Isabella Park

One Line Summary: The frequent use of experimental weapons in the Ukrainian War threatens the safety of civilians and may escalate the lethality of other conflicts. 

Modern warfare has been extremely reliant on the sheer size of a country’s military in recent decades. With high-tech missiles and the number of ships determining the likelihood of victory, it is unsurprising that superpowers such as the U.S. and China have continuously been growing their defense budget. However, the success of drone warfare in the absence of any international regulations and accountability could accelerate the humanitarian concerns over weapons development.

Due to its artillery disparity with Russia, Ukraine developed drone warfare as a sustainable way to protect its airspace. Although Ukraine previously obtained air defenses such as the Patriot Air Defence system, which sends missiles to intercept hostile projectiles, and F-16s, American fighter jets, they failed to defend against Russian precision-guided glide bombs, which rely on smaller drones that detect Ukrainian positions to guide airstrikes. With conventional tactics, Russian glide bombs are challenging to take down due to their low altitude and minimal radar signatures. Furthermore, the financial costs for Ukraine to use interceptor missiles would be counterintuitive: one Patriot missile costs millions of dollars, while Russian munitions cost less than a hundredth of that. 

In response, Ukraine has adapted FPV drones (First Person View drones originally developed for taking out ground targets) to become interceptors instead. Such repurposed drones, which originally cost $700, can intercept Russian drones that cost over $100,000 with a success rate of over 50 percent. The costs of such drones are also being lowered through the use of 3D printing, which can produce smaller drones capable of dropping grenades. The development of easily updatable smartphone applications that run a targeting algorithm through reconnaissance drones allows Ukrainian soldiers to fire artillery on Russian ground targets without the need for complex machinery. Beyond decentralized efforts, the Ukrainian military itself has established a special unit for long-range drones. Having achieved more than 7,000 strikes by October 1, this unit usually launches drones into Russian territory at night. To increase access to weapons, the Ukrainian military has also created the Iron Range testing program, which provides manufacturers with feedback from active combat situations in exchange for prototypes. 

Contrary to Ukraine, the Russian military has preferred traditional drone construction tactics and investment over decentralized innovation. For example, they use laser sensors to trigger Ukrainian bombs in the air, maximizing the damage of shrapnel sprays. Although these have proven extremely effective, many Russian soldiers complained that higher bureaucratic officials are unwilling to permit the use of complex electric machinery. This renders the Russian military unable to replicate the kinds of tinkering that Ukrainian soldiers have utilized to craft cheap yet effective weapons. However, the Russian military has continued to invest in experimental drones and has tested a few models on the battlefield. This was clear in the wreckage of an Okhotnik drone that was shot down by a Russian jet over Ukrainian airspace in order to destroy the technology after a failed experimental flight. The new drone would be able to carry bombs and rockets, hit aerial targets, and conduct reconnaissance. Hence, even though the Russian military has been reluctant to embrace small-scale innovations, it has not slowed down the use of prototypes on the battlefield. 

Despite the need for international standards, it is highly unlikely that any enforcement will be successful. Looking at the Nuclear Proliferation Treaty, which aimed to reduce the production of nuclear weapons, superpowers such as China and the U.S. had no motivation to stop research, and hence did not remove their own weapons. In the case of nuclear weapons, research was also heavily accelerated in the context of an active conflict such as World War II. The Russo-Ukrainian War would likely serve a similar role for AI weapons, putting civilians at risk of unreliable targeting mechanisms if each side is motivated to rapidly introduce newer weapons on the battlefield. In 2021, the UN released a report regarding the unreliability of differentiating civilian and combat targets through drone algorithms in Libya. These issues could repeat on a larger scale when both sides have more financial resources and foreign support. 

This lack of international regulation has incentivized militaries and weapons development companies to use the Russo-Ukrainian War to assess new weaponry’s effectiveness in conflict situations. The U.S., for example, sent the M142 (a multiple rocket launcher) to be assessed for effectiveness on the battlefield. However, there is a general concern that many of these weapons may have not gone through the usual procedures to prevent excessive civilian harm. Such risks are especially heightened with the increased trade of weapons from countries such as Iran, whose government’s adherence to humanitarian standards has been concerning in the past. The prominence of artificial intelligence-based weapons—which make up a significant portion of tested weapons—further amplifies these concerns. These weapons aim to remove humans from the decision-making process in order to increase efficiency and conserve human resources. Such decentralized algorithms challenge regulation and encourage the likelihood of illegal trade. Unlike traditional weapons whose machinery reveals the bulk of its operating mechanism, AI-based weapons rely on the software itself. As the software companies behind them are often government contractors, it is extremely difficult to regulate the AI-based weapons industry internationally. Furthermore, AI-based weapons are far more convenient to trade illegally because the hardware itself is cheap and relatively simple, with software that can easily be transferred without physical limitations. If the Russo-Ukrainian War allows for rapid innovation in AI algorithms, such software could easily be purchased by terrorists or authoritarian governments, allowing any country to engage in mass destruction without significant human capital or sacrifice. 

Although drone warfare has become crucial to the Russo-Ukrainian War campaign, it is impossible to ignore the potential humanitarian consequences associated with the rapid development of such technology without the necessary guidelines. As the war increases in prominence as an opportunity for new technology to be tested, there may be a higher frequency of malfunctioning weapons causing civilian harm. The international community will also have to be aware of the possible spillover of the illegal weapons trade into different militias and authoritarian governments.

Leave a Reply

Trending