By: Aglaia Hong

Donald Trump’s unconditional discharge for thirty-four felony convictions undermines the principles of accountability and equality under the law.

For the first time in U.S. history, a former president has been convicted of serious charges–yet walks away with no consequences. What does this conviction with zero penalty mean for the integrity of American democracy and the future of accountability? On January 10th, 2024, Donald Trump was sentenced to an “unconditional discharge” for his felonies by Justice Juan Merchan of the New York State Supreme Court. In other words, he was given a slap on the wrist. Although guilty of all 34 felonies, there were no substantial punitive measures, simply because of fear of political instability and inconvenience. While Trump’s conviction seemed to show to the public that our justice system doesn’t give favoritism even to soon-to-be presidents, his unconditional discharge dangerously undermines the impartiality of the American justice system. 

An unconditional discharge, in essence, means that a person facing a sentence will receive no legal repercussions. While in some states, being a convicted felon means losing the privilege to vote and the right to bear a gun, Trump will be the first convicted felon holding office. This unprecedented situation marks a turn in American history, as no other U.S. president or high-ranking political figure has assumed public office under such circumstances. The absence of consequences for such a conviction challenges the longstanding principle that elected officials must uphold the highest standards of conduct. 

Trump’s felonies are all connected to the $130,000 in hush money he paid Stormy Daniels in 2016 and $150,000 to Karen McDougal during the 2016 elections to keep quiet about the affairs they had. These felonies included falsifying business documents such as invoices from Michael Cohen to the Trump Organization, entries in the general ledgers of the Trump Organization, and checks issued from accounts associated with Donald J. Trump and the Donald J. Trump Revocable Trust. The impact of withholding the information about Trump being an adulterer, felon, and his exploitation of these women from the public ultimately influenced the outcome of the 2016 election. In New York, falsifying business records is considered a Class E felony. Although not as serious as Class A or Class B felonies, these crimes are nonetheless severe, and having impacted the election and the entirety of the country, Trump received an extremely rare sentence considering his current convictions. “This is very, very rare, especially when you’re talking about a felony case with thirty-four counts decided by a jury in a jury trial,” Henry Pontell, a sociologist and former professor of criminal justice said. Trump’s easy let-off and privilege is clear. Judge Juan M. Merchan, a justice of the New York State Supreme Court, stated that “The protections afforded the office of the president are not a mitigating factor. They do not reduce the seriousness of the crime or justify its commission in any way…one power they do not provide is the power to erase a jury verdict.” Regardless of his unconditional discharge, Trump remains guilty of the crimes he committed. It is clear that under normal circumstances, he would not have received any special privileges. 

The decision to give Trump an unconditional discharge is deeply problematic because of the lack of accountability. Most unconditional discharges are directed towards more minor crimes, like refusing to submit to field sobriety tests, speeding, tax evasion by an attorney, and misconduct by an attorney. The lack of punishment reveals a weakness in the judicial system. How can the public trust in the legal and political systems in the future when they are unable to punish those who must be punished simply because of convenience? This instance could easily set a precedent for other political figures or high-profile celebrities to commit crimes but get off scot-free. Now, Trump’s sentence, or lack thereof on this scale has sent the message that undermining electoral processes and threatening democracy can go unpunished. The problem is not solely about fairness, but legitimacy is at stake. When citizens see that a person like Trump can evade punishment just because of their position, trust in the justice system is annihilated. Public trust in governmental institutions has been on a declining trajectory. According to a Pew Research Center survey from April 2024, only 22% of Americans express trust in the federal government to do what is right “just about always” or “most of the time,” and a Gallup poll indicates that as of 2024, only 35% of Americans have confidence in the nation’s courts. Currently, trust in the judicial system and government is already incredibly low, and there’s no doubt that favoritism will deflate public trust even more. For a democracy to function properly, the law must protect everyone, without exception. The law should not and must not be malleable.

The unconditional discharge given to Donald Trump despite his conviction on thirty-four felony charges is a huge deviation from the principles of what American society considers equality. Yet, despite this revelation, some still believe Trump’s lack of penalization isn’t problematic. To uphold the integrity our government has been built on, the law must be enforced impartially with zero exemptions for anybody. No one is above the law.

Leave a Reply

Trending