Bruce Ru

The recent uptick in natural disasters has made effective government response challenging, acting as a warning to enact preventative climate action to decrease the instances of these catastrophes in the first place.

“You were about to blow… the lights flickered. It almost gave me a heart attack. You were harsh, Milton.” 

This is not an excerpt from fictional literature. This is the writing of a fifth grader from Tampa, Florida, expressing their fear as the Category Three Hurricane Milton made landfall on the evening of October 9, 2024. 

What was especially concerning about Milton was that it came only two weeks after the fateful Hurricane Helene, which itself left over 200 dead and billions of dollars in damages.


There is no doubt that natural disasters, whether they be hurricanes, floods, or wildfires are on the rise. There is also no doubt that climate change is a powerful force behind these phenomena, even if it is inconvenient to admit. This creates unprecedented pressure for government response on local, state, and federal levels. For these governmental actors, a new range of risks demonstrates a significant threat to national security.

The most obvious risk is the concerningly short timeframe government has to enact an adequate response when disasters happen at regular intervals. The immediate reparations, including insurance, emergency shelter, and grants from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) are limited. For long-term recovery options, communities rely on elected officials to declare a state of emergency, which already disadvantages Republican statements over their Democratic counterparts. However, it would take another step before help arrives. Government responses require state legislatures or Congress to pass an emergency funding bill. The process is often dragged out by extensive lobbying and debate. As these events happen more often, there is extra pressure on this already exhausting loop. 

Even when help does arrive, inequality and corruption often deny it to those who need it most, limiting the effectiveness of the response. The role of income disparities in determining the aid one receives is especially problematic, as inspectors often declare damage to poorly built homes as pre-existing, and therefore undeserving of financial support. Similarly, renters, who often dwell in vulnerable areas such as basements, are more at risk of injury and death than wealthier homeowners. Race also plays a role. Many Black and Latino communities live in poorer, segregated areas that already lack resources for emergency recovery. These disadvantaged areas are often undesirably close to toxic sites, flood-prone areas, and other high-risk locations. In territories such as Puerto Rico, federally capped block grants mean that essential programs such as Medicaid cannot expand in times of dire need. Furthermore, for the many colored people of undocumented status, help is completely unavailable. In ethnically diverse communities such as those in Florida affected by Hurricane Milton, these problems widen racial tensions. Coupled with income inequality, a failure to equitably address disasters has long-lasting impacts on community social dynamics.

Another threat of particular interest in modern times is forced migration, causing irreversible losses to many communities while escalating the border crisis. The destruction of local communities and the continued loss of land in coastal areas at the hands of disasters can force entire populations to relocate. The most acute example in the U.S. could be Louisiana, which famously “sheds another football field of land” every single day, in addition to mass population movements after extreme events. In fact, New Orleans lost one-third of its population following Hurricane Katrina, presenting serious economic and cultural losses. Interestingly, this is a rare case that affects both the wealthy and poor alike. When a landslide rages indiscriminately, a multi-million mansion ends in the same pit as a pauper’s hovel, forcing everyone on the same exodus. However, much of the drama in fact unfolds outside America’s doorstep. In tropical Latin American nations, hurricanes and floods displace disadvantaged populations and represent an unpredictable link on the feedback loop of political instability. Left with little choice but to flee, many walk hundreds, or thousands of miles for their meager survival. Many illegal immigrants who cross the Southern U.S. border unsurprisingly belong to this category, causing social and political turmoil and straining America’s own resources. Therefore, in this globally interconnected environment, natural disasters that happen outside of America’s borders are in themselves, too, American disasters. 

Finally, all the risks discussed above factor into what is perhaps the greatest threat of all—the loss of our basic trust in the government’s ability to lend a helping hand in the most dire situations. When the traditional disaster response mechanisms prove unable to combat the increased force of 21st-century catastrophes, individuals turn to community-based solutions for support instead. Though these communities are often praised for their agency and self-sufficiency, the government must never lose its overarching role of allocating resources, mediating conflicts of interest, and fulfilling these duties with equality and continuity across diverse constituents. Local communities, by definition, have a limited reach. When a catastrophe affects a large area and is impactful on a national scale, only a well integrated government can ensure that all are catered to equally and the nation remembers and recovers together. Ultimately, it is the Constitution itself that entrusts and demands that the government allocates societal resources for the very population who has elected them as representatives.


These challenges in themselves are daunting enough, but in America’s polarized landscape, politicians too often weaponize these problems rather than focus on solutions. After another chaotic election cycle, the foul air of political attacks as candidates pummel their opponents on the failure to respond to disasters, lingers. In one of MAGA’s iconic rallies a few weeks ago, former President Donald Trump criticized the federal response to the extensive floods in Western North Carolina, mentioning rumors that the government was unwilling to provide support for the residents because it was a Republican area. Only days later, similar conspiracy theories hitched a ride on Hurricane Milton’s powerful winds, landing in the communities of Florida and beyond. Perpetuating these ideas reverses any meaningful effort to mitigate the risks, continuing a cycle of disaster and chaos contradictory to America’s image as a resilient nation.

In the end, policy-makers must understand that liberal or conservative, Californian or Floridian, their final goal is the same—to keep the American people safe on their own soil. The key word is prevention. It is common knowledge that climate change is behind the increased occurrence of extreme weather events, so it is time to take solid steps in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, from eliminating fossil fuel use to making our economy truly circular. It is true that political parties have different priorities, and environmental action might even seem to contradict politicians’ interests. However, it is clear today that for Democrats and Republicans alike, climate action is essential to achieving their objectives. It is a new frontline in combating inequality and protecting the American middle class. It eases forced migration in cities plagued by uncertain population trends and a border crisis. Finally, it is key to America’s image as a strong and innovative superpower in the 21st century. All of these goals are relevant to any leader who loves this country. There is simply no time for disunity in an era where there is more to worry about than the next election. If these recent disasters have not yet taught us this lesson, then nothing will.

Let us think back to the fifth-grader who wrote to Hurricane Milton, a testament to its horrific force. What that student probably did not know was that without the effects of climate change, Milton would have made landfall only as a Category Two hurricane. Our leaders, democratically elected to represent all American people, must not let down children like them.

Leave a Reply

Trending