By: Kristen Ma
Biden’s endorsement of hydrogen power via tax incentives forwent regulatory standards to the benefit of harmful combustion-based energy corporations.
For the better part of history, combustion fuels and net zero emissions were thought to be mutually exclusive. Now, the prospect of hydrogen fuel distinct from greenhouse gas emissions is being realized, with Congress footing a hefty $170 billion bill under the Biden Administration. Just weeks before former President Donald Trump succeeded incumbent President Joe Biden, the U.S. Department of Treasury scrambled to disclose its policies for the IRA (Inflation Reduction Act) §45V tax credit, which granted hydrogen producers more leeway in qualifying for subsidies. This policy renounced stricter qualifications from previous 2022-2024 drafts of the policy, allowing companies such as the Constellation Energy Corporation and Plug Power to benefit from the subsidy, despite concerns that they may not entirely meet sustainability standards.
Tax credit 45V provided a more lenient approach to stimulate the hydrogen industry, introducing delayed renewable energy requirements, expanding eligibility for nuclear power and natural gas. The previous requirement for hydrogen producers to match their electricity generation with renewable energy on an hourly basis has been postponed from 2028 to 2030. Until then, companies can adhere to a looser annual standard and still obtain the tax credit. The credit also expanded to include nuclear power plants slated for closure: these plants may receive subsidies provided they support grid stability and implement nuclear reactors such as small modular reactors, which are ideal for co-located hydrogen production. The final rules also enabled natural gas to qualify for the full tax credit of up to $3 per kilogram given that carbon capture is employed to mitigate emissions.
New regulations do not differentiate between hydrogen varieties, which is paramount to determining environmental consequences. Green hydrogen power, as intended in the credit, leaves behind water vapor and warm air in its wake. Very little – and in many cases, zero – carbon dioxide is emitted. Green hydrogen is produced from an electrolysis process charged by renewable sources such as solar, wind, and hydropower. The electricity generated divides water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen gas; the hydrogen is subsequently stored or utilized in fuel cells. The catch? A cost twice, if not three times as steep as its alternatives. Blue and grey hydrogen prove far cheaper and prevalent, but are derived from fossil fuels. Natural gas and methane undergo steam reforming (SMR) which expels carbon dioxide as a byproduct, indicative of negative ecological ramifications. Contentious points arise when credit is afforded to corporations of varying degrees of environmental impact. Thus, though the Biden Administration’s tactic of incentivising hydrogen power through tax credit offsets costs of clean hydrogen, easements to its initial, stringent ordinances vulnerates subsidies to unmerited claims and combustion-based energy production.
At their core, Biden’s subsidies are without a doubt, positive. The tax credit is attractive in that it makes hydrogen more cost-competitive with nonrenewable energy. The objective is to stimulate domestic industry, which in turn lowers CO2 emissions in the production of cement, steel, and transportation. In March of last year, the Department of Energy (DOE) stipulated $750 million dollars toward 52 projects across 24 states with the aim of bolstering the hydrogen industry. Funded by the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, said projects furthered electrolysis technologies, extended recycling capabilities for clean hydrogen components, and led to the creation of more than 1,500 jobs. They are also projected to produce 14 gigawatts of fuel cells annually, enough to sufficiently power 15% of medium to heavy-duty trucks sold each year, as well as an additional 1.3 million tons of clean hydrogen, according to the DOE. Clean hydrogen can be used as a rocket or vehicle fuel, in electricity generation, and other industrial processes. More recent rules permitted hydrogen gas derived from natural gas and methane to receive tax credit, provided carbon capture systems are utilized. Moreover, the rules established opportunities to draw out landfill methane to impede the greenhouse gases from rising into the atmosphere.
Barring its benefits, the chief issue with Biden’s framework for clean hydrogen lies not in what legislation contains, but rather what it does not. A lack of regulations apropos of what constitutes clean energy can precipitate greenwashing. Greenwashing refers to a specious practice whereby an adverse policy or product is portrayed as more “environmentally friendly” than it is. In the context of hydrogen subsidies, it can be best explained by a “box and claim” system that would fraudulently label fossil gas power plants as having zero emissions. Under this system, pollution caused by fossil gas companies could be blotted out by the aforementioned withdrawal of landfill methane. For example, biogas captured from a dairy farm in Philadelphia could “cancel out” a fossil gas plant in upstate New York. Companies selling offsets would therefore be compensated for concentrating pollution as opposed to adopting sustainable practices. The tax credit thence backfires because it incentivises loopholes and potentially nets harvesting of woody biomass, trash incineration, and more fossil fuel extraction. Sara Lutz, a Senior Climate Campaigner at Friends of the Earth, expressed her discontent: “This was a missed opportunity to set a strong standard that rightfully excludes burning wood biomass and trash from being declared clean electricity… It’s disappointing that the Administration declined to exclude polluters from qualifying for the clean electricity subsidy.”
Other loopholes persist. Companies with nuclear reactors verging on retirement for economic reasons can claim tax credit to produce hydrogen if it would help the plants remain operational. In addition, hydrogen producers are not required to buy clean electricity to align with their output until 2030. Until then, a loose, annual standard grants them subsidies. This lack of definition has also left several companies – among them blue hydrogen producers – unsure of whether certain benefits are applicable to them, thus halting subsequent projects worth roughly $3 billion.
In summary, while Biden’s hydrogen subsidies may present a critical nudge toward decarbonization, it fails to set a standard baseline of whether a company should be requited for its environmental neutrality. Without successive amendments, lax regulations without mention of green hydrogen will erode the validity of clean energy designations. The Biden Administration has one of two choices: (a) scale hydrogen without exacerbating pollution and cannibalizing the clean power on the grid, or (b) channel subsidies explicitly toward green hydrogen projects to achieve long-term climate goals.





Leave a Reply