Max Langhorst

One Line Summary: Donald Trump has consistently touted tariffs as a way to fix America’s economy? Is he right? 

In all three of former President Donald Trump’s presidential campaigns, he has consistently and incessantly touted tariffs as an economic fix-all. In the 2024 presidential debate, he mentioned a 10 to 20 percent blanket tariff on imports multiple times, a statement pushed back on by Vice President Kamala Harris, who called it a “Trump sales tax.” Early in his first campaign, Trump proposed a 45 percent blanket tariff on China, which he framed as a way to use American trade influence there. Throughout his political career, Trump has had a famously strong vendetta against China, spending much of his administration embroiled in one of the most consequential trade wars in recent decades. In 2020, Trump famously called himself a “tariff man.” Now, as the Republican candidate for the upcoming 2024 election, he has talked about tariffs as a way to bring in revenue for programs like universal child care, implying that such programs were merely a drop in the bucket in comparison to the “trillions” of dollars that would be collected from other countries in tariffs. Interestingly, Trump’s biggest political rival, Harris, has also proposed increasing tariffs on China for a very similar set of reasons. However, she emphasized that her proposed tariffs would be more “targeted and strategic” to help protect American business. 

Tariffs have been a hot-button political issue since the signing of the Constitution. In fact, one of the first laws signed by George Washington was a five percent tariff on the majority of imports. But at the time, it was thought of as just an easier way of instituting taxes. Attitudes in the pre-Trump decades were generally anti-tariff. When Trump won the presidential election in 2016, he brought with him a wealth of changes, including tariffs. His administration levied many tariffs on other countries, with a particular focus on China. A basic understanding of the how and why of tariffs certainly seems critical, especially given their recent resurgence. 

What are tariffs?

A tariff is a tax imposed by the government and paid by importers. When a company in the U.S. imports something from China, the U.S. company usually pays some percentage of the shipment’s value to the American government. 

Why do people use tariffs?

Tariffs have historically been used to allow home-grown industries a fighting chance against a bombardment of cheaper products from outside. They have also been used to fight against countries who artificially decrease the price of their products. They, in addition, have been used extensively as a political bargaining tool to punish countries for other acts.

Who uses tariffs?

By and large, developing nations are the biggest users of tariffs for a variety of reasons. For one, tariffs can be an easy way for a government to collect money, and they can help support the often brand-new local industries. Now we come to the most critical question: Are tariffs effective? 

Ultimately, Trump’s relentless statements that tariffs will save America’s economy are inaccurate. According to economists, tariffs risk provoking trade wars that will hurt the global economy. In general, tariffs have both benefits and costs. When used as a political tool to punish other countries for unrelated acts, tariffs can be effective, especially if such countries are not in the economic position to stand up to the U.S. Some economists have found that U.S. sanctions on Iran were effective in inducing leadership changes, but these results are somewhat controversial. However, if tariffs are used economically, evidence for their benefits is dubious at best. Economists have repeatedly shown that tariffs are, at their core, just another form of taxation. Trump has frequently said that his tariffs are paid by other countries, such as when he tweeted in 2018 that, “When people or countries come in to raid the great wealth of our Nation, I want them to pay for the privilege of doing so.” While getting other countries to pay for the right to trade with America might be great, that is not how tariffs work; tariffs are taxes Americans pay when they import goods from another country. When a tariff is put on another country, the American businesses that buy products under it are suddenly on the hook for tax revenue that they must immediately pay to the federal government. As a result, they have to raise prices, and the effects snowball throughout the economy. The idea that tariffs are paid by other countries, while relatively common in politics these days, is nonsensical. Instead, tariffs are a form of taxation without taxes. The tariffs raise prices, causing low-income Americans to disproportionately bear most of the burden. However, since Trump continues to imply that the tax primarily affects other nations, Americans largely blame the resulting price increases on other factors. When a politician increases tariffs, they bring in money that they can then say is helping “balance the budget” while skirting much of the political fallout of raising taxes on Americans. 

Overall, however, Trump’s tariffs have been unsuccessful. They were terrible for Americans in general, but they were felt especially by low-income people because tariffs function somewhat as taxes on the entire economy, and the poorest Americans are least equipped to pay those taxes. Somehow, Americans have allowed misleading rhetoric from Trump around tariffs to dupe them into thinking his economic policies will drastically change their lives when in reality, tariffs make the economy worse while increasing support for politicians.

Leave a Reply

Trending