fist of protectionist policy he wielded during his 2016 presidential term—an approach with little room for compassion. Should he be granted another term in the Oval Office, Trump will likely reintroduce Migrant Protection Protocols (MPP) and Asylum Cooperation Agreements (ACAs), both of which have faced significant controversy for their impact on asylum seekers and border communities. The MPP, often referred to as the “Remain in Mexico” policy, required asylum seekers to wait in Mexico while their cases were processed in U.S. immigration courts. This policy led to overcrowded, unsafe conditions in border cities, where prospective immigrants were vulnerable to violence, exploitation, and inadequate access to resources. The Asylum Cooperation Agreements (ACAs), implemented with countries like Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador, aimed to reroute asylum seekers to these countries instead of allowing them entry to the U.S. Both policies have been condemned for bypassing the domestic asylum process and increasing humanitarian strain on border communities, ultimately limiting the accessibility of asylum from the U.S. Harris, on the other hand, is expected to focus on creating legal pathways to citizenship, while further strengthening security measures by investing in the fortification of the border workforce. Notably, she too intends to reduce access to asylum—just to a lesser degree than Trump. 

Both candidates propose measures to address border issues, yet neither is likely to resolve the systemic dysfunction within the U.S. immigration system. Unfortunately, shying away from significant bureaucratic reform and opting instead for enforcement-only approaches will not remedy the shortcomings of current judicial and refugee processing. Under-resourced immigration courts and an overwhelmed asylum system, the true culprits of the border crisis, are left unaddressed as border security is held up as its holistic solution. If both candidates continue to play hooky with their obligations towards both a comprehensive overhaul of the current border management system and the asylum-seekers themselves, U.S. immigration politics will face a bleak future of humanitarian crises, deepening inefficiencies, and escalating partisan gridlock that will fail to address the core issues plaguing the framework.

This election will be a referendum on the national identity of America. As voters weigh their options, they must consider the long-term implications of each candidate’s stance—not only for the lives of those seeking refuge but for the nation’s ethos. Ultimately though, the course of U.S. immigration policy hinges on the willingness of its leaders to prioritize systemic reforms, refrain from exploiting immigration as a divisive political weapon, and embrace policies that honor both security and humanity.

Leave a Reply

Trending