By: Henry Zimmerman
The rise of the Alternative für Deutschland brings to question the durability of Germany’s commitments to European security and prosperity amid a changing global order.
With the German Bundestag elections just weeks away, voters face a choice that could either unify Germany and Europe or deepen divisions. The Alternative für Deutschland (AfD), a provocative anti-establishment party, has become the focal point of this election. Germany has not seen such strong support for a far-right party since Adolf Hitler’s Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (Nazi Party). Since winning its first seat in 2013, the AfD has drawn condemnation and comparisons to Germany’s darkest political past.
The incumbent governing coalition has collapsed, with the SPD, Green Party, and FDP unable to agree on continued Ukraine aid. Now, the AfD polls at 22 percent, second only to the center-right CDU/CSU at 30 percent. The party’s rise stems from widespread dissatisfaction with the government’s handling of the economy; 46 percent of Germans blame the SPD for the nation’s economic struggles, while only 11 percent view the party as economically competent. Germany’s economy has contracted for a second consecutive year, driven by challenges in the car industry, high energy costs, and fallout from the Ukraine war. The AfD capitalizes on this discontent with a bold platform unburdened by a history of governance.
The current government’s failure to manage the social and economic consequences of mass immigration from the Middle East, Africa, and Eastern Europe has further fueled anti-immigration sentiment, with many Germans believing immigrants strain the country’s resources. Public safety concerns intensified after the December 20 terrorist attack injuring over 300 at the Magdeburg Christmas market, linked to a right-wing Islamophobe, exposed critical government lapses. Extremists associated with the AfD escalated tensions, culminating in neo-Nazi protests with chants of “Deport, deport, deport.” While the AfD promotes radical policies like “reimmigration,” a euphemism for mass deportation, mainstream parties—apart from far-left party Die Linke—also called for stricter immigration measures in response to the attack.
AfD support is heavily concentrated among poor East German men, with the party polling at 29 percent in Thuringia, its highest nationwide, and over 20 percent in most other eastern states. Many East Germans feel neglected, as policies appear to favor West Germans, immigrants, and the EU over their economic interests. The region’s Soviet-era legacy, which stigmatized minority identities, exacerbates resentment over immigration and proposals like deporting “unassimilated” German citizens to “preserve German culture.” Political dissatisfaction runs deep, with only 20 percent of AfD supporters viewing German democracy favorably, compared to 65 percent of other Germans.
Founded in 2013 as a eurosceptic reaction to the Eurozone crisis, the AfD gained traction by addressing concerns over the common European currency, which mainstream parties largely ignored. Its 2017 platform diplomatically threatened an EU exit if significant reforms were not made, advocating for a tariff-free European zone while opposing the Euro, EU control, and open borders. The 2015 migrant crisis brought the AfD to national prominence, as Angela Merkel’s “wir schaffen das” (“we can do it”) message on immigration divided public opinion. By the 2017 Federal Elections, the AfD had become Germany’s third-largest party, campaigning to abolish the Euro, curb immigration—particularly of Muslims—preserve “German tradition,” and reinstate conscription for German citizens, primarily for military service in the Bundeswehr, with an alternative option for public service for conscientious objectors.
The AfD’s isolationist stance aligns with Russia and China, raising concerns in the West. In power, the AfD would benefit Russia, Germany’s former energy supplier in terms of electricity and gas, and China, where leader Alice Weidel once lived, in terms of geopolitical power. By reducing the EU to a trade alliance and rejecting the Euro, the AfD risks fracturing European unity. Germany’s €20 billion annual EU contribution, vital to the bloc’s budget, would disappear, undermining sanctions against Russia. The party also opposes aid to Ukraine, advocating reconciliation with Russia and lamenting the loss of cheap Russian gas. Controversies, such as the arrest of Maximilian Krah’s aide for alleged CCP ties and Krah’s CCP-sponsored trips, further cloud the AfD’s geopolitical aims. Krah, a German lawyer and AfD Member of the European Parliment since 2019, has faced scrutiny over his connections to China, particularly after his assistant, Jian Guo, was arrested for allegedly spying for Chinese intelligence. These positions inject uncertainty into Germany’s foreign policy and strengthen adversaries of Western cohesion. An AfD victory would shatter the fragile foundation of European unity.
Despite its popularity, the AfD has received widespread condemnation for its right-wing extremism. Its embrace of grievance, rhetoric tied to nazism, and Islamophobic, anti-Semitic, and xenophobic views has led the party to be classified as “suspected extremist” by German domestic intelligence. The AfD has been accused of repeatedly allowing the party’s most extreme members to make disagreeable and offensive remarks and then having more moderate members walk them back or clarify them. This bears political risks, as this May, National Rally, a right-wing party in France, refused to work with the AfD in the European Parliament following hateful comments made by the AfD’s Maxamillian Krah.
The AfD has made efforts to appear more moderate, cutting ties with its extremist-classified youth wing and positioning co-chairs Alice Weidel and Tino Chrupalla, who command 80 percent of the party’s voter support, as leaders aiming to mainstream its policies. Chrupalla, referencing Elon Musk’s endorsement, quipped, “The firewall between the AfD and the White House is officially gone, and that makes the German firewall look silly.” The “firewall” refers to the political strategy used by mainstream German parties to isolate the AfD, preventing it from gaining influence by refusing to cooperate or form coalitions with them at any level of government. Despite these efforts, Weidel concedes that the AfD is unlikely to gain federal power before 2029 due to other parties’ strict “firewall” tactics, which include exclusion from parliamentary negotiations, blocking AfD candidates from leadership positions, and ruling out coalition agreements. Still, Weidel remains optimistic about a potential alliance with the CDU/CSU, should their policy goals outweigh reputational risks. Even if the AfD secures the largest vote share, its extreme rhetoric and neo-Nazi ties would likely keep it sidelined in the Bundestag. A majority victory, the AfD’s only viable path to power, is improbable given that 79 percent of Germans hold unfavorable views of the party. However, shifting public opinion and unforeseen circumstances could still pave the way for a nationalist resurgence in Germany.
While the AfD may not gain power in Germany soon, its rise is already reshaping the political landscape. Mainstream parties have been pushed to the right, forced to address challenges to the status quo on issues like immigration, energy, and the economy—topics central to the AfD’s appeal. To counter its growth, these parties must tackle voter grievances driving support for the AfD. This is evident in the CDU’s stricter immigration policies following the Magdeburg attack. However, this strategy may fall short, as many AfD supporters reject diluted versions of their party’s extreme agenda.
The AfD’s ability to implement its platform, including mass deportations, EU withdrawal or reform, and conscription, remains doubtful due to limited public support and legal constraints. These policies have faced fierce backlash when attempted elsewhere. Alarmed by the AfD’s rise and disregard for democratic norms, mainstream German parties have taken protective measures, such as enshrining the Constitutional Court’s powers in the constitution. Simultaneously, calls to ban the AfD or cut its public funding are growing, though experts are divided on whether this would weaken the party or embolden its base. With its polarizing policies, controversial legal status, and widespread unpopularity, the AfD’s ability to govern effectively seems unlikely. Yet, the rise of radical parties often leads to repression and instability, underscoring the need to scrutinize the far-right carefully to preserve Germany’s democracy.





Leave a Reply