By: Ethan Ly
On January 20––the day of his inauguration, Trump pardoned around 1,600 January 6 insurrectionists, a move that threatens the U.S. justice system and sets a dangerous precedent.
On January 6, 2021, a mob of rioters stormed the U.S. Capitol, pushing past an undermanned police force and eventually —–through forcible means–– entering the building. The horde, according to FBI estimates, consisted of around 2,000 to 2,500 people, around 1,600 of whom were subsequently convicted. They faced either misdemeanor offenses or more serious charges; some had pleaded guilty. Among President Donald Trump’s recent flurry of executive orders, all of the almost 1,600 rioters were exempted from legal consequences regarding the insurrection. Trump instituted the pardons on January 2025––his inauguration. He also commuted the more severe sentences of and released 14 imprisoned insurgents, who are members of far-right militias, most convicted on grounds of seditious conspiracy. Whether or not Trump understands the significance of his actions is unclear; the setbacks to the justice system, however, are crystal.
The convicted rioters were incited by Trump’s persistence, via social media and speeches, of a “stolen” and “rigged” 2020 U.S. election. An electoral certification verifying then-President-elect Joe Biden’s victory took place on January 6, and on December 26, Trump tweeted, “Never give up. See everyone in D.C. on January 6th.” The incumbent President thus served as the bedrock of the attack on the U.S. Capitol, spreading claims of a stolen election––which have since been disproven–– and summoning rioters. Yet, Trump today, still maintains his debunked claims. Clearly, the January 6 riot was an attempt to prevent Biden from obtaining office. It was also an attempt at a self-coup: Trump ignited the effort of a coup d’état and declared Biden’s victory as illegitimate to maintain power.
Prior to his inauguration, he had made clear his intentions of granting the January 6 rioters clemency; the scale of his pardons, however, was unanticipated. In late November during an interview regarding his 2024 TIME Person of the Year naming, he said of pardoning insurrectionists as soon as he was inaugurated, “It’s going to start in the first hour. Maybe the first nine minutes.” Additionally, Trump labeled them “great patriots.” He even described the rioters as “political prisoners,” despite them having gone through the criminal justice system that would eventually convict and sentence them. Trump’s intent, given his prior statements, to grant his supporters clemency was clear, though his plan to execute these goals was unsettled. In late April, in a statement to NBC News, Trump said he planned to grant pardons “on a case-by-case basis.” Vice President J.D. Vance, in early January at least, seemingly agreed with such a proposition. Vance said in an interview with Fox News that his superior’s clemency orders “obviously” should not have included rioters who acted in violence. Yet, he contradicted himself around a week later, defending Trump’s blanket pardons.
When officially announced on January 20, the extent of Trump’s pardons thus spurred controversy, even among fellow Republicans. Republican Senators Thom Tillis and Lindsey Graham of North Carolina and South Carolina, respectively, have criticized the President’s actions. Tillis, who has previously cautioned of a broad clemency’s consequences, said in regards to the matter, “I just can’t agree.” Police officers, especially among those who were injured during the January 6 insurrection, also stood against the blanket pardons. Republican pushback from the party’s senators and initially from Vice President Vance, however, presented obstacles to Trump’s pursuit of executive action.
Alternatively, Trump justified his actions by claiming that the rioters, those imprisoned, “have already served years in prison and they’ve served them viciously.” He continued, describing the prisons’ conditions as “disgusting,” “horrible,” and “inhumane.”
Similarly, early last December, then-President Joe Biden controversially exercised his presidential ability to grant clemency. After previously saying otherwise, the former president pardoned his son Hunter Biden of his tax and gun convictions. Deciding to do so, however, was certainly biased and unreasonable, manipulating the justice system to prioritize familial loyalties.
Around the same timeframe, in stark contrast, then-president Biden commuted the sentences of approximately 1,500 non-violent drug offenders who were placed under home confinement during the COVID-19 pandemic. His decision lay in their commitment to rehabilitation and worked towards their reintegration back into their communities and families. Additionally, their convictions were non-violent crimes, and the laws by which they were sentenced, the Biden administration said, were outdated. The former president’s mass granting of clemency was productive, furthering criminal justice reform and pushing for reintegration within the general public among the incarcerated. However, Biden’s mass pardons, which included Hunter Biden and other members of his family on January 20, raised important questions: What actions should be deemed worthy of clemency? Where should U.S. citizens and lawmakers draw the line?
Legally, both former President Biden and Trump’s pardons are valid. According to the Constitution, presidents are allowed to grant clemency “for Offences against the United States.” That power is mainly unrestricted, limited by the exception that presidents may not pardon themselves. However, unreasonable pardons, including Hunter Biden’s, undermine U.S. citizens’ trust. Even worse, Trump’s recent actions blur the structural definitions of right and wrong.
In comparison to Biden’s mass commutations last December, Trump’s rationale for blanket pardons is close to baseless. Surely, the individuals involved in Biden’s commutations initially deserved their punishments. The former president justified his actions considering unfair, outdated laws and that they had since positively impacted their communities. The January 6 rioters, in contrast, were not unjustly impacted by old laws, and many of them had participated in violent acts. If Trump believes they were unfairly affected by out-of-date policies, then the laws he opposes include assaulting police officers and seditious conspiracy. Additionally, by refusing to consider rioters’ pardons on a case-by-case basis, he disregards whether or not they had undergone serious rehabilitation. By nearly blindly selecting which insurrectionists receive clemency, he seemingly bases pardons on their loyalty to him, demonstrated in their actions on January 6. Essentially, Trump makes it clear that insurrection benefiting himself ––activity that would otherwise be considered unlawful–– can be tolerated.
On January 6, numerous Trump supporters engaged in behavior deemed violent by the justice system; letting them off the hook would essentially label those actions acceptable. During the riot, insurrectionists assaulted law enforcement in a variety of methods, resulting in over 140 injured and five dead police officers. Misconduct before the police is certainly an unacceptable misdeed by judicial and moral standards, yet Trump’s blanket pardons would erase rioters records of such wrongdoings. The president is sending the completely wrong message by granting January 6 defendants clemency: that assaulting law enforcement is justifiable in the context of a self-coup. Furthermore, Trump essentially considers the latter––an insurrection–– acceptable by planning to release 14 members of far-right militant organizations, many of whom were convicted on counts of seditious conspiracy.
Plainly, pardoning January 6 rioters erases their convictions; but by doing so, Trump negates an attack on the U.S. and essentially denies its consequences. The attack’s main goals, denying Biden’s election and maintaining Trump’s reign, opposed American democracy. The insurrection instead resembled actions taken in authoritarian regimes, where power is preserved through force rather than electoral legitimacy. By absolving the rioters, Trump not only dismisses the gravity of their offenses but also undermines the rule of law, setting a precedent that political violence can go unpunished when it serves a leader’s interests.





Leave a Reply