Andrew Liu
One Line Summary: As the balance of the Senate lies in a handful of close elections, the consequences will reverberate across the American government.
As the U.S. presidential election approaches on November 5, all eyes are focused on Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump. However, for a certain portion of the country, the Congressional elections may call for some attention. A third of the Senate is up for reelection this year, and with margins tighter than ever, both Democrats and Republicans know that winning the Senate could be just as crucial as the presidency.
What is the significance of polling data in the upcoming congressional elections? For each of the 33 ongoing Senate races, polling agencies take representative surveys and samples from within a respective senatorial district. Then, they use different weighting systems and models to calculate public opinion, thus generating a projected winner for the election. Since separate polling agencies will weigh their models differently, they may project conflicting winners in close elections. In spite of their limitations, however, polls do reveal which races are close and which are not. As of October 25, the polls have identified four toss-up states, where the election could go either way. Importantly, three of these tossups, namely, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, have Democratic incumbents. The polls also suggest another notable dynamic: the Democratic incumbent state of Montana is currently leaning Republican.
To put these polls into perspective, it is important to define the margins within Congress. Currently, the Democratic Party holds a majority in the Senate, while the Republican Party controls the House of Representatives. However, the Democratic Party only holds a thin majority in the Senate: 51 seats to 49 Republican seats. As a result, the Republican Party only needs to turn two Senate seats from blue to red to gain control. With four Democratic incumbents and no Republican incumbents at risk of losing their respective elections, the polls tilt towards a possible Republican majority in the Senate (51 Republican to 49 Democrat seats) for the next two years.
Now, let’s take a closer look at the Democratic incumbents at risk. Since senatorial races only focus on voters in their district, the factors that influence these elections are distinct in each state. For example, take the race between Democrat Bob Casey and Republican David McCormick in the battleground state of Pennsylvania. Casey, whose father was once Governor of Pennsylvania, represents the role of a seasoned politician against the hedge fund newcomer McCormick. In their ideology, Casey’s campaign specifically attacks large corporations, linking to McCormick’s Wall Street background. This is an extension of Casey’s economic argument about Greedflation—the theory that corporate greed is driving increases in prices—which has been a main topic of his past term. On the other hand, McCormick hinges his campaign on Casey’s stance on public spending and decisions against tax cuts. McCormick argues that the Democratic fiscal spending that Casey supports is a far greater cause for inflation than Greedflation, a critical area of focus in a Pennsylvania district focused on the economy.
Tammy Baldwin is another Democratic incumbent at risk against Republican candidate Eric Hovde in the state of Wisconsin. Much like McCormick, Hovde is a newcomer, and he is also from big business and finance. The Wisconsin race has tightened more than experts have expected and has turned far more personal than other races. Unlike the Pennsylvania race, which has frequently alluded to the wider presidential election, Baldwin and Hovde have stayed more contained in Wisconsin-specific campaigns, focused on issues like abortion and candidate identity rather than the economy.
In Ohio, the Democratic candidate at risk is Sherrod Brown, who is going against outside businessman and entrepreneur Bernie Moreno. The Ohio race sparks interest because Sherrod Brown is a Democratic incumbent in what has been a firmly Republican State. As a result, with Trump almost certainly winning the state in the presidential race, Brown’s chances lie in connecting with the working-class voter base he has historically been successful with.
Lastly, Democrat Jon Tester is running against Tim Sheehy in Montana—a race that is largely tilted in Sheehy’s favor. While Tester tries to appeal to voters with his past and life in Montana, Sheehy seems to embody the values of those same voters as a former Navy SEAL. By portraying Tester as a yes-man in the Democratic Party, Sheehy hopes to come off as the more appealing and strong-willed candidate.
Within each of these races, there are several common threads. Each of the Democrats is fighting to appear more centrist, an issue as their districts turn far right. There is an overall climate of needing to return to the basics—to simplify American values. Although this isn’t a full mirror of Trump’s “Make America Great Again,” it is a reflection of why veterans like McCormick and Sheehy are doing well. Interestingly, however, is the trend of big business on the Republican side. McCormick and Hovde come from hedge fund management and banking respectively, and voters will pay attention to how they balance their past with the need to connect with ordinary Americans. In comparison, the Democrats are almost all career politicians. With Bob Casey as an example, they will be trying to lean into the narrative of experience, compared to the radical change of the outsider candidates. Ultimately, each race counts because the Republicans only need to win two out of the four to gain control of the entire Senate.
It is important to address the political consequences of a Republican double majority in Congress. If Harris wins the presidency, a Republican double majority could be a call back to former President Obama’s second term, where policy progress slowed to a halt. Although he was able to pass widespread policies such as Obamacare during his first term, the double majority in his second term adamantly prevented him from fiscal spending. Moreover, the double majority stalled Obama from nominating Judge Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court. If Harris faces a red double majority in her first term, many of her tax reform policies and child tax credit programs may be shut down.
On the other hand, if Trump gets a Republican double majority, he will be able to lead the country down any path he wants, and almost no one will be able to stop him. Looking back to when he had a double majority his first term, Trump was able to enact tariffs and immigration reforms at a rapid pace. In fact, during his first 100 days in office, Trump passed more legislation than any other president since former President Harry Truman as a result of his party’s grip on Congress. However, more importantly, full Republican control gave Trump the power to efficiently appoint hundreds of Republican judges across the U.S. judicial system. Favorable judges, especially at the Supreme Court level, can tilt power in Trump’s favor even after he is gone from office. As conservatives tilt toward personality politics—with Trump at the center—a possible Republican majority in the Senate changes the stakes of this upcoming presidential election.





Leave a Reply