By: Yara Handschin

Trump’s early presidency unleashed a torrent of executive orders aimed at reshaping America’s immigration policies and workforce protections, but the consequences have been disastrous.

At his inauguration on January 20, President Donald Trump solemnly swore to create a nation that is proud, prosperous, and greater than ever before. Greatness, however, is an incredibly subjective thing. While Trump may see the expedited removal of undocumented immigrants and the restriction of social welfare benefits as constitutional solutions, they contradict the very principles the Constitution was built on. The early days of his presidency were vicious — executive orders were signed with a fervor astounding to anyone with a New York Times subscription (push notifications were coming in hourly). For Trump, these swift, unilateral actions set the tone for his rule, serving as actions representative of the direct approach to legislative inefficiency he advertised throughout his campaign. However, the unchecked use of executive orders to circumvent Congress and the judiciary poses a direct threat to the separation of powers that anchors the American political system.

One of the most infamous early policies was the 2017 “Muslim Ban” — an executive order that banned foreign nationals from seven predominantly Islamic countries from visiting the country for 90 days, suspended entry to the country of all Syrian refugees indefinitely, and prohibited any other refugees from coming into the country for 120 days  — appeared as a major policy accomplishment for the first iteration of the MAGA immigration mandate. Eight years later, it is getting revamped — the same ban, now in a trench coat. Of course, legal efforts are being undertaken to prevent the ideological demolition of fair immigration law. Reps. Judy Chu (CA-28), Don Beyer (VA-08),  Jerry Nadler (NY-12), Ilhan Omar (MN-05), André Carson (IN-07), Rashida Tlaib (MI-12), and Sen. Chris Coons (DE) reintroduced the National Origin-Based Antidiscrimination for Nonimmigrants (NO BAN) Act, which would prevent future bans by the Trump administration on people of Islamic faith, or any other religious group, by strengthening the Immigration and Nationality Act to prohibit discrimination based on religion. The bill would also require that any suspension of entry into the United States be narrowly tailored, backed by credible evidence, and subject to appropriate consultation with Congress. “Trump’s ‘Muslim Bans’ have always been a betrayal of the ideals and values that inspired America’s Founders. Donald Trump’s use of racial and religious prejudice to bar people from entering the country does not make anyone safer, all it achieves is further divisions in our society and the weakening of U.S. leadership on freedom and liberty abroad,” said Rep. Beyer in a press release introducing the bill. “Our NO BAN Act would make clear that neither racism nor religious intolerance are acceptable barriers to lawful immigration, and I urge my colleagues to reaffirm America’s stance against bigotry and religious discrimination.” 

Trump’s executive orders on immigration extend far beyond the “Muslim Ban.” His administration has implemented policies such as the expansion of expedited removal, which allows for the deportation of undocumented immigrants without a hearing before an immigration judge. Additionally, the Remain in Mexico policy (Migrant Protection Protocols) forced asylum seekers to wait in dangerous conditions outside U.S. borders, undermining their fundamental right to seek asylum. Family separation at the border, a direct result of the administration’s “zero tolerance” policy, inflicted trauma on thousands of children, demonstrating the administration’s willingness to enforce immigration policy at any cost. 

America no longer has a formal stance against bigotry and discrimination. The subtle evil of Trump’s executive orders lies in their framing: he subverts their fanatical nature with sheer mass and speed. At their core, they are the political equivalent of hitting every single U.S. voter over the head with a spiked club. There will be no second guesses. There will be no follow-ups because everyone is too dazed and confused by the impact to question whether the violence was necessary or effective in the first place. The influence of immediate judicial pushback – the issuance of injunctions by federal courts across the country – is the single widespread response with the capacity to immediately call into question the validity of Trump’s orders. We will undoubtedly continue to observe legal initiatives similar to the NO BAN Act as floods of executive orders deposit themselves on our lock screens. This resistance, unfortunately, is far from terminal. It has been less a deterrent than an inconvenience, allowing the president to press forward with an agenda that, rather successfully, undermines various constitutional protections. The legal battles over the “Muslim Ban” culminated in a landmark ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court in June 2018, which upheld the policy largely in its original form. While the lengthy judicial process led to various modifications to its scope and magnitude, the ban’s core elements remained intact. 

The framing of these policies reveals their true insidious nature: they are often disguised as necessary security measures or administrative streamlining when in reality, they function as tools of exclusion and fear. The swift enactment of these orders leaves little room for public discourse or legislative oversight, forcing the courts to serve as the last line of defense. While judicial pushback has resulted in temporary injunctions and partial reversals, the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold the “Muslim Ban” set a dangerous precedent for executive power over immigration. 

Despite legal resistance, Trump’s immigration policies have largely succeeded in reshaping the landscape of U.S. immigration law, reinforcing the notion that executive fiat can override constitutional protections and congressional authority. As the flood of executive orders continues, so too does the need for legislative intervention. The NO BAN Act and similar initiatives serve as crucial countermeasures, but the battle over immigration justice is far from over. Without structural reforms to limit the unchecked power of executive orders in this realm, the constitutional principles that govern America’s immigration system will remain under siege.

Leave a Reply

Trending