By: Andrew Liu
As Trump uses tariffs as bargaining chips on the global stage, he is bargaining the future of the American people at the same time.
Since Donald Trump stepped back into the Oval Office on January 20, he has swiftly begun executing various campaign promises and threats, many of which have been stirring for the past 4 years. Among the initial executive actions of the Trump Administration, his proposed tariffs have been some of the most divisive. Using the long-standing International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) of 1977, Trump has identified international threats posed by China, Mexico, and Canada. As such, he has used the IEEPA act to levy heavy tariffs on each of these three countries, generating questions regarding both motive and impact. In doing so, he leverages the US economy as a bargaining chip in global diplomacy, gambling the fortunes of the American people in the process.
Before analyzing Trump’s use of protective tariffs, it’s critical to first understand how these economic policies function. Tariffs act like any other type of taxation, taking money away from the people and giving it to the government in the form of revenue. However, tariffs are only placed on a particular type of transaction: imports. When someone inside of a country imports goods, the port authority assesses the total value of the import in the US Dollar due upon the receipt. The person buying the goods must pay the full price of the tariff before the goods are released from US custody. This results in a sudden increase in costs for domestic buyers.
Three groups are affected by protective tariffs: domestic importers, foreign producers, and domestic producers. Firstly, domestic importers who buy goods from foreign countries are hurt. Tariffs impose a tax on imports, making it more expensive for domestic importers to do business. Simultaneously, foreign producers are also hurt, even though tariffs aren’t directly levied on this group. Since tariffs make it more expensive for domestic importers to purchase a certain region’s goods, that region’s producers will have to reduce prices to compete in the open market. This cuts away at their margins. Finally, the group that benefits from tariffs are domestic producers. Since tariffs increase the cost of foreign goods for domestic importers, these businesses are encouraged to instead purchase goods from domestic producers, allowing domestic producers to better compete in the domestic free market across almost all industries.
Analyzing these effects of protective tariffs, we can begin to understand the geopolitical leverage Trump hopes they can provide. First, looking at China, there are several differences between Trump’s current tariffs on the country and his past tariffs from the trade war in 2018. During Trump’s first presidency, his tariffs involved much more economic reasoning, with trade deficits and intellectual property infringements as the central cause. In comparison, Trump’s recently imposed 10 percent tariff on Chinese imports has been justified by China’s role in manufacturing chemicals linked to illegal drug production. In a way, this symbolizes a difference in approach between the two administrations. The earlier Trump was more willing to be brash and upfront with his reasoning, whereas now, he takes a backdoor route to justifying his tariffs. It is true that China facilitates widespread opioid production, but Trump’s larger motives are still likely aligned with the trade-deficit. Even with the difference in alibis, however, the current tariffs themselves have had very similar effects to the last trade war. Just like last time, China has responded by placing counter tariffs, which are Chinese tariffs placed on American imports. It wouldn’t be surprising to see both sides begin to outsource supply chains to alternative countries, resulting in a more prolonged economic schism.
In addition to China, Canada and Mexico have also been hit with tariffs. Although the two North American countries have historically been allies, Trump has targeted Canada for its relaxed policy against drug trafficking. Moreover, Mexico’s border control issues have been a major issue for Trump, even since his first campaign. Thus, the President’s tariffs on Canada and Mexico are set at 25 percent, far higher than the tariffs on China. Since, neither Canada nor Mexico have economies large enough to survive the potential shock that China can, a prolonged trade war is a much greater threat. As a result, it makes sense that both the Mexican President and the Canadian Prime Minister have made concessions to Trump, leading to a one month pause on tariffs for both countries. President Sheinbaum of Mexico promised to send 10,000 members of her National Guard to the US-Mexico border, addressing Trump’s demands regarding the migrant crisis. Correspondingly, Prime Minister Trudeau promised to crack down on fentanyl and the organized drug trafficking crime network in Canada.
Although these concessions are the best outcome for the United States, they have only led to pauses on the tariffs on Canada and Mexico. Therefore, Trump still has Canada and Mexico under pressure, and this use of tariffs as a threatening force has set a tone for the United States on the world stage. Trump’s execution of tariffs aligns with Trump’s image of America First, that the United States government should focus on what benefits America and disregard foreign policy. By manipulating international trade as a bargaining chip, America has established the lengths it is willing to go to place Americans first, and as of now it seems to be succeeding. It has shown that it can truly influence the policy of its neighbors. However, in the long term, this strategy weakens America’s place at the top of the global economic food chain. As US allies and BRICS countries realize that the US can no longer be relied upon, they are more likely to form relationships amongst themselves. During Trump’s first presidency, China dealt with the Trade war by diversifying its economic relationships in South Asia. Who’s to say Canada and Mexico couldn’t do something similar, if forced to do so? By putting itself first now, America may be cutting itself out of the picture moving forward.
More than geopolitics, it’s important to address how the tariffs impact the American people. As mentioned earlier, tariffs are fundamentally a tax on domestic importers, those who purchase goods imported from other countries. In day-to-day life, these domestic importers supply a significant portion of goods in most American households. Car manufacturers import steel, supermarkets import vegetables, and even stores import clothes. As tariffs are levied, their effects become the burden of the average American consumer. Prices will rise. This is troubling, considering Trump’s presidential win was in part on the basis of a worker’s economy: an economy where lowered living costs and increased wages are a given. Precisely for this reason, Republicans like Mitch McConnell have gone against Trump’s tariffs. In the end, as much as it is about economic utility, this threatens the values of many consumer first Americans.
Tariffs imposed by Donald Trump on China, Canada, and Mexico will change America’s international influence and the lives of everyday American citizens. Therefore, as a country, we must ask ourselves what we value more. Do we need more bargaining chips on the geopolitical poker table? Or do we care more about the holes those chips burn in the pockets of the average American?





Leave a Reply